Suppose you were convicted, rightly or wrongly, of a capital crime, and sentenced to die. You’ve exhausted every appeal and the time of your demise is nigh. However, wherever you live has a new rule that says that while there is capital punishment, the prisoner chooses their method of execution.
There is no trick that gets you out of dying, you;re done for. How do you wanna go?
Either rifle/shotgun right behind the head or injection. For injection, what veterinarians typically use for euthanasia or high amounts of opiates. I don’t suppose I’d be allowed to go out with a “party mix” lethal injection.
The firing squad just seems like a more dignified way to die, compared to the alternatives. You get to die standing up, and you’re killed by men, not by a machine. Plus it’s fast and fairly painless, relatively speaking.
I sure wouldn’t trust the firing squad to put the bullets in the right place for a fast and fairly painless death; in fact it seems that every firing squad shooting always puts bullets in the torso or abdomen rather than the head.
Guillotine seems quick and pretty foolproof. Most mornings I lie in bed a while before I have to get up, and I imagine myself being beheaded. Sometimes I’m on my back, watching the blade plummet to my neck
Why yes, I’m a skosh depressed, why do you ask? Also I’m of French ancestry. Maybe that contributes to my fascination with the guillotine.
Firing squad has a certain romance to it, though. As Ambrose Bierce wrote, “if you hear of my being stood up against a Mexican stone wall and shot to rags please know that I think that a pretty good way to depart this life.”
“In bed, with a hooker. When I’m 80.” Paraphrasing Tyrion. Or in a British movie (I think this was Meaning of Life) we were told that “this man is about to die” while being chased off a cliff by a pack of shirtless nubiles of his preferred sex (female, in both of our cases).
But if someone asked me about a reasonable method, I would pick the guillotine. Supposedly you would experience a few moments of unspeakable distress, but it would still be quick.