I may be dumping my most beloved sister (long, rambling, depressing)

As I’ve mentioned in a few threads, I come from a fairly large family. When we were growing up, I was closest to my sister “Lindy,” seven years my senior. We just got along really well; we clicked. There was never any doubt in my mind that she simply adored me more than she adored my other brothers and sisters, and likewise she knew she was my favorite. She’s always the person I list as my emergency contact; her daughter is my life insurance beneficiary; for years she was the first person I’d call when in danger, trouble, or distress. Because our mother had so much on her plate when we were children, Lindy largely raised me – not out of obligation, but out of love.

But the worm has turned.

Lindy is a racist, you see. A virulent one. She’d deny it, but a prime part of her defense is that it’s impossible for black people to be racists–a common claim I personally feel to be (a) moving the goal posts and (b) bullshit. She doesn’t use pejorative terms like “honky” or the like about or towards white people. She does, however, consider them evil, and any political or social conversation we have will inevitably include her blaming any problem the evils of White America. She didn’t go to one of our favorite cousin’s wedding because he was marrying an redheaded Irishwoman.

Lindy is also a fundamentalist Christian. Well, Pentecostal, anyway. Her church (the same one I was raised in) teaches Biblical literalism and hellfire and the damnation of fags and dykes–everything you’d expect. She thinks – no, let me change that, she WORRIES, she FEARS – that I’m going to hell because I belong to a church that teaches that the Bible is mostly metaphor and myth and history, and that each individual has the responsibility to figure out her or his own path.

As you may be able to tell, this has been bugging me for a while. It got worse around the end of last year, when our mother was in her final illness and all of the Rhymers were quite stressed; we had a couple of screaming arguments. The worst of these was when I was reporting to Lindy and the rest of my siblings the doctors’ report on Mother’s cancer, which has begun as breast cancer (requiring a double mastectomy) but had progressed to tumors in both hip bones, one shoulder bone, one thigh – and, well, you see where this is going. The doctor had described a course of treatment that was basically palliative, meant to make Mother as comfortable as possible in the time she had left. I hadn’t argued, because during his presentation I had the sickening realization that I’d heard all this before, in the same hospital, when my former girlfriend’s mother was dying.

Anyway, I took copious notes (the doctor commented on the salience of my questions and deduced that I’d already gone through this) and made copies for my siblings and aunts. Lindy got angry because, she said, we couldn’t trust Mother’s doctors because they were white and likely to use her as a guinea pig. She screamed this at me, and I told her I didn’t appreciate her taking her anger at the doctors, fate, the world on me.

Mom died in October. Two large parts of the reason I managed to get through it (though grief is still killing me, to tell you the truth) are the Straight Dope and my (then new) girlfriend “Beth.” Beth (who’s white, and a good deal younger than me) worked hard to keep me from screwing up work while I was most incoherent. The Dope helped because I posted about my grief at the time, and **NuttyBunny ** suggested I write Mother a letter and place it in her coffin to get out my feelings.

I took that advice.

All of which leads to what’s happened in the last two weeks. First of all, I called Lindy Saturday evening because I’ve been trying to recapture our former closeness. I mentioned that I’d just had dinner at Beth. Asked about her day, Jeanie proceeded to inveigh against how all white people in county government are evil and determined to screw all the non-whites. Referring to specific celebrated case hereabouts, she harped on the “fact” that, while not all white people seem evil, none of them can be trusted.

Most of this I ignored, because I’m used to it. But last night –

Last night we had dinner at another sister’s house. Beth was one of two non-Rhymers present. The other was “Bobby,” pastor of the church we grew up in. He’s one of the few ministers of that denomination I can stand. At any rate, during the evening, I talked privately, the way people do. He mentioned to me that he was worried about my immortal soul, because he was told that I didn’t believe in the afterlife or resurrection, and, of course, disbelieving in Heaven and Hell is a sin. I needed to get away from my church if those are its teachings, he said.

