[QUOTE=CarnalK]
Why shit on it? I guess that varies from poster to poster. I would guess SOAP did it because he’s annoyed with Sampiro’s exhaustive narrative style. Would that be good enough for you? Should we have a sticky listing proper BBQ Pit posting motives?
…
To quote the rules we are so fond of:
‘’’
[/QUOTE]
I’m not talking about rules here. I’m talking about decent human behavior. Look, I think our society has gone way overboard in what you could call artificial niceness. It’s gotten to the point that no one will ever tell you if they don’t like what you’re doing (even though not knowing may cost you all kinds of problems later on), and people won’t even allow you to make a realistic assessment of your own weaker points without whining “Oh, don’t put yourself down!” I want to slap people silly over that one sometimes.
BUT heaven forbid we should allow consideration to interfere with literary criticism? Or the ultra coolness that allows us to be ironic, bored and indifferent (publicly) about anything, even the death of good old Mom, right? No, can’t let anything interfere with those.
Of course, I don’t know what I’m expecting from someone who describes that thread as a “3-part 10 page opus to bitch about fucking funeral arrangements? If you need to self publish, get a goddamn LJ account.” Obviously, your literary criticism and your coolness are *far * more important.
[QUOTE=CarnalK]
Believe it or not but I’m not planning to share my Mother’s death on this message board. Regardless, why is the “BBQ Pit” such a great place to post about it? Though in fairness, I have argued before that they should change that MPSIMS forum’s fucking name. People like yourself apparently take it real serious.
[/QUOTE]
You know, I don’t plan to post about the death of my Mom here either. So what? People cope in different ways. I don’t really give a shit whether you thought Sampiro was being tacky, or attention-whoring or what. The fact is, he was writing about events that, even though he described them in a somewhat humorous fashion, he made very clear were quite serious and very painful to him. I’m not asking that you or anyone else give him sympathy. I *do * ask that you refrain from shitting on him under the circumstances, and that includes telling him that you lack the interest to be bothered to read his post because it would take too much of your oh-so-precious time. And I really don’t think that’s too much to ask, even on a fucking message board!
This thread has been extremely useful to me, in that it has told me some of the people who I can count on to be really shitty when the chips are down. I’m really quite grateful in that respect.
ETF, my understanding is that judgement and judgment are both accepted these days.