Soda:
Since I’ve already posted on the subject, I might as well follow up with some more advice based on your new input.
I think you’re on the right track here. Taking some time off is a good step. But keep in mind the following:
Yes, he probably does truly love you at the moment. And he may truly love you a month from now. But love is subject to the strains and pressures of life. He could move in with you in October, and then change his mind and move back in with his wife in December. Passion doesn’t last. Sooner or later every relationship gets to that point where passion fades and a comfortable routine sets in. And that’s when you’re going to be in trouble.
You said in your first post on the subject that “He wasn’t unhappy before he met me.” I take that to mean that his relationship with his wife was basically okay or humdrum, but he’s now grabbing an opportunity to “trade up” to someone (you) who inspires more passion in him. That bothers me because most husbands get one or even many opportunities to “trade up” during a marriage but don’t do it. Most husbands understand that their commitments to the wife and family override the lure of the opportunity to trade up.
Here’s my own personal experience: I was married for ten years and then divorced my wife. During the ten years of marriage I had several opportunities to trade up to more passionate relationships, but I didn’t take them. I only divorced my wife when our marriage turned into a war zone and stayed that way for a couple years. And even then it tore my heart out to end the relationship, because my commitment to my wife still mattered to me even when I hated her. And when I say “commitment,” I don’t just mean wedding vows. I mean our history together, our plans for the future, our investments and purchases together, our upcoming vacations, our routines together and mutual support for each other when one of us was in trouble (even when we were feuding), and so on and so on. And I can’t even imagine what it would have been like if we had had children.
So I speak from experience. Normal people just don’t walk away from commitments of that magnitude simply because they see an opportunity to trade up. Based on the little bit that you’ve said about his relationship with his wife, I have to assume that he has no respect for his commitments, and that your relationship with him isn’t going to last past the point when the bloom wears off the rose.
If your boyfriend is taking the opportunity to trade up, then that means that his commitments are relatively unimportant to him. He is going to act on his whims. He loves you now, so he wants to be with you now. What happens when the passion inevitably fades and other opportunities arise, or when he awakens to the fact that he has a child in the world? What happens when the daily grind of life (legal proceedings, divorce, alimony and child support payments, gossipy neighbors, or a new job elsewhere) make it easier to leave you than stay with you? Based on his past history he certainly isn’t going to stick around out of a sense of commitment to the promises he has made you. After all, he made the same promises and more to his wife, and they aren’t doing her much good now.
I’m all in favor of passion and true love. An offer of genuine passion and love shouldn’t be discarded lightly. But I also think that you have to keep your eyes open for warning signs. Consumer beware. Yes, he probably does indeed truly love you right now. But if he has no respect for commitment, then he’s not going to be around for you once the passion wears thin and the daily grind of routine life together kicks in.
So here’s my advice. If you get back together in a month, then consider my previous advice about keeping it on the level of a fling. Keep your investment in your relationship with him to the minimum possible. Do the fling thing, just as a last line of defense against almost inevitable (in my opinion) disaster.
Okay, I’m all done. The month-long break is a good start. And I wish you the best of luck, whatever path you choose.