Bobby didn’t seem conscious of the irony of his approach. But what concerned me more is that I’ve never had a discussion about my spiritual beliefs with him, or for that matter with any of my blood relatives. Moreover, in his lecture to me, he specifically referred to my finding comfort in the thought of my mother’s body decaying and becoming part of the earth again, and her thus becoming flowers and earthworms and birds trees and so forth. So I asked him how he knew this, and he said Lindy told him. I asked him how Lindy possibly knew, and he didn’t answer.

Beth, looking fairly miserable, said that she thought she knew.

Remember the letter I mentioned earlier? That specific imagery was mentioned in it. I spent days writing it, and Lindy had asked at on point if she might read it. I told her no; it was private, and no one but me would ever see it. (Which includes Beth, by the way.) Shortly before Mother’s funeral-- after the casket was placed in the church but before it was closed and before the service started – I put the letter, in an envelope, in the coffin. A little overwhelmed I went outside. Beth stayed inside the church, either because she figured I needed space or she was a little tired of standing beside her drama queen boyfriend. Being inside, she saw Lindy when she came to the church a little while later. Lindy, she said, had placed a flower in the casket–but it also looked like she took something out. Beth had wondered about it but chosen to keep her thoughts to herself. She wasn’t sure of what she’d seen, and she didn’t want to borrow trouble; and she was a chary of confronting Lindy herself, as she finds her intimidating.

I wasn’t chary. . I was pissed. I went to talk to Lindy. I asked her if she’d taken my letter to Mother out of the casket and read it. She hesitated a minute and said yes. She was worried about my salvation, she said; she didn’t want me to go to Hell when I died; she wanted me in Heaven with her. Anything she had to do to accomplish that, she would do.

So Beth and I left at that point. And right now I feel like saying “Put a fork in me, sis. I’m done.”

She put the letter back after, right?

I think not, but I didn’t ask. I don’t care.

Wow, that is just about the most awful thing a sibling could do to you. I’m so sorry. My thoughts waiver between forgiveness and cutting her off completely. Whatever you ultimately decide I think a good long break would be adviseable.

I’m so sorry that happened to you. You have my sympathies on the loss of your mother and the loss of the sister you thought you had.

I was going to post that I could understand why she might talk to her pastor about her concerns for your soul. Not that that excuses being annoying about it. But what she did with the letter is just WRONG. Nothing excuses that. She had no right to violate your trust like that. I’m so sorry you’re having to go through this hurt, on top of the pain of losing your mother.

I don’t really know if there’s anything anybody can tell you that will make it any better, and I don’t know if your relationship with your sister can be healed, but is there a way for you to back away from it for a while, without cutting things off altogether? I just hate to see family members lose each other forever, if they don’t have to. Maybe some breathing room, and then see how things look?

Do you mind if I pray for the two of you?

My condolences on the loss of your mother. May your heart’s sadness heal with time.

My condolences on the loss of your sister. May your heart’s anger subside over time, even if you find forgiveness for a betrayal that profound, impossible.

If I were in your shoes, any forgiveness for this act would come in the form of a similar letter, placed in Lindy’s coffin.*

  • When and if she died before me. I’m not implying I would hasten the event.

My God. The nerve of your sister.

I think you need a break from her. Whether you ever reconcile with her is up to you, but start by having a bit of life without her in it, and see how you like it.

If I were in your shoes, I probably would’ve verbally ripped her a new one for even daring to invade on the privacy of your last goodbye to your mother. Her fundamentalist beliefs are being used as a crutch to foster the idea that it wasn’t a betrayal in her mind, and, well, she needs to know that something like that is NO EXCUSE for what she did, especially since she not only invaded your privacy, but decided to spread it around as if it were fashionable gossip. Yes, she only talked to her pastor, but even that is too far, as he approached you.

Forgive her if you feel you need to, but at the same time, make it absolutely clear that she did something that is despicable and tough to forgive under any circumstances.

If/When you talk to Lindy, you might want to leave out the part about Beth seeing her take the letter.

