Alberta, Natural Resources, and the Rest of Canada

Looking at the Ballot measures, most of which are looking to pass, does Alberta stand a chance of making the changes to the Canadian Constitution called for in questions 6 through 9? My understanding is that 7 provinces, representing at least 50% of the Canadian population, need to agree to the changes. That is addition to getting through the Senate and House of Commons. The 50% rule means that they need either Ontario or Quebec to sign onto the changes.

There is no stomach to opening up the constitution. The failure to amend it through the Meech Lake and Chalottetown Accords almost broke our country and lead to a near successful Quebec referendum in 1995.

In general, federal politicians govern as if the Accords were successfully passed. No federal politician wants to recreate the constitutional crisis that reopening it will lead to. UNLESS they are 200% certain everything will pass.

Of course, we are suffering through a wave of chaotic conservative provincial premiers. Smith bring just one who has no problem with throwing the entire country into crisis if it plays to her dysfunctional populist base.

There were ten questions on the ballot. A majority of Albertans favour tighter restrictions on voting, social services, etc. as this giftlink identifies.

Many of the questions are sort of non questions. Only citizens can vote NOW.

The questions were written to support an impression of greater sovereignity. The fact that they probably don’t make too much difference was never the main point. At least none of the questions were about delicious barbecue, ice hockey, or the merits of HP sauce…

This right here. While the Canadian constitution can be amended, it is a long and tricky process, and seeing Meech Lake and Charlottetown fail has made a lot of Canadians shy about trying to change it again. “It ain’t broke, ain’t no need to fix it” is the overwhelming attitude.

The constitutional questions on the Alberta referendum were ridiculous. They all depended on the cooperation of other provinces, especially Ontario and Quebec. But I doubt that would happen. “Hey Ontario! Bonjour Quebec! How’d you like to give up all those cushy Senate seats, so you have no additional say in government, just so Alberta feels better about itself?” I’m pretty sure I know what the reply would be, and it wouldn’t be something you could repeat to your grandmother.

I do think that some discussion on Alberta’s constitutional questions is warranted, and if those discussions lead to a constitutional convention, well, so be it. But there are better ways to instigate such a conversation than Danielle Smith leading Albertans to believe that they can drag Canada and its provinces around by the nose with her referendum questions.

I like today’s Guardian’s take on the process.

Excerpt:
“The early result – roughly 75% against 25% – looks emphatic. For all the separatists’ talk of “success”, Albertans did not buy their tactical argument: that voting for a future referendum would strengthen the province’s hand against Ottawa. However, the sense of alienation in the province is profound: polls show that Albertans think most of the country does not respect the region.”

“Addressing that alienation has come at a worrying cost, both politically and environmentally. Mr Carney, who was raised in Alberta’s capital, Edmonton, made a series of pacts with the province’s premier, Danielle Smith. He agreed to back a new 1m-barrel-a-day oil pipeline and tear up environmental rules. Mr Carney has to deliver tangible gains, or else the sizable faction that supports separatism within Ms Smith’s United Conservative party will entrench itself and look for future opportunities to act.”

“Whatever replaces the “Let Alberta decide” movement will have an uphill struggle. In his book The Republic of Alberta, the journalist Tyler Dawson wrote that it has “no charismatic leader like René Lévesque, the suave, smoke-wreathed Quebec separatist who took his province to its 1980 secession referendum. There is no culturally entrenched canon of nationalist literature to fill Alberta bookshelves. The province has no unique language or race or faith that binds its residents together.” Yet victory this month for the Lévesque-founded Parti Québécois in provincial elections reveals that separatists can win power despite their raison d’etre being unpopular.”

“To those who witnessed the Brexit referendum, the Albertan poll offered a depressing rerun of nationalist gripes and political fantasy. The easy assurance that sovereignty can be recovered painlessly is wearily familiar.”

If the question was your question I’m assuming you would so blithely accept Alberta elections actions and decisions in this matter?

What I was asserting is that making any decisions with any eye to managing the CTs that choice may spawn is a fool’s errand.

