I've transformed into a hottie (longish)

This weekend, apparently. After several months of no luck at all with women, and a subsequent shattershot approach to online dating (four or five e-mail, phone, texting “relationships” active at all times, plus four or five women whom I’ve already gone out with recently on first- and second-dates with), I’ve hit the dating jackpot in the past day or so:

  1. Thursday night, I meet a woman (from one of the sites) for a drink. We’d been flirting online, and she seemed unusually enthusiastic about the pics I’d posted. Me not so much, since she had posted a single pic that barely showed her face. Turned out she was pretty good-looking, and when we went up to the bar to fetch our second round of drinks, she says to me, “I think I’m going to have to kiss you.” I go, “Maybe it’s a little soon?” and she looks hurt so when we get back to our table, I plant one on her before she sits down, and then later when we leave the restaurant, there is another hour or so of further kissing in her car, the space limitations of which prevent much more from happening, but she wants to see me again “very soon” in more spacious and private surroundings. Next morning she texts me a dozen times, trying to arrange a rendezvous, but I persuade her that her job, my job, the thirty miles between her location and mine, traffic jams, etc. stand in the way. So we’re on to get together this weekend.

  2. Friday night (last night) I get a call from another of my dating-site correspondents, a rather strange one in that we had actually dated ten years or so ago, and I’d contacted her because I didn’t recognize her from her pics (she’d gone from a long-haired blonde to a close-cropped brunette). She was under the (partly correct) assumption that we had broken up because she’d pissed me off, and I assured her that bygones were bygones. She said “Let’s meet sometime,” and Friday night was “sometime.” She asked if she could drop by for a drink, so I thought “What harm could be in one drink?”–when she got here she started telling me how damned attractive I had gotten (I’ve lost 50 pounds in the last year or so) and starting in again telling me how sorry she was for pissing me off and how she’d like to try again, so we indulged ourselves, and parted at 2 AM.

  3. This was all happening in the context of another woman whom I’d gone out with on two dates (dinner date and theater date) before, whom I liked a lot, telling me that she was interested in me but needed a little time to decide how serious she wanted to be. Usually, this kind of talk bodes ill, prefacing a decision not to get more serious with me, but no, on friday afternoon, she phoned, and started pressing me to see her again soon, after a week of “thinking it over.” She sounded like she had decided to get serious with me, the difference being that now I had this woman from Thursday night (and would very soon have this other woman from Friday night) expressing fairly urgent and explicit desires to start some heavy-duty romantic stuff with me.

But wait, it gets worse–earlier this week, I heard from

  1. the woman I had yearned for and dated the last few months of 2009 who kept breaking up with me and then starting up with me and breaking up again. (I’ve written some previous posts about how heartwretching it was for me to endure this, as I was really crazy about her.) We’d kept in touch since the last breakup (in January) and I 'd been having little luck dating on-line since January, but a few days ago she said she “was reconsidering our breakup,” and she missed me and was thinking she’d made a terrible mistake. I told her I didn’t want to go through another breakup with her and her commitment issues, and she agreed–she said she would give it some more thought, and decide whether she could or couldn’t make a real commitment this time. We’ve agreed that certain tangible signs of real commitment needed to be there this time–her being willing to spend whole weekends with me, her introducing me to her family and friends as her new boyfriend, and most of all her willingness to turn down invitations from other guys to go out on dates while dating me–she’d kept that option open (didn’t act on it, tho) while we were dating, and I foolishly put up with it. I thought I was being cool and open-minded, but it made me into a gibbering ball of jealousy and insecurity. So I told her, “Sure, think it over, and if you’re ready to commit, you know where to find me.”

So within the past few days, I’ve gone from a guy who has having a very hard time getting women to express any interest all (my best case being woman #3, who needed time to decide if she wanted to get serious) to a guy who now has four women expressing some advanced level of interest–my last two night’s dates, who are plainly available right now, and these two (somewhat hotter) women who have stepped up their thinking about getting romantically involved with me.

The problem, if this IS a problem, is that I don’t really enjoy being a player, and juggling women, or even in deceiving women, however mildly. I’m looking to get into a nice, stable monogamous relationship, and any of these fine, attractive, intelligent women would do perfectly. I would be jazzed if only one of these women had earlier taken the position that she’s taking now, but now I’m frazzled with the array of options before me.

My approach was a kind of “market” approach up until this point: to date as many women as I could keep straight, and hope that one of them turned out to be attractive and interested in me, and I’d been fairly self-critical about my failure recently to get one woman interested (which self-criticism has motivated my recent weight-loss, so it’s not a bad thing in itself.) But now the “market” is behaving irrationally and I find myself with a bewildering set of options. I’d gotten so accustomed to the “Market” telling me “Sorry, I don’t think we make a good couple,” “Sorry, no chemistry,” “Sorry, no spark. Good luck searching,” “Sorry, I’ve decided to go back to my ex-,” etc. that I’m really puzzled by my sudden good fortune. At least I knew what I needed to do when I was a coldie: keep trying. But now that I’ve suddenly burst into flame, I’ve no idea what I need to do.

The market is fickle and cyclical (ficklical?). This week, everyone is hot for your junk bonds. Next week, you may be back to Milken it yourself.

Congratulations on your good fortune.

I think you are looking at this the wrong way by expecting the women to weed themselves out due to disinterest. You need to be thinking about what YOU really want in a partner. Surely as you get to know these women better, there will be things about some of them that make them less than desirable partners. Be picky, you deserve to have a great woman. Have standards but have fun.

Be young, be foolish, but be careful.

The gratuitous downer for today is:

Women do that deliberately. Research in ongoing as to whether it is an innate ability or if therer is a comminications network they utilize to coordinate actions.

I’ve experienced pretty much the same thing. While I was single and not really looking for a relationship women were nice, but markedly uninterested. Once I found a woman that I wanted to get serious about, the week went something like the following.

Alice: We should get together sometime

Betty: There’s a concert Friday night

Charlotte: I cook a great lasagna, you should try it.

Debbie: My roomate and I are arguing about who gives the best bj. Will you help us out?
And on and on. They do it to drive us crazy.

When it rains, it pours. Somehow women know when a guy is in demand and they flock. Quite a bizarre phenomenon.

You really need to repost over on this thread: Share actual problems you’ve had that no one will ever sympathize with Share actual problems you've had that no one will ever sympathize with - In My Humble Opinion - Straight Dope Message Board

It’s some sort of alignment of the planets.

Man, has THAT ship sailed long ago. I’m 56.

I know, I read that thread title and thought “Perfect.”

In theory, sure. But a few slow months have made me adopt the scattershot approach–I weed 'em out as far as which one to correspond with, but once I rule them e-mail-worthy, the next move is up to them, I figure. Until this week, I didn’t have any choices to make. What I really needed to get was “laid.”

Pen, paper, 4 girls across the top

Rank each one in various categories

Hotness
brains
education
how much you like being with them
how much they seem to dig you
posess any other issues I am tolerating because I want to bang tem

something like
Girl A B C D
Hotness 1 3 2 4
Brains 1 2 3 4
education 2 3 4 1
digs me 2 4 3 1
dig them 3 1 4 2
issues 1 2 3 4

                    10                  15                19                  16

rank them ascending, descending, whatever come up with a dozen little things to rank

You will probably end up with a fairly clear cut top 2.

Personally I think the girl who already was an on and off again thing you just may want to let go, she had plenty of chances to keep you and chose not to, she probably thinks she can do better and you don’t want to be who she is “settling” for until Mr. Perfect shows up. I have been there, never had it come out well.

Same thing with the girl that pissed you off…maybe she is great and just did something stupid, if its an ongoing behavior you might wanna scratch her off the list too. (example she is always late and a lateness issue was what upset you, that probably has not changed.)

What a wonderful problem to have.

That is why they call it, “Dating”. You don’t need to look at this like you are leading them along. You need to look at this like you need to figure out what each woman brings to the table and see if its a match for you. At the same time, don’t be dishonest with them either. Tell them openly and honest where you are in your relationship status and it will work out much easier.

Enjoy this time and sample the menu, so to speak, so you can see what you really want.

Oh, hey,** PRR**!
How you doin’, you sexy thing?
:wink:

As Richard Hell says: Love comes in spurts.

You keep using that word - I do not think it means what you think it means.

I agree that #4 should be off the table. She’s nuts and she didn’t treat you right the first time around.

I have a question about #1. You said she texted you a dozen times the next morning. Were you texting her back or did she send you multiple texts all in a row. Because if she did…ginormous red flag.

And congratulations on your newfound hottieness.

In fact, I find there’s a pretty satisfying feeling being able to reject someone who has treated you badly knowing you have other options currently available.

BTW, my suspicion is that there’s something in the water when this happens.

Men, too. I can go weeks without hearing from any of my fling type guys, but then all at once, I will be bombarded with texts from every direction. It’s crazy.

Good points. You shouldn’t need to struggle to work things out - it’s going to be smooth and easy with the right person.

I agree with some points already made; the flaky girl (#4) is flaky. I don’t know about #3, either - when you like someone, you like them, but taking a week to make up your mind isn’t too out there. I also agree that being honest with all of them is important, and thinking about what you want is key, too.

Congratulations on your hotness! I imagine things will work themselves out the way they should.

I texted her back, but it was like “Gotta get to work now,” and she’d be “Do u have 2? Play hooky w me? U cd b here by 10 AM,” like that all morning. The problem with eliminating #4 is that she’s off Drachillix’s chart for “I’d like to be with her” --she’s a 10 in that category (and for looks, and some others) while the others are like 3 or 4 at best–so she sweeps the **Drachillix **charts, but sadly is the least committed now. I will probably have a enormous discussion with her (“The train is pulling out of the station --do you want on or off? And if you bail this time, I think you’ll need to check straight into a mental ward, because I’m asking you to make a solid commitment this time, and to be pretty fucking sure you’re totally comfortable that this is what you want…” kind of talk) before opting for #s 1, 2, or 3, just to be sure that I’m not walking away from something I’ve wanted for months and months, and still I understand that I will be taking a tremendous chance there.