Your tips and advice for feeling good things in life more and not wasting it

I don’t know if I have anhedonia, but I’m someone who just doesn’t feel much about the good things in life. It’s like I’m only ever able to scratch the surface of things that ought to make one happy.

It’s not a lack of gratitude; indeed, I consciously remind myself that I’ve got a good life that the majority of people in the world don’t have, or past eras would have loved to have. Objectively, I recognize that even with low-to-middling income, having a 1-bed-1-bath apartment with all kinds of modern appliances, being debt-free, having a retirement portfolio, dual citizenship, most of my life spent in the United States, having rich parents and siblings, never experiencing danger, a remote work-from-home job, extensive travel to many places in the world - all of that stuff is stuff that I intellectually know many would envy. I’m not rich, but I’m not poor. So it’s not ingratitude, it’s just not sinking in.

Like, if my favorite NFL team won the Super Bowl (which I’ve never seen happen,) my reaction would probably be a “well, that’s good,” and then not register any or much more dopamine. That’s been much of the story of my life - having lots of good things that other people would envy, but it it just not triggering any sort of pleasure in me. It’s not greed, like, “I live in a 630-square foot small apartment but if I lived in a 9,000-square foot mansion then I’d be happy!” - not at all. It’s just that I seem to have a really ‘flat-line’ brain.

I don’t like being this way, because it feels like I’m wasting things. After all, the point of things is to enjoy them, and if some person in a worse off situation than I would love to have the things I have, but I don’t get much kick out of my things, then it’s a waste. So, any tips or tricks on how to make oneself maximize or enjoy more what one has? Lecturing myself about how other people are worse off doesn’t seem to do it.

Have you considered seeing a therapist? They might be able to help.

Is the point of things to enjoy them? Let’s question that.

I understand anhedonia; I have it in the afternoons, but I had severe depression in the past so I haven’t considered it a real problem. But it is admittedly frustrating at times. Like when I just sit down after a hard day’s work to enjoy some restful thing, and…I can’t really enjoy it. Sucks.

Anyway. I can’t believe your appliances are what you value most in life. Whatever that thing is that you do value, how can you get more of it?

It’s not about pleasure in the hedonistic sense, but satisfaction. And that comes, in my experience, from actively working on things you care about, succeeding at hard things, making strong social connections, and a lot of stuff that doesn’t seem, at first blush, like much fun. It’s the stuff that forces you to engage and overcome challenges that really gets the blood flowing. Find more of that.

That’s the thing I’m really grateful for in my life, that even when it was very difficult, it was still very meaningful. Right now my life, which isn’t particularly easy (at least not for me) is overflowing with meaning. It’s in my work and my family, my writing, and especially my parenting. All things that require daily concerted effort, and may not be particularly pleasurable in the moment. Parenting is unique among those for me because I have no choice but to show up and do the work. It’s basically forcing me to generate my own meaning.

What I learned recovering from severe depression is that happiness is something you do, consistently, day after day, over time. Actually, I think it’s many things you do. Finding what those things are is different for every person. And it can be different things at different times.

I guess I’m just saying I’m not surprised that superficial things like nice appliances are not moving the needle on your personal happiness.

Day after day it is drummed into us that runaway climate change, overpopulation, nuclear war, a large asteroid, or AI is going to destroy human civilization. It is a constant theme in social media and the movies. That alone makes it hard to feel happy and at peace but, as if we need more, we have our own personal travails to deal with as well. This requires a real effort on our part to tune out what could happen from what is happening on a day to day basis in life, but that effort is required to get ourselves out of that kind of negative mindset.

“I could go down to the cliff and look at the sea like a good tourist. But it’s no good if there isn’t somebody you can turn to and say, ‘Nice view there.’ It’s the same with the churches, the relics, the moonlight or a Cuba Libre. Nothing in the world is any good unless you can share it.” – Out of the Past (1947)

I have a dire life expectancy.

But we do have a decent life. My kids are in the house or right close. Grandkids are present in my life everyday.

But I’m alone in my head a good bit of the time. Speech difficulties.

But I paint a smile on my face and look for little tiny things that make me happy.

Fake it til you make it is my motto.:smiling_face:

I disagree. The point of things is to serve a purpose. For most things that purpose can be utilitarian. But for others, the purpose is to facilitate an experience and I have found that joy is found in experiences and not things. For example, I have a sailboat. Owning a sailboat and being able to use it gives me some pleasure, but no real satisfaction. The joy comes from sailing my sailboat. Lasting joy comes from the memories of those experiences. I think the same can be said about art, music, thrill-seeking, or anything else we choose to do that creates experiences. I can’t thing of a single object which can give pleasure and enjoyment by its mere presence.

