I’m pretty sure you’re the one interpreting it as ‘lazy’.
If you choose to not develop a resource, then why should someone pay you for that choice? Why should you expect payment for that choice?
Alberta and Albertan’s could shut in all production tomorrow and become a ‘have not’ province.
Should I expect Quebec taxpayers to subsidize that choice? Of course not. Regardless, the practice of equalization will immediately stop in that scenario.
when the implication was that the work was necessary.
If you instead think the work isn’t necessary, I don’t understand what your objection is.
Because they agree that not developing it - not destroying the environment - is something worth paying for. “They” here being Canada as a whole. Québec not developing fossil fuel resources is good for Canada as a whole, because it somewhat offsets the otherwise appalling levels of emissions generated by the provinces that don’t.
Sure. And that would be great! Of course, many Albertans would probably leave for other places if they can’t work the sands.
They’d be hypocrites not to.
Given that the system has been in place since way before the Albertan oil boom, and has Constitutional support, I somehow doubt that. The formula might get adjusted again. Looks like last time that happened was a barrel of laughs!
You don’t see the hypocrisy of their position? They won’t develop their resource but take money from those that do.
Your position is that Alberta must pay the rest of Canada for allowing them to develop their resources?
And your wonder why Albertan’s are upset with this attitude?
It’d only be hypocrisy if they complain if Alberta stopped producing the emissions it does and hence paying as much as it does.
You say “develop their resources”, I say “inflict lasting damage on the environment”. Potato, no-potahto-because-AGW-killed-them-all, let’s call the whole thing off.
Do I wonder why some [1] Albertans are upset that they be held accountable for their chief industry being the major climate polluter in Canada? No, I don’t - it’s exactly what I’d expect given my views on overall human selfishness and venality. Doesn’t excuse them.
but clearly not all, given what the actual Alberta residents posting here have said ↩︎
As someone who was born, raised, and lived most of my life in the Maritimes… BC is stunningly beautiful. The Rocky mountains and the old growth forest blow my mind away every time I get to see them.
Been coast to coast (but not the third coast sadly), no place in Canada like the Rockies.
I have visited the Canadian Rockies, and that ties with parts of South Africa as the most beautiful places i have ever been. (Table mountain took my breath away. And so many weird plants!)
But Ontario is high on my list of where I’d live if i could live anywhere. In or near Toronto. There are jobs for people with my skills, participants in my hobbies, and it’s close enough to family to be easy to visit
No doubt so did the people of DuPont Canada while their product destroyed the ozone layer, or of Ontario Hydro while its sulphur-spewing coal plants were turning rain to acid.
“Positive economic contribution” is no longer sufficient cover for destroying the environment. Some Albertans are just really slow to catch on, apparently.