Do people often surprise you?

How often in life have you been surprised by someone? I don’t mean at the instant teller at gun point…“Surprise! You’re being robbed!” or coming home thinking everyone’s forgotten and…“Surprise! Happy birthday!”

I mean meet a person. Start getting to know them (platonic or romantic), begin to see some character traits and form a picture/opinion of what they are like but end up getting it all wrong.

Can people be actual dichotomies? Not by virtue of saying one thing and doing another but actually being a complete and unexpected surprise. As in, “Wow! You had me thinking you were a conservative but you’re a complete liberal!” or maybe, “Seriously, every single thing you own is a status symbol or designer label but you really don’t buy into that entire thing and are happy to shop at Target… except that you don’t.”

Happens to me all the time. The most frequent scenario is the racist. I’ll be going along enjoying someone’s company and really feeling like I’m connecting and suddenly they’ll drop the N bomb. Homophobes…same thing.

I rarely meet someone I initially dislike and then find out we’re thinking along the same lines.

Political correctness, to a great degree, is to blame for these surprises. People don’t wear their true colors on their sleeves because it ain’t cool or they don’t want to deal with the fallout face to face. Consequently, it sometimes takes a while to see who you’re dealing with.

So if your little voice is at odds with what you’re being told and you can’t really gather sufficient evidence to validate the voice, which do you trust?

Might be that it’s your own past experiences or mistakes that are sending out a DefCon-3 based on false radar reading? No?

I had a playboy, macho high-school classmate who surprised me when I found that he regularly used the word “whom” - correctly.

I had a co-worker who normally ate horribly, bringing giant, frosted, liquor-store bought honey buns to the office to eat for breakfast each day. He was also boastful about his gastronomic capacity; he thought it made him masculine. One day came from McDonald’s with a burger and a small fry as a side - from which he ate the fries one by one!

Always.

There was a girl I was afraid of in high school - she was well known for being loud, obnoxious, bitchy, and mean for no reason. I spent all of my high school days avoiding her.
Several years later, when I was working at the factory, I was told I had to train a new worker - and it was her! You can just imagine what I thought. Grimly, I nodded, agreed to train her, and got ready for a long, hard night.
She quickly became one of the best friends I’ve ever had. She’s a little rough around the edges, but she’s one of the most lovable, sweet people I have ever met. I’d take a bullet for her.

Then there was the girl I was good friends with for seven years or so. She was great to hang around with, we had lots of fun together. I thought she was pretty cool, and we got along great. Then I moved in with her, and she made me her personal slave! She was so great until I got too close. The things I learned about her in that house were disturbing, indeed. This is the one I’ve mentioned on the boards many times before. The one that thinks she’s Jesus. No, really, no joke.

I surprised a fellow co-worker once. I’m known (when I’m over my shyness around people) for being pretty goofy, silly, butt-of-the-joke kind of person. I love to make people laugh. I give way to people so they feel good about themselves, or allow myself to be walked on (as long as it’s not detrimental) for the sake of someone else. Most people who only know me as far as that will describe me as sweet, but a bit of a “simpleton”. I don’t remember what had happened one day, but someone was taking advantage of another person, and I put them in their place pretty quickly and efficiently, without raising my voice. The forklift driver overheard me, and caught up with me during lunch while I was walking alone in the warehouse. He whispered, “You’re not nearly as silly as you make yourself out to be, are you?” I smiled. He said, “You’re a pretty smart girl. You surprised me.”
“Give most people a chance, and they’ll all surprise you, toots,” I replied.

And I think that’s true. At this point in my life, I try not to form too many ideas about someone I don’t know well. I don’t see the way they are dressed, or the way they act in public, or who they hang out with as a good way to judge what kind of person is inside. I ignore all of that crap, and try to hear them. From the nastiest person to the sweetest person, they’ve all got something inside that will surprise the hell out of you, if you let them. Good and bad.

But I love people so much. All of them, even the bad ones. There’s aways something. People surprise me every single day. Some days are better than others, admittedly. But everyone hides. Everyone hides. Even the ones that think they don’t, they hide, too.

That’s neat. I’d like to learn to look at people like that. :slight_smile:

Not sure if I can.

Aww. Anastaseon… that was lovely. It was kind of inspiring.
I’m very sensitive and observant and receptive to undercurrents and body language, etc., and I still get taken once in a great while. Not as much as I used to. But some people are very, very good at hiding who they really are until one day something changes and you see that they’re not who you thought. Some people have very few tells.

But I love people so much. All of them, even the bad ones. There’s aways something. People surprise me every single day. Some days are better than others, admittedly. But everyone hides. Everyone hides. Even the ones that think they don’t, they hide, too.
[/QUOTE]

Worth the price of admission - right there. Thanks Anastaseon, that is so wonderfully accurate. God I wish I could let go of judgement and live that.

But I love people so much. All of them, even the bad ones. There’s aways something. People surprise me every single day. Some days are better than others, admittedly. But everyone hides. Everyone hides. Even the ones that think they don’t, they hide, too.
[/QUOTE]

Worth the price of admission - right there. Thanks Anastaseon, that is so wonderfully accurate. God I wish I could let go of judgement and live that.

No, I try not to base my initial vibe on past experience (mostly because it’s been wrong often enough). I try to get to know the person. Sometimes that can take some time. Take the woman I used to work with, for instance. We were getting along well for about a year, and then she revealed a side to her personality that was a deal-breaker as far as I was concerned. But sometimes the situation that forces the reveal doesn’t come up in everyday conversation, so you have no way of knowing until it comes up.

In general, no, people DON’T usually surprise me. Maybe it’s because I’m such as great observer that I get their number quick, or, contrariwise, maybe I just don’t pay much attention period.

But you know who surprises me? My husband of nearly 12 years. Most often in a good way.

And also, the woman who is rapidly becoming my “best friend”. When I met her I really liked her, but I though she was kind of fluff-headed. The more I have got to know her, the more depth and intelligence I discover, which is cool, because the “fluffy” fun stuff is real too.

So, maybe it’s only when I really get to know someone that I see them do enough stuff to occasionally depart from initial impressions.

About five people surprise me negatively for every one that surprises me positively. I guess because the negative-appearing ones get cut loose before they get the chance.

Maybe I have to stop being attracted to “nice” people.