American Idol 3/4, 3/5, 3/6

I agree with Randy that she needs to work on her confidence. I was thinking Ramiele seems a little tentative even though she’s got one of the best voices in the competition.

She’s little, she’s cute, she chose a horribly over-done song that we’re all tired of hearing, and Ramiele can go on home now.

TMTH?

Oh, are they not doing that yet? No wonder the girls look like they pulled their outfits out of their suitcases.

Brooke cannot be doing this song, where’s the boobie-shaking whore parade?

Well now. I like Snow White tonight. First Amanda and now Snow White. It’s opposite day for me.

Snow White is such an annoying goody-two-shoes it makes me gag.

I would love it if someone put a sex tape of her on the internet.

Brooke’s “Love is a Battlefield” is great. I can almost NOT picture Pat Benatar with the angry chicks behind her having a dance-off with her pimp.

Oh my god, Randy just said Pauler choreographed that shitty dance in the video?!

Huh. I liked Brooke. I didn’t like her after her breakdown on Hollywood day, but I liked this and I liked last week.

I thought Brooke was very good. I don’t like that she’s a sniveler.

Oh, I liked your reference to the video better than mine.

Bitch. :smiley:

Sayesha(sp?), more highwaisted pants?? Come ON!

More Whitney?? Come ON!

It was better than Asia’h, but it’s still too risky to sing Whitney.

What is it, Whitney night? Shyesha even has the Whitney mic tap going on.

That wasn’t half bad, actually. Now let’s hear all the judges say she shouldn’t do Whitney.
Hey, the didn’t. Opposite night!

Why can’t they just ban all songs ever performed by Whitney or Celine? That said, I thought it was OK.

My vote:

Kady and Asia’h can go home. Or replace Asia’h with Amanda, out of pity because she seems to want to go.

I hate the mic-tap. Christina Aguiliera is the worst offender. I can’t focus on anyone’s performance when they mic-tap because it’s all I see.

Syesha is technically very good but she always seems so rehearsed and coached and self-conscious. I wonder if she’s a pagent kid or something. She’s always “on,” and it never seems like she’s showing her real personality.

Who should go: Kady and Kristy. Who will go? Hell, I dunno. People voted for Dubya twice and Hilary still hangs on-- so who knows what’s on this country’s mind.

Hah! I think it’s working on me subliminally. I’ve got this urge to go to H&M…

#1 Carly

#2 Ramiele

#3 Kady

I haven’t liked Syesha but she impressed me more tonight than earlier nights.
Kristy Lee and Brooke were OK.

Thank you, Nutty thank you! :smiley:

I was starting to like Brooke, she score big points with me doing “you’re so vain” but this was just wrong somehow. What the heck was with the bubblegum machine jewelry on her mic hand?

Syesha made good use of her moisturizer, she was shiny. Needs a better bra, however, and her hair confuses me. I like her, dunno why but I do.

Dio I’m so not seeing what you’re seeing. I can’t remember a single thing about Kady, and while I’m not a huge fan or wanna hang out with either of them, I could list at least four or five things about Kristy.

I like (for voice and/or personality)
Amanda
Carly
Syesha
Kristy
Brooke

I don’t care about
Asia’h
Ramiele
Kady