I’m not involved, and I’ve only spent a bit of time looking this draft over, but FWIW, here’s some thoughts:
Charlie Garner was taken way too early.
Jamal Lewis was taken way too late.
Daunte Culpepper before Manning and McNabb??? Ooofah.
You guys are absolutely obsessed with running backs. Picking a fourth RB before a QB? Granted with 8 teams you probably won’t get stuck with a completely crappy QB, but I think the value of a great QB is underrated, and the value of an iffy rb is overrated.
Although it would be stupid to predict the outcome of a not yet completed mock draft, here’s my picks. Hell, I finished 7th last year in the SDMB, so they may not be worth the electrons they’re printed on, but here you go:
3rd place: hustler. The top QB, the top WR, and a solid group of RB (I actually like Barlow to replace Hearst this year). Not enough depth though. I was intrigued by pls reset because of Portis and Owens, but some iffy depth there, and no QB. I don’t think you could win this year with Warner or Maddox or whatever crap is left leading your team.
2nd place: CamelToes. What’s not to like on this team. Oh, wait, the weak ass receiving corps. Fantastic qb’s, wonderful rb’s (three starters who will all put up great numbers this year) make this team tough to beat. But Burris was a reach (he’ll still do fine), and talk is KJ will be on the block come season time. I wouldn’t want him anyway. Some late round gems may save the WR crew (or a trade), but this team will be carried by their qbs and rbs.
1st place: mouthbreather. He paid me $50 to pick him. O.K. he really didn’t but he’s got a heck of a good team. Bledsoe may not be the best, but he’ll put up solid numbers for you. But in McAllister, Henry, and Green he has a lot of great young talent. Whereas Faulk and James may have seen better days, these guys all have huge upsides, and are proven commodities. Moulds and Horn should be able to hold their own.
Just some idle thoughts to chew on. Good Luck.