**Pulp Addiction ** was my vote. I only had it once, and I still miss it!
I’m torn between From Russia with Buzz and Wavy Gravy. Oh how I miss these very best ice cream flavors ever!!
I hadn’t realized they’d dicontinued Bovinity Divinity. THOSE BASTARDS!
–Cliffy
The one I want isn’t there. But I am given to understand it was never sold here…just in the UK.
But my write in vote goes to:
The Full Vermonty
(maple flavoured)
Southern Pecan Pie!
It’s pie! It’s ice cream!
It’s pie AND ice cream!
What’s not to love?
Best. Flavor. EVER.
So far as I know, none of the Heath bar flavours are sold anymore in Canada. Neither is Chubby Hubby. 
I voted for Rainforest Crunch.
Coffee Toffee Crunch!
Weee! Another Rainforest Crunch fan popping by after the vote.
It was my first Ben & Jerry’s flavor and love at first lick. First loves last forever!
I voted and put this in the comments box:
Re: From Russia with Buzz
I wholeheartedly agree. That flavor is what allowed me to survive my first two years of college. I almost cried when they stopped carrying it. Chocolate chunks with little coffee ground bits in them! Oh my gawd I want it back.
Fresh Georgia Peach, y’all!
I’m a Floridian by birth, but I mostly grew up in Georgia, and I’m back again after another long sojourn in my native state. And I can tell you, nothing’s better than peach ice cream on a summer night – especially after you’ve been turning that durn churn handle for the better part of an hour!
Urban Jumble! Chocolate, coconut, almonds, fudge…YUM!!!
Must. Come. Back.
If it doesn’t make it, I guess I’ll go Cool Brittania in round 2.
Yet another voter for
From Russia With Buzz! 
Hey, it’s chocolate, it’s coffee, it’s a pun on a James Bond movie. What more could a graduate student want in an ice cream?
(Besides, it made for AMAZING smoothies!)
I WANT MY ‘FROM RUSSIA WITH BUZZ BACK!’
No, I’m not obsessed, really.
__
<< Coffee: the 100% all natural alternative to sleep. >>
Full Vermonty was sold in the US. I used to buy it when it was available.
I can’t believe they killed the sublime Pulp Addiction, yet the icky, sickly sweet nastiness that is **Phish Food ** is still around. But Pulp Addiction isn’t in the top ten. Sigh. I also could go for Cool Brittania.
The SDMB admin should consider implementing this maneuver with banned posters. ;D
Re: the thread
Concession Obsession was retired? But I saw a pint of it the other day at Wal-Mart…
shiver
Mwahahah!
Wavy gravy pwn3s all!
Tremble!
Rainforest Crunch was also my first, and I was heartbroken when they retired it. Delicious cashew-y carmel-y goodness.