Is it actually possible for Alberta separatists to understand that patriotism and support for Canadian unity is not a partisan position? It’s a position of loyalty to one’s country and its history and traditions and faith in its future, and it transcends all politics.
Yes. No one that I know of has denied it. People who want to separate from Canada want to do it because they think they can do better without being tied to the boat anchor that Canada now is. No one hopes that Canada doesn’t succeed. No one wants the third world next door.
And again, since you’re impervious to this statement but others might not be, Alberta does not send money to anyone. Federal revenue is from tax payers not provinces. For giggles here’s the provincial breakdown by tax bracket. I continue to be impressed how no one gives Manitoba a hard time.
And keep in mind health transfer sit outside equalization payments, and can be augmented by bi-lateral agreements with the federal government. Furthermore, the per capita formula includes permanent residents, international students, and non-permanent residents in its formulation. Residents the current provincial government asked for and now would like to scapegoat.
| Province or Territory | <$55,867 | $55,867 to $111,733$55,867 | $111,733 to $173,205$111,73 | $173,205 to $246,752$173,205 | >=$246,752 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Newfoundland and Labrador | 69% | 23% | 5.3% | 1.4% | 0.9% |
| NB/NS/PEI | 69% | 25% | 4.2% | 1.0% | 0.8% |
| Quebec | 65% | 27% | 5.0% | 1.2% | 1.1% |
| Ontario | 63% | 26% | 6.9% | 2.0% | 1.7% |
| Manitoba | 69% | 25% | 4.5% | 1.1% | 0.9% |
| Saskatchewan | 64% | 27% | 6.5% | 1.8% | 1.2% |
| Alberta | 61% | 27% | 7.6% | 2.7% | 2.1% |
| British Columbia | 62% | 27% | 7.0% | 2.2% | 1.8% |
| Canada | 64% | 27% | 6% | 2% | 2% |
No one is saying otherwise, or ever has been. Alberta is made up of Albertans who pay taxes. Those taxes pay for services, which Albertans (and Alberta) see less of for their money, and equalization payments that go to provinces that refuse to do the necessary work, or make the necessary decisions like Quebec developing its oil and gas fields, to improve their economies and not have to rely on those payments.
Now that that is laid to bed, can you stop pretending that people don’t know this and maybe acknowledge that latter concern?
No chuckles. You and your ilk continually misrepresent equalization.
Have I? Are you saying I just lied above? Is it a misrepresentation?
Moderating:
Remember, attack the post not each other.
These exchanges are getting too personalized.
Like the left keeps misrepresenting those who want independence. I’m pretty sure I don’t fit into any of the preconceived categories that has been applied to them.
Just as a factual matter, I might be on Uzi’s side on this.
Alberta has above-average median incomes in Canada. So because of graduated taxation, it almost has to been that average-income Albertans are doing the moral equivalent of sending money to places with lower incomes and/or more needs, some in Alberta, and some outside.
For another kind of example, it might cost Canada Post $25, or more, to deliver an ordinary letter between remote communities in Nunavut and Yukon. I have no problem admitting that letters sent from Calgary to Edmonton effectively subsidize that.
Would Albertans be able to give their children better lives if an independent Alberta was able to shake off such subsidies? No, for reasons given earlier in the thread. If I was a Canadian from Alberta, I think I’d be proud to support my country in such a way. But it seems to me quibbling to deny that there is a sort of subsidy.
Nor does anyone argue with your analysis. But the question is for how long? We have people in Alberta questioning why we aren’t spending more on healthcare, education, etc. Okay, I see an easy $20B that could be spent on it. When will this be freed up for use in the province where it was generated?
When the provinces receiving that money are not developing their resources and may be actively preventing us from developing ours why are we subsidizing their choice?
You want to put separatist issue to bed, then address these issues rather than calling people names because it concerns them.
I think the point is people pay income taxes directly to Canada, not Alberta. It was never Alberta’s money. “Moral equivalency” isn’t actually a thing in national income tax.
This is more ironic, since Alberta does not charge sales taxes and other provinces do.
It was Albertan’s money. The taxpayer. There is only one.
Jealousy? What is the point of the comment? Develop resources, don’t spend like drunken sailors, live within your means, create a positive investment economy, and you too can not have a sales tax.
No. It was a Canadian’s money. The national government is who charges that income tax, not Alberta.
Not sure of your point. Do you deny that some provinces get money from the federal government, benefiting specifically people who live within that province, while other provinces do not?
My point is what I said - people pay the income tax as Canadians, not Albertans. It’s Canada’s [1]money to do with what it wants, it in no sense is “stolen” from Alberta as it was never Alberta’s to begin with. If Alberta wants to do different things with its citizens’ money, it needs to charge them its own tax.
You can say “equalization payments”, I know what those are and I don’t deny they exist. What I do deny is that the money being spent is in any sense Alberta’s. It’s Canada’s money to spend as Canada decides.
There are provinces which don’t get federal money for health care and social programmes? News to me.
Must. Resist. Urge. To. Type. Canadia. ↩︎
If provinces want extra money for services they can tax their own citizens directly. Your words.
Yes federal government sends money directly for those specific purposes. It also conceptually sends a check to provinces essentially labeled ‘Equalization’. 2 payments per month. The province can spend it on whatever it wants to which is different than health care transfers. There is no requirement that they spend it on comparable services.
Some provinces get that ‘cheque’ others do not.
And if Canada wants to give money using whatever criteria it wants, it can use the money it gets from taxing its citizens. Hey, it already does that!
I already said i know what equalization payments are. No need to explain them to me.
I think they’re a great idea. In my country, poorer provinces get a lot of my tax money (proportionally) . Good for them!
Forever? I’ve already explained that Quebec could develop it’s resources and not have to receive payments. That would mean more for others who don’t have that capacity. I expect you’d be all for that?
What incentive, other than their good will, should we create for them to do that? How long should one group of taxpayers pay until the other group chooses to do the work, which they eminently can but have chosen not to, necessary to stop it?
If they’re always going to be poorer, sure.
It could. They prefer a cleaner environment for everyone, I take it. Good for them.
Unlimited resource development that ultimately affects even distant me? Not really, no.
Aah, I see, you think other provincials - Québécois for ex. - are lazy rather than just making different choices (IMO, the right ones) from Albertans?
They are, I believe, free to leave and find a country that aligns more with their beliefs. They just don’t get to take part of Canada with them.