Michelle Pfeiffer. Aged (hers) 18 to present.
Charlize would be OK too.
I like you.
That’s it right there,(except for the hymen stuff :)) for me it would be Jena Malone but she is a similar age to me. I’ve had a crush on her since I was 15.
Can we form a line, here?
As he was once described, “the thinking woman’s British crumpet.”
I’m kind of surprised somebody already said it… Jodie Foster.
Nicole Kidman if she would dance in the rain in a mini skirt first.
Mary Poppins was pretty hot too. You know she had black thigh highs
on under there.
Alice Cooper, circa 1974. Hell, I wouldn’t kick him out of bed now and it’s been so long since I’ve had sex that I’m practically re-virginated. So, Coop, call me.
Grace Kelly,
or Carolyn Jones (Morticia Addams)
My fantasy was always to lose it to Slash and Axl Rose from Guns N Roses AT THE SAME TIME!!! Dirty little fifth grader! :o
Yes, and when I was in 7th grade, an 18 yo was as old as my parents.
I think the rule should have been “of legal age”. I’ll sign up for Johnny Deep, but he should be 15 or 16, not college-age!
Another one for Paul McCartney back in the day. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Monica Bellucci. Wow wee!
Why that’s an easy one for me. I like him clean shaven much better. I can’t think of anyone much cuter than Gael García Bernal …gawd is he hot!! 
And here he is: Gael García Bernal
Amy Linker. No, wait… Andrea Elson. No, wait… Andrea Barber.
But seriously folks. Bananarama. Or, if forced to choose just one, Keren Woodward circa 1986.
I read this *way *too quickly and thought you wrote “Art Linkletter.”
Well, kids do say the darndest things.
Marylin Monroe or Cleopatra. I’m not picky.
Is it weird that the first thought was an actual fictional character…?
It would definitely have to be Julian Casablancas! -sigh- Anytime, but now days, he’s got me by the jaw!
Danny Kaye, please.