Pick your three favorites from the current menu of 39 Ben & Jerry’s Original Ice Cream flavors.
New York Super Fudge Chunk
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Dublin Mudslide
In the Graveyard:
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
From Russia With Buzz
Dastardly Mash
New York Super Fudge Chunk
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
a tie between Mint Chocolate Cookie and Coffee Heath Bar Crunch
Since I tasted “Mission to Marzipan” all others are dead to me.
Dammit, somehow I left out that and three other flavors. Oh well.
The best one ever was Bananas on the Rum. Sadly it is no more.
they don’t have coffee coffee buzz buzz buzz which is the family overall favorite. The pumpkin is roomies, the cherry garcia is hubbys
Well, roomie and husband, being diabetic I eat their sugarless vanilla with little dark chocolate chunks in it when I indulge. Best tasting diabetic junkfood now I cant get chocolate splenda sweetened tofutti 
<me shakes fist and curses test marketing as the tease it is>
I do ice cream maybe three or four times a year. I really miss being nondiabetic.
Haven’t had them all, but it’s chubby Hubby all the fucking way, man…
Joe
Moved from IMHO to Cafe Society
Ellen Cherry
Deliciously Different
Coffee heath bar and two pints of Wavy Gravy, which unfortunately doesn’t exist anymore.
Sad panda is sad.
I voted for Dublin Mudslide and Chocolate Fudge Brownie, but my other favorite is Coffee coffee buzz buzz buzz. Do they not make it anymore?
I also loved “From Russia with Buzz”. OMG I want that back.
Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Strawberry Cheesecake, and Oatmeal Cookie Chunk.
I also adore the Berried Treasure sorbet, which according to their site they still make, but it’s disappeared off the shelves here.
vanilla
I picked pumpkin cheesecake, maple blondie, and everything but the… , but I’d swap out the last for Boston cream pie if it were on the list.
I voted for:
Cherry Garcia
Coffee Health Bar Crunch
Dublin Mudslide
But I would probably add Pumpkin Cheesecake if I ever tasted it (never saw it around here… sob). I 
pumpkin-flavored stuff.
Ditto someone who said Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz. I loved it but now it’s gone…
BUT my all-time favorite was one that had coconut ice cream with almonds and chocolate chunks! OMG!!! Soooooooooo good. I don’t know what the heck it was called but I lust for that flavor and wish it would come back. Best coconut ice cream ever!!!
Stephen Colbert’s Americone Dream (especially with some bacon crumbled in, no lie)
Cherry Garcia
Pistachio Pistachio
With an honorable mention to Chunky Monkey, which we won’t be short of for the next month.
(Why yes, I have watched Hot Fuzz far too many times.)
New York Super Fudge Chunk. My favorite by far. Cherry Garcia is a distant second.
I’m not allowed to have B&J anymore so I miss out on all the new flavors. I miss Coffee Heath Bar Crunch.
I didn’t see it on the list (i guess since they don’t make it anymore?) but Pop Rocks was the best thing EVARRRR. Of what’s left, Chunky, Chubby and Colbert FTW.
I see Cherry is winning, but I think Turkey Hill does that flavor much better.
My picks were #1, #2, and #5 in popularity in this poll: Cherry Garcia, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, and Americone Dream. Americone Dream is my go-to, though if for some crazy reason I’m eating it in a cone, I’ll get Cherry Garcia.
Edit - Americone Dream is hovering around 5th, my mistake.