Perhaps FairyPrincessKitty?
SpazCat vs OpalCat vs CrazyCatLady vs bobkitty vs catbiker vs HelloKitty vs psycat vs BiblioCat vs flapcats vs …
lno vs LNO vs INO vs ino

I’m game 
iampunha vs Iamthecowgodmoo
Psychobunny vs. Nutty Bunny
Cecil Adams
Qwisp vs. Lucki Chaarms
adam yax versus Eve
Ginger of the North and SouthernStyle
Happy Lendervedder vs. Happy Frood
And given all those “food-related” ones that Algernon posted up earlier, I think we should add GingeroftheNorth to the mix. Sure, ginger’s a spice or something of the sort, but it goes well with food…
F_X
Eve vs. Chava (which is Hebrew for Eve)
Zev Steinhardt
gobear vs swampbear vs Bearflag vs GrizzRich
(I know there’s a number at the end of Bearflag but I can’t remember it)
PolishSausage vs Senor Beef
Homer J Vs. Kwyjibo.
(One in the same. No?) 
Zev–thanks! I didn’t want Eve to be left out, but there’s nobody named Adam-something…
Urban Ranger vs. Arden Ranger
Well dang. I coulda sworn I saw an adam yax here.
Within the last 90 days, both adam yax and Adam P. have posted on the SDMB.
Well, aside from him.
Oh, and there’s also Eve vs. Arden Ranger. (geddit? eve arden? the actress?)
Also, Arden Ranger vs. Avalonian vs. Lady of the Lake in a three-way tag-team mud-wrestling extravaganza!
Flamsterette_X Vs. WaterJ2
**EggNogg ** vs. Green Bean
Cajun Man vs. irishgirl
Hail Ants vs. David, God of Frogs
sWitchazel vs. hazel-rah