[QUOTE=chrisk]
Wasn’t M1 the werewolf one? I thought that was a scum win - I was watching it, and remember the description given of the few remaining scum turning into wolves at dusk and setting upon the surviving town.
[/QUOTE]
That was M2, I think, which was also a werewolf-themed game. M1 was definitely a town win. sturmhauke, as the Seer, definitely played a large role in that. M2 was the one where storyteller as the Godfather sold out all his teammates for the win.
M2 was a Mafia-themed game, but NAF had the winning Mafia turn into Werewolves at the end.
[QUOTE=sachertorte]
I don’t want the game to devolve into some sort of mind-game of “did that vote count?” or “I left off vote on purpose to manipulate the vote.” Not that any of you would try and manipulate the game in such a way
[/QUOTE]
Yeah, that’s only acceptable in the off-board three-handed games. 
That was a beautiful move in three handed.
And yeah - I screwed up in recruiting mafia, but I continue to maintain it wasn’t scum commiserating, just my town half posting his real thoughts. That, and I killed the wrong person at the start. But suspicion was already starting to turn my way for being generally quiet.
Ah well - I had fun.
[QUOTE=Darth Sensitive]
And yeah - I screwed up in recruiting mafia, but I continue to maintain it wasn’t scum commiserating, just my town half posting his real thoughts.
[/QUOTE]
Yeah, but even if it was your “town half,” you were only able to feel “bad” about the dotchan lynch because you KNEW she was town. No townie can be 100% certain about any lynch, barring an investigative role with no percentage of failure.
Game’s a bit slow, but it’s to be expected since it’s the weekend, I suppose.
[QUOTE=HazelNutCoffee]
No townie can be 100% certain about any lynch
[/QUOTE]
I’m rapidly reaching the point where I’m 100% certain that anybody I lead a lynch against is Town…
[QUOTE=HazelNutCoffee]
Yeah, but even if it was your “town half,” you were only able to feel “bad” about the dotchan lynch because you KNEW she was town. No townie can be 100% certain about any lynch, barring an investigative role with no percentage of failure.
Game’s a bit slow, but it’s to be expected since it’s the weekend, I suppose.
[/QUOTE]
I was, as scum, basking in the revelation of power roles (until I decided I wanted to shoot myself over the flip-a-coin-wifom), which meant that whether or not she came up scum, as a townie I would have been pissed.
[QUOTE=Darth Sensitive]
That was a beautiful move in three handed.
[/QUOTE]
Thanks! It’s the type of move you can only get away with in three handed mafia and I don’t think it will ever work again.
But it was fun. 
[QUOTE=HazelNutCoffee]
It would be fun if someone created an archive of sorts for the mafia games
[/QUOTE]
For the moment, there’s this:
Mafia The Game III: Kinder and Gentler
M3 Forbidden Thread
Mafia V: The Cult of Sekham
M5 Forbidden Thread
You-Solve-It Mafia Game
Y-S-I Forbidden Thread
The Mob is Recruiting
TMIR Fobidden Thread
All other games can be found on the off-board site (which is down at the moment, so expect an error message for a bit…)
Thanks for confirming that it is not necessarily my employer trying to lock me out of the off-board site. Always a lingering fear…
[QUOTE=ComeToTheDarkSideWeHaveCookies]
Thanks for confirming that it is not necessarily my employer trying to lock me out of the off-board site. Always a lingering fear…
[/QUOTE]
And thank you for confirming the same for me.
And thank you both for making me feel better. I was getting worried.
Yes - the downness of the offboard site makes me sad. I know that you all are plotting to lynch me!
[QUOTE=Darth Sensitive]
Yes - the downness of the offboard site makes me sad. I know that you all are plotting to lynch me!
[/QUOTE]
Now I feel like I jinxed us all by saying I preferred the OB site because it was always up :smack: . Well and the search, which I still prefer
I’ve made the homeless inmates a temporary home here.
What’s really ticking me off about it was how much work I had to do today…I was all jazzed about the fact that I wouldn’t be on there for several hours, so there’d be lots of new content for me to pour through and analyze. Grrr…
My, we’re certainly the little hijackers today, aren’t we?
Hal: your list forgot to include Mafia: The Conspiracy , and its associated thread.
How couldyou forget that one? It’s where I’m at my most sexiest!
I haven’t been able to contact Idle Thoughts, so there is no spoiler board to play in.
If not knowing details is causing you sleepless nights, send me a PM.
[QUOTE=sachertorte]
I haven’t been able to contact Idle Thoughts, so there is no spoiler board to play in.
If not knowing details is causing you sleepless nights, send me a PM.
[/QUOTE]
I am sure someone here can set you up with a proboard if you want it. (I don’t know how these things work myself, but I am told it is fairly simple.)
If I were a player, I’d be haranguing the mod about this (via PM of course): sach, exactly how are you evaluating “substantive” posts? It sounds like one of those fuzzy rules that I dislike.
I think I’ll watch this one without perfect knowledge. I’ll see how well I can detect scum without being in the game.
With 16 players, I expect there’s 4 scum. That’ll mean the town can afford 3 mislynches and 1 no-lynch. If there’s 5 scum, it’ll be 3 mislynches and 0 no-lynches. That’s hard, so there’s probably about 3 power roles (counting masons as 1 power role).
My guesses for most likely scum: hmm, no guess yet. Day 1 is always tough.