In which things end badly...or, the Conclusion of the Friendship

First of all, mucho thanks to everyone for giving me hugs and support and advice. I’m always in need of perspective. You’ve made me smile, which is nice right now. Thank you.

A few things to clarify:

First, the e-mail may have seemed vague, but I’d told him all that stuff Saturday, during our “discussion.” But he wasn’t listening. Everytime I said, “James, you hurt me…” he would interrupt. When I tried to explain why I was hurt, he would call me immature and say I was being overly dramatic. That e-mail was the summation of what he already knows, what I’ve already told him several times. I just thought that being straightforward in that reply was the best way to get my point across.

Why do I feel betrayed? I was always honest to him about my feelings. But he used them against me to make himself look like a hero to Nancy. I spoke to her right before I left, and she wasn’t angry. She hadn’t thought I was mean to her when I walked away. James created this little drama so she would see him as a shining knight, and he did it using my honesty and openness. And then he accused me of having ulterior motives.

Also, after he told me he didn’t love me, I didn’t stop loving him, but I did realize that it wouldn’t happen. I waffled on the issue of leaving, and finally decided to stay until school ends for the semester so I would not have added stress. I have three weeks to go now. When I told him I was leaving IKEA, he begged me to stay. I mean, he literally cried because he didn’t want to lose our friendship.

The things I did for him as a friend were no different from the things I do for other people. I’m a giving person (more often than not, a pushover). A week before his party, I had one for A. I bought him a nice present, but I do that for everyone. I am, at heart, a realist. I understood that he wouldn’t love me (like weirddave said, he doesn’t believe that friends can ever be anything more) and did my best to deal with it. I foolishly believed that it would all work out, but I never believed anything romantic would happen between us.

I’ve had this happen before to me: a close friend (who was gay, so the love thing never played a part) basically used me when it was conveniant for him. I had a lot of fun with him and we had been friends, on and off, throughout our childhood, so it seemed natural. I let his opinion of me matter more than my opinion of myself. I let him be my friend when it was good for him and allowed him to make me feel like less of a person. I did this same thing with James. The only way I handled the other situation was by cutting him out of my life. I think it’s the only thing I can do now.

In retrospect, I truly believe that it was like an ego boast for James to have me around. As my manager said, “James is not-so-humble…okay, he’s an arrogant prick.” I never realized that before, but now I see it. He has qualities that I admire, but he’s very willing to use those qualities to cut me down when it suits him. I was a reminder to him that someone thinks he’s wonderful, so he wanted me to stay, so he cried and told me not to leave. But when I exhibited actual human feelings in the matter (instead of being some sort of robot), I was in the way.

I’m trying to rationalize all this, but it’s hard. This whole matter has left me with a bad taste in my mouth. At the same time, though, it’s solidified what I know about myself to be true. As I said, I know what kind of person I am, and James is not going to compromise that. I still need to work on being a pushover and having more faith in myself, but I have time for that.

Steve, I’m trying hard to be a bad-ass ninja rock star, but I may have to take a leave of absence from the post while my poor heart recovers.

“These boots are made for walkin’, and that’s just what they’ll do. And one of these days these boots are gonna walk all over you.”

God help me, but that’s the first thing that came to my mind when I read that note.

{Sarah} You go, girl!

I have to say, I too have been through this.

On the side of you, Sarah, and also on the side of Nancy, kinda.

There was a thread about my situation a while back, too. I just wanted to say that going up to Nancy and telling her what was going on, making it clear it wasn’t anything against her and that you didn’t want to hurt her gained you some HUGE respect in my eyes.

And although it might be weird for her, it’s much better than the REALLY hurtful alternative, trust me.

If ya ever feel like chatting, just email me.

Bah. Your bad-assedness is quite apparent in this thread, so :stuck_out_tongue: to that idea.

What kind of a world would we live in if ninjas couldn’t cry? :wink:

Manda JO, where were you when I was going through my turbulent love life learning this slowly and painfully? I am now married to a man in a wonderful honest relationship that is the best thing in my life, but it was so many years getting to this stage.

Listen to her, Sara. It’s so true. Give yourself a week or two to wallow in might-have-beens, then move on - you deserve happiness.

oh sara, i’m sorry this happened. from what you posted you were honest and forthright, not a surprize to those that know you here. i believe that you acted correctly. telling nancy that there maybe times you would disappear and why was fantastic. you did all you could to protect yourself and your feelings without stomping on the feelings of others. unfortunately james was unable to be as forthright. i think you are quite right in breaking the relationship totally. time to put yourself first. you can do it.

Probably in the slow and painful line myself. Our culture celebrates the long, drawn-out, drama-heavy, angst ridden love affair so much that I think we are all half convinced that if it dosen’t hurt, it isn’t love. Furthermore, it has to last at least two seasones of 22 new episiodes before actual culmination for it to count.

I bought that idea, and I spent years moping after guys (one in particular) and it never once occured to me “You know, if this thing were gonna work out, it would have by now.” Nope, the fact that I spent years pining just made it all the more special, all the more a sure thing. (Writing this actually makes me cringe a bit. 'Nother decade or so I will be able to relate the story without even a twinge of embaresment). Furthermore, we convince ourselves that it can’t be over until we get the big “closure” episode, so we hang around, moping, waiting for a sign from god that we should move on.
When I met my husband, it was so totally different than that. It was so easy. We liked each other; we admired each other; we had everything in common; our egos were never in the way; we had the same idea of what a “relationship” was. Everything clicked in a matter of weeks, and I’ve learned that you don’t have to “hurt the ones you love the most” and that the course of true love can run smooth. So while there certainly is a place in this world for people who like turmoil and turbulant relationships, it isn’t the only game out there. My husband dosen’t love me less just cause he’s never broken my heart.

Sarah, honey…I am SO sorry you are having to go through this. Being honest can really come back to haunt you, but in the long run it is the only way to live. With time and perspective, you will realize that being honest with both James AND Nancy, although they weren’t (or at least HE wasn’t) mature enough to understand or accept this in the spirit it was offered…well, you STILL did the honorable thing. I know this doesn’t help much at the moment, though.

(((((Sarah)))))

You know where to reach me, sweetie. I’m here for you if you want to talk.

Much Love,

Cheri

Sara,

I was in the same spot as you, with only two differences: the other girl was my best friend, and I didn’t trust myself enough to tell the guy to piss off. The result was a two year long sturm und drang that I still carry the scars from.

You did the right thing. Not just the right thing, but the classy, womanish, stand-up, ballsy thing to do. I am impressed as all hell.

I can’t say I’ve been in the unrequited love situation, but I have been in the “this person is wonderful and can do no wrong”. I think you should listen to your manager and take off the rose coloured specs? It will only do you good Nacho, believe me, I’ve been there and thought “this person is wonderful and I really dont mind being walked over”, then I took off my specs and saw what everyone else saw. He’s really pushed the friendship by treating you the way he did after the Nancy incident. Cooling the friendship and moving on and making other friends is really what’s needed here. I know it’s easier said than done but try for the sake of your sanity k?
Good luck
eirroc

Hell, I’m proud of you. If I had half the self-confidence you have at your age, I probably wouldn’t have gone through most of the crap I did through most of my twenties.

Chalk this up to a big learning experience. Not all “wonderful and good” guys are always so (amazing what love blocks from your vision, eh?), but don’t let this make you too cynical, either. I’m glad that you didn’t let this linger longer, as others may have done. If you’re an honest and straight-forward person, then the romanticized unrequited love thing just isn’t for you.

Manda JO has it so right about finding the right person–when you do, everything clicks right into place.