Let’s clear some things up about Bush’s Fighter Pilot days.
First of all, it’s true that he scored in the bottom 25th percentile on the aptitude test. HOWEVER, he also scored in the top 5% on the officer’s qualification test. I’m sure that was considered.
Now, there are a lot of ways you can go once you are accepted to basic flight school. First, you can wash out. A LOT of candidates wash out. Second, you can wind up passing, but with a grade low enough that you are assigned to fly support aircraft like cargo airplanes. That way, you can fly as co-pilot and gain experience, and the Guard can then assess your performance again in relative safety.
Generally, only the best performing students in basic flight school get a shot at fighters, because fighters are single-seat and there’s no one to supervise you (other than a few two-seat trainers which are used for fighter qualification).
Once you’re in fighter school, there are still a lot of ways to wash out, and a lot of students do.
It’s certainly possible that Bush used political pull to get him assigned to the guard, but I guarantee you that he made it into the F-102 purely on his skill. Political considerations go out the window here, because putting a poorly qualified pilot into the seat of an F-102 is a sure way to send him home in a box. Those fighters were hard to fly and very dangerous. BTW, it takes high intelligence to pass fighter school. You not only have to learn the stick-and-rudder skills, you have to learn all the aircraft systems, aerodynamics, meteorology, instrument flying, etc. More people probably wash out from their inability to learn the concepts quickly enough than wash out from being unable to handle the aircraft.
Finally, Bush volunteered for a tour of Vietnam. He was turned down because at that time they were only taking pilots with a minimum of 500 hours time in type, and Bush had 300. Cynics among you may suggest that he knew this when he volunteered, but that would suggest that Bush was smart enough to know that one day he would need to show such a thing on his record, AND somehow knew that there was no way he’d be accepted. That doesn’t jibe with the ‘dumb guy’ persona Bush’s enemies are trying to smear him with.
Frankly, I think it’s amazingly shallow to consider Bush dumb because the pundits are using that to pigeonhole him. Why don’t you evaluate him on his record? This is a guy who was a party animal, and no doubt didn’t try very hard when he was in school. Nevertheless, he managed to get a graduate degree from Yale. Hands up, all you detractors who have Ivy-League Graduate degrees. I’ll wait.
Oh, you don’t have one? Okay. How many of you managed to get elected governor, and get re-elected in a landslide? How many of you managed to run a campaign that has gotten you to a stone’s throw from the presidency?
I’m being a bit flippant here, because I think the topic deserves it. The bottom line is that this is a guy who is NOT dumb. He may not be a rocket scientist, he may not be a scholar. But he’s certainly well above the average in intelligence.