I was madly in love with Johnny Cash when I was a kid back in the 60’s, and everyone laughed at me - but hey, take a good look at him when he was a young man and you’ve got to agree that he was a very manly-looking man and had a pretty good build on him!
I’m fascinated by DJ Qualls. (Lord, he’s skinner than I am!) And Mickey Rourke in Iron Man.
I agree with Eminem, but again, not to keep, but to play…
Also, Tommy Flanagan…but I love an accent! God forbid I travel to Scotland or Ireland, I may never come home!
I have to agree with you. I hadn’t seen him in anything before, and I thought he was awfully weird looking when I first saw him on “Lost Girl,” but he’s totally grown on me.
I didn’t notice this before in time to edit…but it’s not just you. Every time he’s on screen - in Maine, mind you, not the fairytale land - I keep finding myself thinking that if he was my age, he’d probably be pretty hot.
There’s nothing strange about this one at all. I think she’s WAY hotter than Erin Andrews.
Aw, I came in to say Eminem.
I’m also strangely attracted to Jason Mewes of Clerks/“Jay and Silent Bob” fame.
I also love Alan Cumming - even though he is not at all my type.
And you’re only sometimes his. 
I had never even heard of her before Top Chef S8, but there’s something about her.
She certainly has a “distinctive” facial structure, and not one that I’d typically call attractive. But I can’t look away. 
She was certainly striking as a model back in the 90s, not in a traditionally “sexy” way but beautiful nonetheless.
Doesn’t hurt that she was probably the most likable, friendly and fun personality that season IMO.
Totally okay with that…because I am sure he sometimes fantasizes about a married, female, Canadian Forces Officer-mom…doesn’t everyone?
I do!
Gosh…I am neither a celebrity, nor strangely attractive. Thanks Superdude!
Back when this thread was new, I remember thinking “Carey Mulligan? Jessica Alba? Kate Winslet?? In what backwards parallel universe are these women considered unattractive?”
But I suppose I shouldn’t talk, because my answer is Patrick Stewart. Which I don’t think is terribly unconventional, but it’s unusual for me because he’s old enough to be my grandfather.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gUVjp5k5I4 In case you don’t know what she does or looks like.
Laurie Metcalf
Now, I’m not saying that Kristin Stewart isn’t attractive to most people. But I do find it odd that I’m as attracted to her as I am. Her face is just a little bit different, and that’s enough.
Hayrvey Keitel & Gary Busey … why, I dunno.
Since this thread got resurrected, I’ll comment, the thing you’re looking for is a conjunction. Commas are ambiguous, because they have a lot of uses. If you want a 2 item list, it requires a conjunction (and, or).
Same here. That perma-wistfulness brings out my protective urges and makes me want to keep her safe from the world.
Also, I think Mary Matalin is very sexy.
My god,you find it strange? She is very pretty.
My choices are Francis Sternhagen (Cliff’s mom from Cheers) and Amy Roloff( The mom in Little People,Big World).