[Dr. Horrible] Something new from Joss Whedon, Nathan Fillion & Neil Patrick Harris

True, that was actually pretty shiny, come to think of it, I had the same exact thought right after I posted my previous message…

I hope that we see more from the good, err…bad Doctor as well

as far as Nathan’s characterization of Capt. Hammer, was anyone else getting a somewhat “Steve Martin-esque” vibe from him, kinda’ like Steve Martin in the role of Orin Scrivello, DDS from Little Shop of Horrors, a kind of enthusiastic stupidity

Of course, given Hammer’s case of Antadeiaphobia, all Doc. H needs to do is trap Capt. H in a room filled with ducks, or some other Mallardesque evil scheme

Exactly. From a supervillain point of view it wasn’t Captain Hammer who killed Penny. Doctor Horrible tricked Captain Hammer, by booby-trapping his own weapon. Genius! Muahaha.

Not to mention the humiliation for Captain Hammer - he ran away from that crowd crying like a baby. I’m assuming that, not the death of “What’s-Her-Name”, is what he was on the couch for.

You know, you’re right. I can easily imagine Steve Martin replacing Nathan Fillion. Given Hammer’s mannerisms and songs, Steve would be right at home.

That’s a good comparison. A lot of parody heroes have that smug, optimistic density to them, and Martin has always been great at that.

Nathan’s muscular frame really brings home the performance. Martin would be too frail to pull it off.

Hey! You left off the “Dude.” That’s the best part of that line!

I dunno why. Something about a supervillain calling somebody “Dude”. :smiley:

Those three words, all by themselves, really shouldn’t do to me what they do to me…

No, California Penal Code section 189 lists the felonies for which the felony murder rule applies. It’s not “during the commission of any crime;” it’s during the commission of specific crimes. And as I read further, it seems California has a first-degree and a second-degree felony murder structure.

But enough of that hijack; certainly Dr. Horrible’s crime, attempted murder, qualifies under the felony murder rule and he could be tried for Penny’s death (as well as, obviously, given the ticket for the Evil League of Evil under the same theory).

Having listen to the whole show, I think I can now articulate why I found Act III musically the weakest: it’s the most derivative. Act I is solid; Act II is superb, with “On the Rise,” being a real stand-out, show-stopper tune.

Act III’s first number is “So They Say,” which is very strongly evocative of Larsen’s Rent stylings. And the Horrible number at the end is very Sondheim/Sweeny Todd.

Now, don’t get me wrong: I love both Rent and all things Sondheim, and these are both very good pieces. But neither is original in the ways that the other musical numbers are.

I’m straight and even I think he’s hot as hell. Scrubs sums it up best: “The Todd appreciates hotness, regardless of gender.”

I really loved the Horrible iphone remote control app.

Strangely, though I loved the songs in the actual show, the song I have stuck in my head right now is TMBG’s “Someone Keeps Moving My Chair” with “Dr Horrible” substituted for “Mr Horrible”.

While watching Act 3 again, I realized something…

Doc. H’s Death Ray looked kinda’ …familiar

then I realized, it has the same general lines, and the muzzle/emitter looks very much like the Alliance “Sonic” guns in Firefly (specifically, the guns that Jayne steals in the episode where they rob the Alliance hospital, “Ariel”)

Looks like Joss snuck in a Firefly reference in a kinda’ offhanded manner…

News of Act IV is starting to surface www.doctorhorrible.net

Dr Horrible’s coat is recycled from the same ep as the Death Ray - Firefly’s Ariel

Over on the IMDB discussion page, fans of DHSALB are wondering what they should call themselves (I.E. Firefly fans being “Browncoats”), the two most popular seem to be “Labcoats” and “The Evil League of <X>” where X can=Evil, Bloggers, or Sidekicks

I prefer TELoE, and my ELoE alias will be…

“Kernel Panic!”, I hold a PhD in confusing computers to the point of crashing

I just put in the Firefly ep. “Ariel”…

Doc. H’s lab coat is the same style worn by Simon and the other Doctors
the Death Ray IS the Alliance’s “Sonic Gun”, but Doc. H holds his upside down, has painted certain trim bits silver and red, and has added a sight to the “top” of the gun to try to “disguise” it, but it’s clearly an Alliance sonic weapon

So, it’s clear that Doc. Horrible is in all actuality, an Alliance sleeper agent, trying to infiltrate the ELoE for some nefarious Alliance purpose…

Funny you should say that. At the Comic-con Dr. Horrible panel, someone asked the actors to name their favorite musicals. Fillion said, “Probably no surprise to anyone that it’s Little Shop of Horrors.” So he’s aware of the influence as well.

At the same panel, they “confirmed” a soundtrack and an Act 4.

Nathan is still a hoot. Eliza Dushku mentioned in a later panel how she’d like to be the meat in a Nathan Fillion/Tahmoh Penikett sandwich.

I endorse this sentiment. Only with me subbing for Eliza.

Just in case anyone’s still interested who hasn’t seen it and doesn’t have itunes, it’s back online on both myspace and hulu. Joss is awesome.

http://www.hulu.com/dr-horribles-sing-along-blog