'08 Fantasy Electoral College Game

I’m still rooting for ataraxy22 to win. (I think he/she picked the most favorable EV outcome for Obama in this thread.)

GO ataraxy22!!!

Well, no, actually.

AHunter3 for the win (I hope)! wooooooo! GO!

:smiley:

(Sorry; on skimming through the thread, I misread yours.)

(in all fairness, there is ANOTHER such thread and in that one someone else also said over 400… I’ll see if I can find it…)

Did find it, but too late for the edit window.

Fish says 410.

Sort of. Those numbers represent the expected value of each candidate’s probability of winning the individual states. They say that the single most likely outcome is 311-228, followed in short order by 353-170, 364-159, and 338-185. According to the site projections, one of those four vote totals will be correct a little more than one time out of three.

It looks now that my 390 may have been just a wee bit too optimistic. Oh well. I’ll take it as it is!!!

Updated my predictions earlier today here.

My original prediction in this thread was off, but for my new one, I’m batting 100% so far. NV will go to Obama, MT, AK, MO to McCain. IN and NC look like tossups, and I could miss there. Hope not, though. Landslide plz.

Dude, we all won. Don’t think it will end up at 400, but you done fine.

My ‘hail mary’ optimistic prediction, which I said I would stand by, did not prevail.

I am therefore out of the running.

But I’d like to point out that my initial more conservative prediction of 378 is still viable. At the moment Missouri is trying to be the spoiler. Missouri would cost me 11 and drag me down to 367. I think NC and IN are on track to deliver, and while it is still relatively early returns MT looks good too.

Revised prediction 367, with hopes for 378.

Well, I missed the EC count, but my popular vote guess was pretty good. I’ll take it. :smiley:


	                    ** Obama	McCain	     Popular**
AHunter3	              400	   138	      57-40
atarxy22	              390	   148	      55-43
borschevsky	              388	   150	      53-45
Figgle Pighead	              381	   157	      52-46
Chronos	                      379	   159	      56.2-42.4
hawthorne	              379	   159	      52.8-44.6
BobLibDem	              378	   160	      58-40
Lakai	                      375	   163	      57-41
Lawn Gnome!	              375	   163	      55-43
garygnu	                      375	   163	      54-44
MentalGuy	              375	   163	      52-46
Raygun99	              371	   167	      52-46
Kid_A	                      368	   170	      53-46
Marley23	              364	   174	      53-45
Captain Lance Murdoch	      364	   174	      52-46
Hawkeyeop	              364	   174	      52-45
Knorf	                      364	   174	      52-45
Unix Geek	              353	   185	      52.2-46.4
peekercpa	              351	   187	      52-46
**El_Kabong	              349	   189	      51-48**
zamboniracer	              348	   190	      52-47
atomicbadgerrace	      340	   198	      51-46
bibliophage	              339	   199	      51-48
Onomatopoeia	              338	   200	      52-46
Diogenes the Cynic	      337	   201	      51-48
jsgoddess	              327	   211	      52-46.5
Cyberhwk	              323	   215	      53-47
Wilson	                      320	   218	      51-48
threeorange	              318	   220	      50.4-48.2
The Tof	                      311	   227	      52-47
ShibbOleth	              311	   227	      51-48
kunilou	                      311	   227	      50-47
Pleonast	              306	   232	      53-45
RickJay	                      306	   232	      51-47
want2know	              304	   234	      53-46
Captain Amazing	              301	   237	      52-48
Jack Batty	              295	   243	      51-48
MsWhatsit	              293	   245	      51-49
Elendil's Heir	              290	   248	      49-47
jsc1953	                      279	   259	      52-48
Happy Lendervedder	      273  	   265	      50-49
Kevja	                      272	   266	      50.5-49.5
glee	                      269	   269	      52-48


This puts the current lead somewhere near El_Kabong, but I expect, from what I’ve been able to read, that this will shift more toward the top of our chart.

Note that I’ve input all of this manually, based on the last post you had before the deadline. Please let me know if I’ve got your numbers wrong.

My prediction (which, I’m glad to say, was unduly pessimistic) is accurately reflected in your table, thanks.

Here’s to the President-elect!

Hmm, I’m on pins and needles. 24 hours after the election and NC shows a slight edge for Obama, MO for McCain, but neither has been called yet. If it stays the same, looks like Captain Lance Murdoch will win, based on the tiebreaker.

Looks as if the final Electoral College split will end at 364-173. Four Dopers had that part right.

Marley23 364 174 53-45
Captain Lance Murdoch 364 174 52-46
Hawkeyeop 364 174 52-45
Knorf 364 174 52-45

Now just waiting on a final popular vote split, then might have to go to the second tie breaker. Or not. Either way, very good call from all four of you.

Yes indeedy. N.C. has been called by the AP and CNN for Obama; Missouri is still leaning McCain but nothing certain yet.

Looks like Obama might take Omaha, inching the EC up to 365 in the process. Sure wish that they’d finish up with Missouri.

In my local election, there was a bit of a fun recount. The Supervisor of Elections race was a virtual tie, with the incumbent Buddy Johnson up by just a bit. But there were a lot of problems with the local election, including an inability to upload data from all of the optical scanners. So they had to re-feed the scan sheets into new scanners. The challenger just barely won once they were able to work out the kinks in the voting system. FWIW I voted against the incumbent, not because he’s a bad guy (I don’t think that he is) but because we seemed burdened with long lines and a bit of incompetence. Plus, I later learned, he took the bid on the new equipment, from Diebold, which no longer operates under that name, even though they were not the low bidder. And they contribute heavily to the RNC. And their equipment doesn’t work properly. Hope the new SoE does a better job.