Billy Meier, whats the verdict?

Okay, that’s pretty cool, I admit. But it doesn’t support the claim of “a magma chamber some 7 kilometers right under the Vatican city.”

Geophysicist here.

I suppose presumably the idea was that a scientist couldn’t easily dismiss the idea of a magma chamber several kilometers under a city.

But the funny thing is that even if there are no direct measurements (as in no drilled wells), indirect measurements are sufficient to detect plenty of things under the surface. It is, in fact, how I make my living working for a contractor that helps oil companies detect subsurface hydrocarbons at such depths. While my particular area of expertise is not volcanoes, every volcano situated near any major population center certainly has monitoring by geophysicists.

So, no, the very concept of this undiscovered subsurface magma chamber connected to a volcano a hundred miles away is ridiculous. We have the tools and technology to detect such things and have had such for decades now.

I see that they tried to cover their asses by claiming scientists can’t actually do this. And maybe that was true 50 years ago. It’s not true now. Maybe you can claim our theoretical knowledge is false. Well, that doesn’t work, either, or else we wouldn’t have success drilling for oil/gas at depths (including wells exceeding 7km depth). Our technical expertise is certainly quite up to the task, which has been repeatedly verified by direct experiment and economic recovery of hydrocarbons. And also by experiences like detecting trapped miners, like the case of the Chilean miners a few years ago.

“Moot”
“Losing”

In the spirit of the thread, “jmoot” is acceptable.

They’re not doing well convincing those of us without specialized knowledge either.

[INDENT][INDENT]

It’s probably right about the disruption of truth or facts by misinformation or deception. Yet try to remember that in the classic scientific approach, nothing is absolute truth, most things are derived in ACCORD to current knowledge and understanding. A hypothesis/theory is valid until dis-proven. That is classic science. Now we don’t have to be classic scientists to understand the harm deception can bring. Yet on the other hand we’re bombarded and surrounded by deception in our seemingly normal “everyday” lives. Do you believe all statements in the commercials you watch? Do you believe in magic? Did we find WMDs in Irag? Do you believe in every word the president/PM says? Deception at this moment is all around us, and sometimes through experiencing it we may come to discover a higher understanding/truth/fact.

Hence deception can sometimes be a good wake-up call, when a person may realize that whatever he believed was false or was just a good looking idea. Or in simple terms, “beautiful bullshit” :slight_smile:

So let’s say a person is confused and doesn’t see the higher truth yet. He hasn’t spotted the deception. If he tries to convince everyone forcefully to believe his confusion, he’s not “the evil”, he’s still confused. Are you more likely to reveal his confusion by arguing/force/insults/derogatory comments? Maybe. Probably not - as experience shows on this forum. Or is it more peaceful to state “OK thank you” and move on? Let that person be with whatever he has, until one day it dawns on him.

It’s everyone’s own task to learn to discern the lie and the fact. And that again comes from “experience”, and without experiencing deception - how would one learn? Not everyone is born a truth seer.

Well imho… (my subjective opinion that is not be forced upon anyone). Is that Billy is not being honest. Probably has a beautiful imagination and would have made a wonderful science fiction writer. What made me make the opinion? ---- It’s the ego that is evident (we all have one). It’s the attraction to fame and attention, plus inconsistent messages of higher spirituality yet the loving vibration is not there. And exclusivity claims. And plus this site with according information.

http://www.iigwest.com/investigations/meier/
Particularly this and this.
http://www.iigwest.com/investigations/meier/asket_nera_deconstruction.html
http://www.iigwest.com/investigations/meier/dinosaur_deconstruction.html

Although there are justifications that all those were faked by “MIB”. Which then makes it seem like MIB are only after Billy and no-one else who also had encounters. Unless ALL else who had encounters are fakes and not real - then Billy is the only one. That makes him again, exclusive. No offense newinitiation, this is just my subjective opinion - not aggressive towards yourself or Billy. My opinion is subjective, limited from what I gathered. I don’t hold the absolute truth.

Nevertheless, it’s pointless to argue or prove anything in this ideology matter. Since it is the persons life and path to choose and experience whatever is there. Let it be.

And finally, if you don’t believe in Billy’s case - Why are you spending time on this forum arguing? Over something you don’t believe? Isn’t that an obstacle? Perhaps you could be doing something more constructive now? :)[/INDENT][/INDENT]

In the OP and Herr Meier’s defense, I don’t believe these are photos of the same woman. They are lovely and have similar haircuts, but at that time, in suburban Chicago, not the Pleiades, most of the girls I knew were working on that same straight, blonde hair, Swedish bikini model look, with varying degrees of success.

Scroll to the top of the page. Check out what if says in the banner right under the words “THE STRAIGHT DOPE”.

Thank you! I was all but certain this was the case, but wanted a cite one way or the other. Cool job, by the way!

I am not and I mean if you read between the lines, what you wrote above is exactly what I was referring to Smeghead.

For once we agree on one thing

The Jews does not necessarily have to be a Zionist nor an Isrealite nor a Habraon OK

There are even Jewish people who oppose the Zionist Isrealites and non Israelites alike and likewise just because you are a Zionist doesn’t mean that you are a Jew

Duly noted thanks for the advice.

Now how could you possibly cover 15-20 different queries all in a single post without generalising which takes away from the debate with absence of specificity and detail required to do it justice.

