I’ll sit in on that one.
UPDATE:
Tag-team match of Hail Ants & RTFirefly vs. David, God of Frogs & DaToad
WorldEater vs. VenusProbe
NoClueBoy vs. Knowed Out
Ginger of the North vs. Nanook of the North Shore
… vs. Northern Piper vs. Sterling North
UPDATE:
Mangetout vs …
tatertot,
cabbage,
boccoli!,
BarBQSauce,
Green Bean,
Smashed Ice Cream,
oreo,
cheezit,
Watermelon Man,
Big Kahuna Burger,
UncleBeer,
LolaCocaCola,
Nacho4sara,
vanilla,
chocolate,
Ellen Cherry,
Honey,
GingerOfTheNorth,
Cherry,
and EggNogg.
Poysyn vs ratty
mmmm Nacho4Sara mmm
Judith Prietht. you’re thinking of Bearflag70. 
F_X
… and Harmonious Discord.
Plus Coldfire vs. Silver Fire.
F_X
gasp I’ve been noticed? Wow thats a first for me. Though I don’t know about that matchup. Her north refers to Canada, whereas my north isn’t very north at all, considering its only the north shore of Long Island. But I’ll take it anyways!
Maybe, but she’s around Baltimore now.
David, God of Frogs vs. St. Urho.
Excellent find F_X.
Arachnid Love vs. SpiderWoman.
David, God of Frogs vs. Da Toad. Then again, maybe Da Toad is one of David’s disciples…
KneadToKnow vs. don’t ask
Just because the names are eerily similar…
Spoz vs. Spoc.
(Spoz would have done this himself when I told him about it, but he’s too lazy… so I said I’d do it)
F_X
Phoenix Dragon versus Dragon Phoenix… like fighting with a mirror…
His4Ever versus lost4life.
KneadToKnow vs. Doughboy
P.T. Smegma vs. Anal Scurvy
Put me in on Sauron’s side.