So, I’m watching the Muppet Show Season 1 with the “special features” turned on. In the Rita Moreno episode, it is mentioned that she is the first actor to win all four major entertainment awards (I already knew this). By saying she’s the first, this leads me to believe that someone else has done this.
I didn’t say it doesn’t count. I merely point out that while her Oscar, Tony and Emmy awards were all in major categories and were all given for individual performances that Ms. Moreno gave, her Grammy was in a minor category most people aren’t aware of, and it was shared by a large number of people.
That is true, but the award IS in a category given every year, and those awards go to groups all the time.
Ms. Streisand’s only Tony was for “Star of the Decade,” which I believe was a special “non-competitive” award given just to her and never before or since. Ms. Minelli’s only Grammy was a “special merit award” from the Recording Academy Association, which is the same group that names the Grammys.
In other words, I think if any of them should be “less qualified” than the others, I’d say it’s those two, simply by virtue of one-fourth of the honor being arrived at non-traditionally or “through a loophole.”