Just a few observations…
The excellent point has been raised by several folks about the basic rudeness and arrogance of dictating to others what their dietary observances should be. Yeah, some of my friends are strict vegetarians and when they’re in my home, damned well better believe they’ll be able to eat everything served, w/o fanfare or hoopla. And anyone with an ounce of ingenuity and a titch of effort can make a dynamite meal that doesn’t have a scrap of meat products in it.(Though I must admit avoiding dairy products is a major hurdle. Soy etc. alternatives to eggs, milk and cheese just don’t get it from a taste and texture viewpoint, and they can be tricky to use as substitutes. And it’s truly amazing how many “ingredients” contain animal products that you’d never realize if you didn’t look.) But to continue…
Hey, if you do it right, you can serve a deliriously great meal and carnivores won’t even notice or miss the absence of meat. It doesn’t have to turn into a huge, ugly war. IMO, it’s the same basic courtesy that says you don’t serve shellfish and/or pork products to Jews who keep kosher, beef to Hindus, etc.
I have great admiration for Linda McCartney, Alix Kates Shulman, and a lot of the other vegetarians who demonstrated that vegetarian eating can be flat-out delicious as well as healthy and–if one is receptive to it–moral as well. They showed that vegetarian cuisine isn’t one of deprivation; rather, it can be an immensely subtle, varied and delicious cuisine.
Using the tritest of food cliches, honey attracts more flies than vineagar. Or to put it another way, good eats gain more converts than lectures.
That said, I do want to just respond to Opal’s analogy of farm animals w/ slaves. No flame, just a resonse! Slaves were human beings, who were capable of wanted nothing more than self-ownership and self determination. Animals don’t have that capablity. Animals ARE dependent on the care, or at least self restraint, of human kind.
I raised the issue solely to illuminate two points:
- feedlots and slaughter houses are damned ugly places. Many defiant carnivores base their stance on a sheltered, sanitized distance. It IS quite another thing to see and know that animals are killed, bled out, gutted and dressed to fill those tidy, white, sanitary meat cases.
- the farm animals are totally dependent on human effort, support and financial investment. I “own” animals (who have me firmly wrapped around their paws) but the plain fact is, very VERY few people would have the desire or resouces to support swine and cattle herds, etc. if they couldn’t pay for themselves w/ their lives and flesh.
These comments are intended as observations, not value judgments. But I DO maintain that they are facts that should be considered somewhere in the debate.
Braving a flagrant statement of opinion (but hey, what better place than the Pit?) anyone who judges other people on what they eat is just plain tacky. Quoting others who said it a lot better, not to mention briefly, what the hell happened to manners?
Veb