Not only will this make mute, the point that needs to be delivered, but it’ll detract from accuracy because of over simplicity.

I am only showing my common courtesy in reciprocity to people who have shown the same courtesy to reply back whatever their contentions or the nature of the post may be.

So I hope you understand.

Thanks

Them first.

No, really.

They are free to choose whatever they want to believe in the privacy of their own minds. I’ll leave them that. But once they choose to attempt to affect other people’s beliefs, their beliefs are fair game.

You say “live and let live”. That works both ways.

Why the double standard?

More constructive than fighting ignorance?

I actually do consider ignorance and bad science an inherent detriment to the human race. Better yet, the last couple hundred years (since the Enlightenment, basically) have shown that personal beliefs are even more illuminating, useful, and constructive when they are based on verifiable fact. We’ve certainly advanced much faster by insisting on such.

Then, what could be more constructive than fighting against such ignorance?

The reality is that all forms of various earth languages have deteriorated

http://www.futureofmankind.co.uk/Billy_Meier/gaiaguys/meierv7p22-23.htm

The UFO photos have gone through stringent scientific analysis with sophisticated equipment of the day and were deemed genuine and not models on strings.

http://www.futureofmankind.co.uk/Billy_Meier/Contact_Report_251

Ptaah

You must continue to keep this secret; do not speak about it under any circumstances. We are only permitted to elaborate to the point as our withdrawal from Earth is linked with the immediate future and related events, in which we are not allowed to interfere in any form so that we may protect and keep close reigns on the secret regarding our own culture and region where we live. This is tied in also with the fact that some matters are impending. On one hand, we were able to foresee them but, on the other hand, they are the reason for our withdrawal, while events that have been unfolding on Earth for several decades now were part of our assignments. We have fulfilled this task, along with the many others we were obligated to look after, and you have played a very important role in this scenario of making public, worldwide, the so-called UFO phenomenon, as terrestrials have labeled it. You alone made it possible to promulgate this subject matter worldwide and provoke the controversy to the extent that it is not only religious and pseudo-esoteric sectarians, fanatics, gullible individuals, madmen, etc., who preoccupy themselves with the subject. Finally, for some time now, a great variety of scientists, governmental agencies, military services and governments have also begun to seriously preoccupy themselves with this subject, a fact that could not have been accomplished without your help and great resulting effort. Actually, alone through your efforts was this successful launching of the worldwide UFO controversy possible, for which we all express our appreciation to you - a recognition you had to really struggle for, when I think of all the harm that came crashing down upon you. And it is irrelevant whether they were health related or associated with the defamations, abusive language, assassination attempts, diatribes of hatred and other things to which we, unfortunately, had to contribute our share, as you know. Had it not been for these occurrences, the UFO controversy would never have come about and scientists, as well as the military and governments, among others, would not have become seriously interested in it. In your defense I am permitted today to speak officially about these matters and the fact that we used special techniques to analyze and evaluate in great detail the movie and photo montages, along with the movie trick photography used by all those bogus and deceitful, purported contactees or UFO observers. We found that their falsified movie and photo material appealed to terrestrial humans, particularly to those so-called UFO experts who call themselves ufologists and the like, and this even includes some well-respected scientists. The absurdity of the falsifications, and the people who believed them, is stunning yet extremely effective. For this reason, we executed maneuvers with our genuinely existing flying objects, e.g., jerky pendulum movements and certain skipping and floating movements, which ordinarily are not a part of our flying objects’ normal movements and flight techniques. Instead, they appeared like those ridiculous, abrupt pendulum and strange swaying movements of the manipulated movies and photos by the UFO swindlers, liars and charlatans. The fact that we chose to execute these movement types is based on the reasoning that they, in particular, would result in the worldwide, fierce UFO controversy which resulted in many hardships for you, of course. You were accused of fraud, deceit, charlatanry and, indeed, dishonesty. You were further charged with constructing models and then photographing and filming them. Often we felt very sorry for you, but were unable to change any of this. Only by executing certain flight maneuvers, which you then were able to film, photograph and disseminate throughout the globe, was the worldwide UFO controversy ensured that led to the previously mentioned outcome. In the future, they will also bring about additional and by now urgently needed results. It may be some consolation to you now to know that everything has occurred with the desired and intended outcome, and that you are now the most important person in matters related to contacts with extraterrestrials and UFO affairs - you probably are the most famous personality worldwide in these matters. Of c…

Look it was many many years ago that I came across it and don’t have the files with me to provide them for you right now not to mention having to go through the mountains of documents to extract it.

You will have to refine your search of that document from Dr Greer’s website

Its being revised and errors corrected

Like I said only if you dealt with the material instead of ranting and raving aganist something that you have never done a decent research on.

In the court of law you won’t even make it past the front door with that kind of sloppy approach.

This is where you people go wrong.

All with what! not a shread of reading or investigation

Look its all here if you want to know what the future has in store for us

Some will obviously come to pass way before 2029 and you won’t be left waiting for too long

How true, how very true

They made many attempts on his life out of the documented 22 assassination attempts on Billy’s life but failed in some instances due to Plejaren intervention and help.

But you know nothing about the Meier case nor have you read anything beyond a cursory glance.

There are so many aspects to the Meier case than this letter"J" used to spell Jmmanuel’s name which you are so obssessively fixated on