Ouch… bad singing and harsh judge comments… hopefully that doesn’t ‘rally’ his fans… eesh, I always hated that in previous seasons.
This performance definitely deserves a one-way plane ticket.
And what painful BS glurge in his human interest piece: “Scott is the heartbeat of America!.. I represent the people who get up and work eight hours a day.”
Simon and Randy say he sucked because, GUESS WHAT AUDIENCE, he did.
…
And to go back to A-Fed. Did Simon’s comments amount to “I don’t like you” to anybody else? A rough recap: “I hated that performance and that song. But you know how to sing to your target audience, and you did that excellently.”
The best Bo and A-Fed.
Worst-- Connie. No, Scott. . . no Connie. . . waitaminit Scott. . . O.K. there’s a sucky tie. One of the girls is going to be in the bottom, I think, but it won’t mean anything. I hope it’s Carrie. She’s never been there.
I see Ice Cube is a personal friend of Scott’s. Okay, I know, but it looked like Cube. Now I feel bad; that was a sad, feeling song Scott did. It had heart,but he couldn’t reach the high notes. Now I’m feeling sorry for him; I’m too soft.
Nobody was really good tonight. I guess Bo did the best by default but only because he’s incapable of truly sucking.
I think it might really be over for Scott…if not Scott, it’ll be A-Fed.
Carries never been on the bottom? :o
Vonzell is just terrific. I hope she wins.
Constantine can do sweet and silly and sexy. He CANNOT do angry. Very poor.
Scott was good for the first half of a safe, boring song. The second half was awful. I still can’t stand to look at him sing. Hands flapping, shambling around the stage… it’s awful.
Best- Vonzell, Anthony
Okay- Bo
Bad- Carrie, Scott, Constantine
I predict Scott goes home, but JAYSUS I hope it’s Carrie.
The audio was terrible tonight, Carrie, Constantine, Vonzell and Scott sounded like they couldn’t even hear the band and as such were floating in whatever key they hoped was right, sadly they were often mistaken.
Horrible sound editing or engineering or whatever it’s called, Carrie has a huge voice and was drowned out half the time, what’s up with that? Seriously awful.
Ok, no one else has commented on this so maybe I just need a new tv?
Best- Bo
Good- Anthony 
Not very good at all- Constantine, Carrie, Vonzell. Connie was trying too hard to be Bo and having rhythm issues, Carrie was losing to the f’ing fiddle, Vonzell gave great show but was all over the place tonally.
Horrible very bad hugely awful song choice- Scott
You have no idea how many farm girl and cow jokes jumped into my head. None I will post here, I’ll tell ya now.
in the bottom. . .3.
Wheres Jaade?
I enjoyed The Bo Show tonight. Who are these other people you guys keep mentioning?
Constantine was terrible. I hate to say it, but I’d even put him below Scott and he should be in the bottom 2. I don’t think Constantine will go home though so it looks like we’ll be saying buh-bye to Scott. If I had to choose another person to be in the bottom 2, I’d have to say Carrie. Anthony was pretty good tonight. Bo is always good. And, Vonzell is too pretty for words so I can’t put here there. Besides, she sang the heck out of that Christina Aguilera song.
I don’t know why all of you are saying AFed was good. Mr. Caricci and I fast forwarded through his performance because of the torment therein.
Bo’s little film thingy made me love him even more and how darling was he when he said his glasses looked lik $600 but only cost $6! I think I love him.
I didn’t know a single song tonight. Overall, not a great night.
Carrie–I hate it when women do that growly thing with their voice. Also, I hate country music. Also, I hate it when AI contestants say “c’mon.” A lousy performance.
Bo–Jim Morrison is in the house! Hate the shades. Still a solid performance.
Vonzell–Terrible on the low notes and screechy on some of the high ones. OK.
Anthony–The whole non-masculine, non-threatening, Ken doll persona is wildly uninteresting to me. He’s been steadily improving over the last few weeks.
Cheeseboy–Memo to Constantine: You’re not Bo. A boring song and a boring performance.
Scott–I find him putrid.
Bo and Vonzell should be the final two.
I predict that Carrie goes home tomorrow.
She’s away visiting family and had a job interview. She should be back tomorrow.
However, she did not watch AI and as such will not have her dose of goodness for us.
I thought Bo and AFed were the best.
Simon was right about Vonzell; she WAS flat.
Constantine made me itchy. What was that song anyway?
I liked the song Scott sang; I didn’t like the way he sang it, but it did seem very personal to him. All the songs he chose seemed to be very personal. If only he weren’t personally so icky!
And I thought Carrie was the absolute worst.
That probably means Anthony will go home tomorrow.
Twas an interesting show. With less contestants it seems to drag on. It seemed everyone (except Scott) was in “this is my chance to really go all out” mode.
No way, he will stay, mark my words. Who goes? I’m figuring Scott UNLESS the Clevelanders go nuts and try like heck.
I guess I’m once again the minority of one. I thought Bo sucked. And though the song he chose sucked as well, even the original hack artist who did it (whoever that is) sang it better and with more passion. Bo’s performance was just boring. Not nearly as boring as Carrie’s, though. How such corny hick music even survived into the 21st century baffles me, and though I don’t know the original, it wouls be hard for it to be more bland than her version. OK, it’s back on here. I hope Vonzell does something decent tonight.
I sure hope so. I think he should have been gone a long time ago.
Rankings:
- Bo
- Anthony
- Vonzell
- Carrie
- Constantine
- Scott