Ma Kent is a farm girl and has those farm girl muscles, but Aunt May grew up on the mean streets of Queens and will be better versed in dirty tricks. Still, I have to give the edge to Ma Kent. Anyone who can tell Superman and Supergirl to eat their vegetables or no dessert wins.
Saturday morning TV versions:
Isis versus Captain Marvel?
The General may have actual powers but Cap has taken down your standard brick before without too much trouble. I never got the impression that General Glory was highly skilled so I have to go with Cap.
Creator fight (sticking to comic creators written in by other creators): Jack Kirby (Waid used him in Fantastic Four), Jim Shooter (Byrne dropped him into Starbrand), Richard Pini (Isabella in Ghost Rider), and Grant Morrison (Ostrander used him in Suicide Squad).
Kirby in a landslide. In one of his most memorable comic book appearances, he was the Thing (in a “What If…?” story.) But mainly, cuz he’s cooler than Shooter, Pini & Morrison all together.
TV time: Catwoman (Eartha Kitt) vs. Catwoman (Halle Berry);
Catwoman (Julie Newmar) vs. Catwoman (Michelle Pfeiffer);
Catwoman (Lee Merriwether) vs. Catwoman (animated version voiced by Adrienne Barbeau)
Much more lopsided. Modern Superman isn’t vulnerable to magic, it just affects him like anyone else. Superboy-Prime is vulnerable to magic; one mjolner hit and he’s pulped.
Not including a new match with Catwomen still out there.
Another one where everyone wins, but that’s probably not the answer you want.
Catwoman Bracket 1 Kitt vs. Berry: Eartha beats Berry down no question. Eartha Kitt looks like she’d fight dirty. Berry looks like she’d be worried about breaking a nail.
Bracket 2 Newmar vs Pfeiffer: Pfeiffer wins. Her Catwoman was crazy and crazy always wins.
Bracket 3 Merriwether vs. Animated Barbeau: Never bet against a toon.
I’m on an Ennis kick, so we’ll go with an absolutely no holds barred super team brawl. The Boys vs. The Crime Syndicate.
Deathstroke came very close to taking out the Flash, Hawkman, Green Arrow, Black Canary, the Atom, Elongated Man, and the Green Lantern in less than three pages. Karate Kid doesn’t stand a chance.
Madcap vs. Madman
I might have missed the bit where they made him invulnerable to magic, but I was treating him as a pre-Crisis Kryptonian and they are extremely vulnerable to magic.
I was this close to writing out this sequence in Clairmontian dialog but good taste overcame that urge.
After wasting several pages of shooting each other and reminding each other that their powers don’t effect each other, Cyclops pushes Havok to the ground while commenting on their relationship. Then they hug and the whole thing (including the massive collateral damage) is immediately forgotten. Technically a win for Cyclops.
With great power comes an inconsistant, confusing, and very common weakness: The population of Daxam vs. the population of Mars (or where ever the white martians hide out).
The pre-crisis vulnerability to magic was never depicted as a vulnerability to magically derived strength (see the All Star Squadron issue where Supes fights Captain Marvel because of the Spear of Destiny for a good example). So I wouldn’t expect it to work that way for SBP. Mjolner, OTOH, is a magical weapon and those were depicted as causing injury pre-Crisis Kryptonians.