Wow, that’s just–words fail me at the moment, but what an incredibly insensitive and invasive thing to do! What entitles your sister to violate your privacy at such a time, using the flimsy excuse that she wants to secure her own peace of mind regarding your eventual spiritual disposition? What in hell makes her think it’s all about her? Why in hell do these professed christians have so little trust in their own god that they can’t leave salvation to the entity that’s supposed to oversee such things? Are they so shaky in their own faith and so doubting of the invincibility and rightness of their stance that they can brook no dissent, no difference of viewpoint?

I’m so sorry–you must be feeling incredibly betrayed right now, not to mention bereft…

Were I in your shoes I don’t think I’d be able to deal civilly with her for a very long time, if ever. Maybe you’re a better person than I am and can forgive her, but if it helps even a bit there’s at least one person in the world who does consider what she’s done to be unforgiveable, regardless of her motives.

I’m sending you a hug, sounds like you could use it…

Thanks for the comment. I actually wrote the OP a week ago, as I wanted to calm down a trifle before sharing it, so I’m not boiling with rage this moment. My apologies for not making that clear earlier.

I think you need to sit down with yourself and have a long discussion about where your boundaries are with Lindy. Then sit down with Lindy and tell her where your boundaries are with her. Make it crystal clear to her that they aren’t negotiable, and what the consequences will be for her stepping on them. If she won’t accept that you can and will set boundaries with her, then you need to decide what the consequences for that will be. If you can have limited contact with her (say, Christmas and birthdays) and not feel like you are compromising your principles, then go for it. If you don’t feel like you can have any contact with her at all, then that’s what you need to do. She really is acting badly.

(Who’s “Jeanie?” :slight_smile: )

Like hell I will. Part of the reason I’m vexed is that she’s not being at all subtle about her opinion that I need a non-Beth (i.e., non-white) girlfriend to Beth as well as to me. Plus I pretty much asked her if Beth was right about what she thought she saw when I confronted her the first time.

Wow, dude, that’s just unbelieveable.

So you only confronted her that one time? I agree that you need a long discussion with her about boundries, as well as one about how she needs to accept both Beth and your religion. That’s pretty heinous behavior.

I suspected as much, even if you hadn’t mentioned it. This is not cool either, as I’m sure you know.

Is she trying to mother you? Does she think she’s doing this stuff for your own good?

I’m glad you took the time to distance a bit, but the pain is still showing through–the hug still stands!

As for Lindy’s stance on Beth, what a pile of shit. I understand the motivation behind it abstractly, I guess, but it seems to me that we don’t have a lot of choice in who we love and that loving someone transcends such ultimately immaterial things as race or gender. I suppose it would be convenient if we could just find the “right” person by some outwardly imposed set of rules and then flip the “love switch” to fixate us on that correct personage, but until we develop such a handy feature there are going to be an awful lot of relationships that seem inappropriate to those not directly involved. Seems to me that a healthy dose of “it ain’t my business” would do everyone involved in such a case a world of good.

Sounds to me like your sister has her head wedged firmly up her ass and needs a good dose of the old clue by four.

My sincere condolences.

If I were you, I wouldn’t write her out of my life permanently. But I would definitely estrange myself. Let any reconciliation initiate from her end. She needs to know the severity of her actions. And when she does come around (if she loves you, she will) you need to let her know that her prejudice puts a wedge between the two of you and so she needs to put a check on the racist commentary.

You’re probably not going to be able to reason her out her paranoia for your soul or her views about white people. But for the good of your relationship, she needs to respect and accept who you are and the things that you stand for.

I’m not involved in this, but from what I’ve seen of my own experiences, I’d think that she thinks she’s doing these things because she “knows” what’s best for her brother, and it’s not what she sees. Sometimes people with such small and close minded worldviews are so thoroughly convinced that what they think or do is right that everyone should do/think just like them.

If this is the case, he may never get through to her, and she’ll think that she’s the victim in all of this. After all, she was “only doing what’s best” for her brother. :frowning:

He may never change her world view, but he can inform her of how her bad behavior hurt him. Whatever it takes to get her to understand that.