That’s pretty much what’s supposed to happen. But I’d bet if you were at the game and experienced it in person it would move the needle a bit more than watching it on TV. Likewise if you were with other people you could share the experience with. It’s not the result of the game that gives you joy, it’s the experience you have and whom you share it with.

I don’t think you have to blame yourself (much less lecture) for having a life where your basic needs are met, plus a little more. Everybody deserves that. But material satisfaction isn’t the same thing as happiness or contentment; many people who “have it all” still aren’t happy, and many people trying to find their way out of poverty still manage to feel joy. It is a casualty of our peculiar American mindset that we believe success = happiness.

Your post focused on what you have. But what do you like? You mentioned the NFL, so presumably you like sports? Do you just watch them or play anything? Do you have friends over for that? Does it feel any different when you share experiences with them, or a romantic partner, or siblings, or whatever? What else do you do in your spare time, or when you travel… and among those activities, does any part stand out more than the others?

I think it’s good to have gratitude and awareness of your privilege, but that’s only one of the paths to contentment, and even then, it takes an emotional — maybe almost spiritual — journey to get there. It’s much harder to just intellectually rationalize your way into joy or contentment.

Once again, I think Spice_Weasel said it best:

You can’t just fill your life with stuff — physical or otherwise, i.e. empty hedonistic experiences — and expect to come out a happier person at the other end. To repeat a tired truism, happiness for most people requires a mix of:

  • Something (meaningful) to do
  • Something to look forward to
  • Somebody to love

Material comfort can ease those quests, but isn’t by itself sufficient to fulfill them.

I don’t know you, I don’t know your interests or hobbies, your friends, your religious beliefs, your age range, your lifestyle, your values, any of that… but generally speaking, if what you’re doing right now isn’t working, why not try something new?

It could be therapy. It could be medication. Maybe a new activity. Mindfulness and meditation. More exercise, better nutrition. Yoga. Sex. Friendships. Partners. A challenging new skill. A difficult relationship you never quite fixed.

It’s different for everyone, and we don’t know you, but it’s worth exploring until you find something that fits better. It doesn’t have to be perfect, just interesting enough to dive into for a few weeks or months. Do that again and again until you find something that speaks to you, then build on it. And when it no longer does, try something else.

One anecdote I’ll share, as someone who also suffered from severe depression in the past: Sitting there thinking about it all in your head never changes anything for the better. A psychiatrist once told me I was “over-intellectualized”. At the time, I thought to myself, “Huh? Does that mean I’m smart? Isn’t that a good thing, and how could there be too much of it?” I’m sure Dopers can relate.

But turns out… as much as I could accurately analyze my circumstances and the world at large, and describe it all with perfect lucidness and out-argue anybody who might try to convince me otherwise… well, it did all of jack squat for my emotional well-being. It’s not enough to merely know something; actually feeling it requires going through the motions and converting imagined thought into lived experience, with all the senses active and engaged. You have to smell the rain, feel the heartbreak, ride the adrenaline rush.

For me, what eventually turned things around (after a few years of unsuccessful therapy and medication) was deciding to completely change my life and trying a different lifestyle altogether, copying some of the people most unlike me. I took on climbing, running, yoga, reading, swimming, singing, guitar, a new college major, gardening, new friend groups… even went to a UU congregation and joined a druidry & witches meetup for a quick second… most of that didn’t stick. But a few did, and became life-long interests, or at least practices I greatly respect.

Yoga, in particular, was kind of a life changer for me, as the child of two engineer immigrants, raised purely on intellectualism and the pursuit of material wealth. To go from giant spreadsheets to a candle-lit studio, listening to chants and self-help mantras while stretching and sweating with a bunch of heart-centered women… was quite the wake-up call about how different life could be. I went back to it, month after month, and forced myself to work through both the physical discomfort (it was hot and I was inflexible) and the emotional and mental barriers (I didn’t buy a lot of their philosophies, I didn’t think and feel the way they did). It taught me a lot about myself that I never even considered before, about how emotionally closed off I had been most of my life. It also taught me a lot about other people and their own struggles; some of the people who looked happiest and most “with it” on the surface were raging alcoholics underneath. But most of all, it taught me that we really don’t have a monopoly on “happiness philosophy”, and that different people and cultures will have radically different approaches for answering the question of what makes life worthwhile.

Yoga might not do anything for you at all. It doesn’t for a lot of people.

But the point is keep trying different things, to force yourself out of your comfort zone again and again and again. It’s how you grow, it’s how you build meaning, it’s how you build genuine connections.

Your life is maybe too comfortable. Challenge yourself and see what comes of it?

I didn’t read all the replies.

For me, I seek contentment far more than I seek happiness.

While the terms are often bandied about somewhat interchangeably, I think they’re substantively different.

If you’re interested in the difference, it might be worth doing a bit of searching online.