CTs will sprout profusely no matter what decision anyone makes. So decisionmakers should just ignore all that noise.

I meant no more & no less.

And the point I’m making is that Alberta elections could have made it solely a CT that had no foundation.
Now it has a foundation. Do you deny that? Would you accept that your side in a question had no representative even when allowed by law to have one when all parties in the other side not only control the law, set the rules, and benefit if their side wins?

The separatists campaigned on the CT that the Canadan government and China are colluding to remove Alberta’s control of its resources and Pfizer made fraudulent claims about the safety of COVID vaccines.

This is a movement of CT nutters. Led by CT nutters. Supported by CT nutters. Funded by CT nutters. Using nothing but CT nutter logic. A big tent of CT nuttery.

There is literally nothing anyone can do to stop the CT nuts. Literally nothing. That the nature of CT nuts.

And here is a prime example of a CT. Just one of many supplied by the stay side.

My issue with the left has always been their infinite capacity to point out the other fellow’s flaws while excusing their own.

Do you understand what a CT is? It is a pattern of thinking where the absence of evidence of something is evidence of that exact something.

That is why it is impossible to prevent CT-ers from CT-ing.

One separatist leader, Jeffery Rath, says that Carney is colluding with China against Alberta all the time. That Liberal MPs get China’s help to get elected. That “globalists” control everything. Legitimately insane and wild stuff.

All the separatist leaders like Mitch Sylvestre founder of Alberta Prosperity Project, David Parker founder of Take Back Alberta, have CT steeped in EVERYTHING they say or do. Just watch an interview with them. The least connected with CT might be Keith Wilson of Let Alberta Decide who legally represented the tucker convoy people so he is connected to the CT nutters but is careful not to go off shouting the wildest and craziest things in interviews.

Except when they have a foundation in truth. Would you have a different take if it were liberals being targeted?

Rath can rant about anything “Liberals are in bed with communist China who got +11 Liberal MPs elected to control Alberta…” and you’d come back with “Oh. There’s a foundation of truth and logic there”

No. If we discuss Chinese foreign interference in Canada, we do it with an allegiance to the truth. Not “truth-ish”. Every single “9/11 inside job, steel beams, etc.” is based on SOME thin original fact/truth. Its the added horseshit that makes it a CT.

These Alberta separatists are all people who came into prominence during lockdown due to their covid conspiracies. They now fully sustain themselves on weaving grander and grander tales of Canadian government collusion and persecution.

I have no interest in giving any of these people any credit for branching off one of their CTs from well documented attempts of Chinese interference opposed to something completely left field batshit like aliens.

Again, would you have a different take if it were liberals being targeted?

I figure anything anyone says who doesn’t agree with your position is going to be categorized as a nutter regardless of their concerns or validity. I’ve posted clear evidence that there was outside influence in the Canadian elections and that essentially nothing was done about it. Yet, it is the people in Alberta who are the traitors and conspiracy nuts, not those MP’s who are still sitting in parliament now that may have been compromised. You claim to hear ‘grander and grander tales’ from them and I hear ‘acceptance of the status quo and the emperor’s new clothes are beautiful’ from the left.

The good thing is that the ~25% or a half million people, gained through a grass roots campaign, who voted to leave is a solid foundation to move forward with.

“voted to leave”??? That’s not what the question was. Option 2 was clear, it was to hold another referendum (which would be about Alberta starting a negotiation with Canada to leave).

The separatists themselves knew they couldn’t sell “leave” to the public (except to the most hardened of Christian far-righters and CTs). They campaigned it as “sending a message to Canada” to “not worry this is just leverage”.

Let’s be honest about that 25% and what it is. Albertans rejected even the most tepid of steps in the process of separation. That’s what happens when a fringe special interest group hijacks a teetering but governing party with their own agenda.

Separatists can’t honestly win at the ballot with a party that campaigns for a separatist referendum. So they then they hijack governance from a dying and desperate party to rig things to get a referendum… then they find out that they lose (75% to 25%)!

Final step, not care. A loss is still a win. Nothing really matters. Everything is a win.