It’s third grade. The night of February 13th. Mom has finally relented and agreed to buy the cheap little paper Valentines they sell by the checkout stands. I know what’s coming so I beg, I plead for a second box. She is ruthless. “I can only afford one box,” she says, tossing another carton of cigarettes into the shopping cart.
At home, in my room, 9:45PM, way past my bedtime. My head pounds, sweat pours down my face. The list of my classmates sits before me. You know, the one the teacher passes out each year for Valentines day, with all the boys in the class in the right-hand column, all the girls on the left. The paper is full of pencil marks and little bits of eraser.
The little pink box came with 34 Valentines, plus the extra-large teacher card. There are 33 kids in my class, 18 boys and 15 girls. There is no margin for error. 25 of the Valentines are the safe “You’re my buddy” type. The other 9 are the dreaded “Be Mine”. There are definitely fewer than 9 girls in the class I would ask to “Be Mine”.
The struggle begins. Right away I assign all 18 boys a “Buddy” card. 7 “Buddy” cards left. Those are easily assigned to a handful of girls. Two of the girls I like get a “Be Mine”, my heart jumping out my throat as I write their beautiful, magical names on the card. Now the hard part. 6 girls left and nothing but “Be Mine” cards. What am I to do? Two girls of the girls are my buddies. They’ll understand, maybe even think it’s funny. 4 girls. Maybe I’ll steal “Buddy” cards from a couple of my guy friends, give those to the girls, give the guys the “Be Mine” cards as a joke. Yeah, it’ll be funny. 2 girls left. One is the mean girl who doesn’t like me. She’ll taunt me all year. The other is the shy, unpopular girl with glasses even thicker than mine. I’m afraid she’ll think I’m making fun of her. She might even cry. Forget it. I have my own problems. She’s on her own.
My mom’s yelling at me to go to bed. I have no recourse. I simply write the last two names on the cards, stuff them in the envelopes, get a paper cut on my tongue when I seal them up. I lay in bed awake all night, living out horrible fantasy after horrible fantasy.
The next day I drag myself from bed, eyes bleary, heart pounding, hands shaking. At school I tremble in nervous, painful anticipation until after the lunch recess. Then the moment is upon us. Like a zombie, without looking anyone in the eye, I drop the labeled envelopes into the decorated sandwich bags taped to everyone’s desk. I feel the shame of not being able to afford the Sweethearts most other kids included with their cards. Finally, it’s done. I sit at my desk and slowly open all the cards I received.
EVERY ONE of my cards is a “Buddy” card. A small part of me dies.
That’s why I hate Valentines day.