You’re sitting right at the edge of contentment. All you need to do to step over it is let go of the sense that you’re doing it wrong. But, if you can’t seem to let this go, one solution does seem to leap off the page here:

For what you’ve articulated above, why not give time or money to causes that you care about? That ought to dispel the sense of waste, shouldn’t it? If it doesn’t, then you know it’s really not about what that stuff could do for others. If you can’t bring yourself to do it, then that’s another useful answer: it’s actually not waste, it’s doing something for you that you’re not acknowledging.

I used to have similar feelings about my emergency cash savings account. It’s more than most people would keep, quite a bit more. I felt it was wasted. I invested it in stocks, and started watching it careen up and down for a time. After experiencing some anxiety around this, I realized the “wasted” cash was doing the job of making me feel as secure as I need to feel. Sure, I could unpack my anxieties as to exactly why I need more for this purpose than others, or get a little more sophisticated with investing, but I choose not to, except for looking for safe instruments that are a slight improvement over cash. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

Do you think you may have clinical depression? Its hard to tell where depression ends and a low pleasure response begins. I know I tried for years to make myself grateful for what I had and it never worked, but once I got my depression treated the gratitude just came naturally. I feel like its a cart before the horse thing for some people.

That’s not to invalidate your experiences as being due to a mental illness rather than being aware of legitimate problems (fascism, climate change, plutocracy, etc) but its something to consider.

From a neuroscience perspective I think a big part of anhedonia is a lack of dopamine signaling in the ventral tegmental area. Dopamine agonists or reuptake inhibitors are used to try to treat this.

However FWIW I think when people abuse stimulants like meth and then become sober, they have long term anhedonia because the dopamine receptors in the VTA are all down regulated.

This is very off-the-wall, but: what are your physical exercise levels like? Physical exertion (at the sweat-and-get-exhausted level) is well known to not only increase dopamine release as a direct result of the exercise, but also stimulate the brain’s dopaminergic pathways (?? it seems to mean making it easier for you to get that dopamine release in other situations too).

Intellectually, we think we like comfort and safety and pleasure (and of course there are many good reasons to). But what our physical brain really seems to like most is overcoming effort and suffering. I don’t know why this is.

Thanks everyone for the replies. As for my exercise, yeah, I’m a couch potato. I do try to make myself walk a few thousand more steps each day/night if I can (I can’t really do jogging or anything running related because of a mild spine injury,) I’m not sure about depression but I do know I’ve had chronic sleep deprivation for a decade, and sleep apnea. I did have to use stimulants like Adderall for my ADHD but, like Wesley Clark said, I quit quickly because of the risk of dopamine receptors being worsened.

The issue I have is, if there’s something exciting that I’m going to be able to do, I start immediately fretting that it will be over too soon. Even with holidays - I love Christmas and I love decorating for Christmas. But as I’m putting the decorations up, I’m already thinking of how fast the season will go. I need to just enjoy the moment.

This reminds me of a conversation I had years ago with a dear friend of mine. He called himself a romantic, but I didn’t exactly see him that way, so I asked him to give me his definition of a romantic. He said to him a romantic is “Someone who seeks ideal states.” And I replied, “You can’t have ideal states, but you can have ideal moments that you collect like beads on a string.”

That’s a very Blade Runner-esque way to look at it :slight_smile: https://youtu.be/HU7Ga7qTLDU?si=tHO8h66De78tm_md&t=56

I have found that when I create things, it gives me a lift. I am not a painter, nor do I write music or poetry. But I am good with tools. I built a ramp from my deck to the grass for my arthritic dog to use. I modified my coffee table so it can be raised up to eat or lowered to rest my feet. When I look at these things I did (or better yet, have someone tell me “that’s really cool”), it raises my mood.

What do you all think of pop sci answers to this, like Maslow's hierarchy of needs - Wikipedia ?

Shortly after graduating college, I went to Mexico to practice my Spanish, do some volunteer work, and see what I could see.

I stayed with a nice couple, both of whom were medical doctors. One day I’m sitting there just being myself and the woman looks at me and says, “Piensas demasiado.” (You think too much.)

I’d been told that by many people but finding out it’s obvious even to people who don’t speak my primary language left an impression.

Many people think of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy in the classic 90s way still, you know, where you trot out your irrational thoughts, identify the cognitive errors and write a new script. That’s not, to my understanding, the direction modern-day CBT is heading. A lot of the research is pointing to something called metacognitive therapy, which is essentially teaching people not to argue with their negative thoughts, but to stop engaging with their thoughts altogether. It turns out just don’t think about it is pretty good advice.

Wow. That’s very interesting, as that was his favorite movie. (My friend died in 2018.)


I don’t think of Maslow as “pop sci”…
:face_with_monocle: