Yes, that is what i mean.
Looking at this from a pairing standpoint, i think it’s either cardinal and someone or jimmy and diver. If cardinal’s mafia I don’t have anything solid to say about which of scuba or jimmy is the partner (I, of course, am as pure as driven snow).
I was hoping cardinal would pop in to defend himself, but i seem to remember that he plays evenings. Since we’re probably at lynch or lose, I want to sit on my vote until i can hear him out.
Thinking about it some more, if we’re in the Jimmy/Diver scenario, we literally can’t lose. Suppose we’re in that scenario. ToDay, we lynch someone. If that someone is Jimmy, we win, game over. If that someone is anyone else at all, then they come up Town, and we don’t lose yet. The fact that we don’t lose is evidence that Diver must have been Scum after all, and since Jimmy vouched for him, it’s in turn evidence that Jimmy is Scum, and whoever the last two Townies are would naturally vote for him.
Unfortunately, we’re not in that scenario. We can lose. If someone would like to present a case for why me and Diver seem like we could have possibly been the two scum in cahoots I’d be glad to discuss it.
There’s two scum out there, not one, and that one isn’t me.
Anyway, it appears that we all agree that in any scenario where I’m scum, we can lynch me later. So at least there’s that.
Does anyone have a comment on whether they think Telcontar accepting my say-so about Diver might indicate that Telcontar already knew Diver was town?
I have a problem right now in that I don’t really feel like cardinal_fang has played a very scummy game. Off the top of my head, I might go so far as to say I think he’s played the least scummy, especially recently (that includes me; because I act like an idiot sometimes). I am accepting Chronos’ bona fides as a matter of faith, but in terms of having to vote just on feeling… I don’t see it with fang. I’m OK with that to some extent, since everybody at this point is in some kind of gray area, but I’d like to try to feel a little more solid about it. What I think is very important from town’s perspective, unfortunately, because right now I’m the power role – I know to a certainty that Diver was town. I know that and the two scum know that. Since that’s the case, I think my vote is going to end up pretty important, and right now, I don’t feel much conviction toward a fang vote. I think right this second I’d lean Telcontar, then Scuba.
Talk to me.
I don’t think there’s any need to make such a case, other than to acknowledge its theoretical possibility. If it is the case, then we’ll have very strong evidence for it toNight, but toDay, we don’t need to worry about it.
And for the record, my vote on cardinal is not based on my feeling… Frankly, I don’t trust my own hunches, and only provided them last page because someone asked for them. My vote on cardinal is because most of the pairings I consider plausible include him, and one of the two pairings that doesn’t involve him still leads to us winning after lynching him. Now, if you want to put together a case against Telcontar or Scuba, then I hope whoever’s alive toMorrow will take a good look at it, but for toDay, I think that cardinal is our best bet.
Cardinal doesn’t seem to have popped up. I think I’ll cast my vote now and leave open the possibility to reconsider based on what he says.
Vote cardinal
Jimmy, look at it this way. Assuming you’re telling the truth about diver and that you yourself aren’t mafia, two out of scuba, myself, and cardinal must be mafia. Which two do you think it is? Scuba and myself? that is implausible based on 2-3 days ago. Me and cardinal? it’s possible, but then a cardinal lynch is safe.
Jimmy, what do you think of scuba’s analysis? he says that, if you were scum, you would be motivated to claim that diver was scum regardless of his actual alignment. Do you agree?
HI guys, checking in.
I won’t have time to post anything substantive tonight, but I’ll wade in over the next day or two.
I see I have my work cut out for me, but I am going to do my level best because if we are indeed at LyLo and I am lynched, we lose. If it’s because I fell out of a computer analysis, then, well, so be it, but I don’t want it to be because I’m a bad player.
I can’t say I understand the pairings business at first glance but will look deeper tomorrow.
Also: happy trails, Meeko!
Jimmy, you’ve stood up for cardinal a fair bit now (insisting that we shouldn’t assume that at least one of you is Scum yesterDay and saying that he’s played the most pro-Town game toDay, off the top of my head). Would you care to give a detailed case why you think he’s Town?
(by the way, this thread feels really weird with so few people left. I keep thinking, “Where is everybody?”, then remembering that this is everybody)
Yeah. And we have way too much time for today, going to be really slow.
So, Jimmy and, presumably, cardinal are objecting to killing cardinal. The rest of us are comfortable with the idea. Not sure what to make of that.
That’s a bit of a strange way to approach gameplay, and no, not really; I mean, I don’t have a detailed case why I think he’s town. If I had one of those I’d have said something about it. What I have is a lack of a detailed case why I think he’s scum, same as I have for everyone else except you and dead people, and for the dead people I already know, and for you I do have a detailed case for why you’re town.
And, again, other than the scum, I’m the only one who knows that if I vote cardinal_fang and get it wrong, the game is over. Which is why I asked to be convinced of the case against him. It puts me in a strange place that you’ve taken my hesitation to stake the outcome of the entire game on fang being scum as a defense of fang. First all I was doing was whining about your system being unfair; now it turns out that what I was really doing was defending cardinal_fang.
Telcontar, that’s a reasonable enough argument. I suppose that ultimately that analysis is what it’s going to boil down to; I have plenty of time to end up making that decision in the end if it does. It can’t be you and Scuba, you’re saying, because you tried to get him lynched a couple of days ago, right?
Chronos, if I can get you to set aside your suspicion about me for just one second, and put yourself in my shoes: right now, there are three votes on fang. One of them, at least, if you have the privileged perspective that I have, you know to a certainty is a scum vote. Would you be inclined to conclude that that’s probably just the other scum protecting himself for the endgame scenario?
Because (still in my head here) it occurs to me that the scum can afford to be bold – they could, at least theoretically, jump right out and both vote along with one town vote, and that’s night-night for us. Do you see what my concern is there? Again, if you can just pretend for a second that I’m town, and tell me what you think (because I’m trusting you even if you don’t me)?
There’s plenty of time here and I don’t see the danger of thinking out loud, so that’s what I’m doing.
OK, then, put it this way. From your point of view (assuming you’re Town), you know there are two Scum left, and there are only three (or maybe four, counting me) people you’re unsure of. If you’re objecting to cardinal’s lynch, then that must mean you think that the two Scum are Telcontar and Scuba (or possibly one of those two and me). Would you care to make a case against Telcontar and Scuba? Or possibly a case against me?
FLASHBACK TO:
The Vote Count:
cardinal_fang (3) - Scuba_Ben, Chronos, Telecontar
Hard to keep up with such a fast-paced game, isn’t it, storyteller?
I’m a bit pressed for time but I think at this point I might as well stop pretending there’s some big events going on that are worth waiting around for. If cardinal is going to show up and make a case I’ll revisit it then.
My thinking is this: no, Chronos, I don’t have a great case for that pair as the scum, any more than I have a great case for anything at this point. I’m going to
vote cardinal_fang
because whatever recalcitrance I have is overcome by 1. the fact that I don’t have much else to work with and 2. the fact that if I put a vote out there for someone else, and they turn out to be town, that one vote is all the scum need to ensure a win if they switch late.
**Hey, guys.
Just checking in from vacation. Yeah, this Day is defintely too long, but I really want to be around for the end of it. I appreciate your understanding and I will be considerably shortening the Day/Night cycle when I get back.
Take a break if you want! :)**
Enjoy your vacation, man. Nobody’s paying you to do this!
Don’t I know it! 
In case it’ll help anyone reviewing the game, here’s my notes on what I considered significant events in the game:
Day/Night 1:
Start of Night Zero
Tom Scud considers lynch the lurker
Tom Scud considers random vote
Oredigger edits, considers mass claim
Tom Scud refines to name-claim only
Nanook edits
paul suggests mass claim of whether name matches role
Tom Scud claims his name matches alignment
Nanook claims name matches alignment
cardinal_fang claims can’t tell if name matches alignment
Meeko points out editing
pedescribe edits for irony
Start of Day 1; storyteller replaces GuyIncognito
storyteller analyzes mislynches, says that a Vig or Doc won’t increase number allowed
storyteller posts character summary
Chronos challenges storyteller’s mislynch analysis
Ichini finds storyteller’s summary helpful
Chronos asks about scum win condition
pedescribe votes Chronos for feigning ignorance of scum
Zeriel fingers pede for reaching on vote
pede unvotes Chronos after defense
Meeko walls pede, finds suspicion
pede votes Meeko for misrepresenting him
BillMC fingers Meeko for smudging pede
Jimmy Chitwood votes pede for on-and-off-again suspicion
Meeko votes pede, reasons not explained in this post
Jimmy Chitwood points out futility of asking about scum tells publicly
Ichini is pinged by storyteller for being helpful
Meeko unvotes pede, votes Jimmy Chitwood for post about public questions
Chronos votes Ichini for inconsistency on storyteller’s summary
BillMC votes Meeko as per previous FoS
Telcontar votes pede for looking like a new player
cardinal_fang votes pede for looking unexperienced
pede defends self as being a weak player
Meeko unvotes Jimmy, revotes pede
AllWalker votes Meeko for misrepresenting pede, BillMC
Tom Scud votes Meeko for misinterpreting arguments
Oredigger votes Meeko for misquoting
Meeko claims to be Sawyer
Oredigger claims name and alignment match
Imaginary Fiend claims name and alignment match
Telcontar claims name and alignment match
Chronos claims name and alignment match
Meeko quotes PM
pede thinks name and alignment match
Tom Scud keeps vote on Meeko to reduce noise level
Mahaloth tweaks rules to give Scum aliases
Tom Scud walls Imaginary Fiend, unvotes Meeko, votes Fiend for opposition to name-claim
ShadowFacts votes Telcontar for flip-flopping on pede
Zeriel votes Ichini for flip-flopping on storyteller
Oredigger unvotes Meeko, as not being a good target any more
Telcontar unvotes pede without automatically lynching Meeko, votes Imaginary Fiend for opposition to name-claim
Nanook votes Imaginary Fiend for opposition to name-claim
AllWalker suggests that Scum might not have said whether alignment matches name, unvotes Meeko, votes Ichini for fliplopping and for not declaring alignment match
ShadowFacts posts lurker check
Meeko fingers BillMC for low participation, lack of alignment comment
Meeko unvotes pede, votes BillMC based on what his posts were
Jimmy Chitwood claims name and alignment match
Ichini votes Tom Scud for support of mass name-claim
Jimmy says he’ll change vote if necessary to break a tie
Imaginary Fiend votes Tom for attacking those against name-claim
pede unvotes Meeko because it looks like Meeko’s case is typical Day 1
pede votes Imaginary Fiend for case made by others, colorful language
Jimmy can’t reconcile pede being scum with votes, unvotes pede, votes Imaginary Fiend
cardinal_fang unvotes pede, votes Imaginary Fiend based on opposition to claim being a stronger case
Imaginary Fiend claims Nikki Fernandez, vanilla
Oredigger votes Ichini, thinks case is the best
Jimmy Chitwood unvotes Imaginary Fiend, convinced by roleclaim, and votes pede
storyteller summarizes vote situation, suggests Ichini claim if possible
ShadowFacts unvotes Telcontar, votes Ichini, he didn’t really explain away contradiction
Ichini unvotes Tom Scud, votes storyteller for initial suspicions plus need to claim
Ichini claims name and alignment match
storyteller votes Ichini, far more squirrelly and scummier than Imaginary Fiend
Ichini claims Sun
End of Day 1; Ichini Sanshigo (Sun-Hwa Kwon, vanilla) dead
Tom Scud votes to replace BillMC
Telcontar votes to replace BillMC and paulwhoisaghost
Tom Scud suggests lynching Fiend for information
Day/Night 2
Start of Day 2; Tom Scud (Hugo “Hurley” Reyes, vanilla) dead by gunshot, Nanook (Kate Austen, vanilla) dead by strangling
storyteller revisits idea of name-claim, claims to have a main-character name, claims was role-blocked last Night
Chronos votes to replace BillMC and paul
pede votes Imaginary Fiend, “still suspicious of him”, votes replace paul
ScubaBen replaces paulwhoisaghost, USCDiver replaces BillMC
Chronos votes Imaginary Fiend for voting Tom Scud and for vote shift
Meeko votes Imaginary Fiend, questions why he made case that Tom was scum
Telcontar votes Oredigger for switching to IF, voting safe for Meeko, stayed out of drama
AllWalker looks at voters that got Ichini killed, those who didn’t claim alignment match, intersection of lists
Scuba Ben shows up, votes ShadowFacts for putting Ichini into tie for 1st place
Scuba_Ben unvotes ShadowFacts, votes Zeriel concerning tangible or null Scum tells
Zeriel votes AllWalker for omitting Zeriel from list in 640
Jimmy Chitwood votes Chronos for apparent inconsistency in views towards mass name-claim
Meeko unvotes Imaginary Fiend, votes Oredigger for Oredigger not liking the case on IF
pedescribe votes Oredigger for staying out of controversies, bandwagon-jumping
pedescribe unvotes IF (forgot to do so before)
Imaginary Fiend votes ShadowFacts, on assumption that Scum is trying to hide behind IF
USCDiver votes AllWalker for buddying up with Chronos, expresses suspicion of Chronos
cardinal_fang walls and votes Chronos
storyteller votes Chronos for basing accusatory discussion on assumptions
Meeko unvotes Oredigger
Meeko votes cardinal_fang because his plan is anti-Town
Telcontar urges vote shift to Oredigger
USCDiver unvotes AllWalker, suspicions were vague, and votes Chronos, “seen enough, particularly in defense from cardinal_fang”
Meeko compares vote lists at peak for various candidates
pedescribe unvotes Oredigger, votes Imaginary Fiend, Jimmy makes a good point
ShadowFacts votes Scuba Ben for misrepresenting Zeriel
Storyteller unvotes Chronos based on Meeko’s analysis
AllWalker votes Oredigger for avoidance of drama, defense of Chronos
pedescribe unvotes Imaginary Fiend, votes Oredigger
Scuba_Ben unvotes Zeriel, votes Oredigger, to force the issue, vague bad feeling
storyteller votes Oredigger to break tie, and Oredigger voted for both Meeko and Ichini
Oredigger votes Chronos in self-defense
Chronos votes Oredigger in self-defense
End of Day 2, Oredigger (Sayid Jarrah, vanilla) dead
storyteller posts lists of major characters, asks people to confirm whether they’re on list, confirms he is
Zeriel confirms he’s on Storyteller’s list
Telcontar confirms he’s on Storyteller’s list
ShadowFacts posts alternate list of major characters
Chronos posts code, results for sausage grinder program
ShadowFacts unions lists, confirms that he’s on combined list of 15
Chronos posts number of appearances for potentially-Town characters
Chronos questions storyteller about list-survey, compares to alignment-match survey
Chronos revises sausage-grinder to include non-final votes
Chronos suggests major characters claim if on the chopping block
(to be continued)
Day/Night 3
[spoiler]Start of Day 3; nobody dead
Jimmy Chitwood sees nothing to change previous approach, votes Chronos to get things started
Scuba_Ben votes Imaginary Fiend as runner-up, twice one-off voter
ShadowFacts mini-walls Scuba_Ben, links to previous case, votes Scuba_Ben
Chronos claims Michael Dawson
Scuba_Ben unvotes Imaginary Fiend, reminded of name-claim
USCDiver votes Chronos, continuation of previous vote
storyteller posts start of summary of Day 1, says he’ll pick back up in a while
Chronos finds mistake in code, corrects and updates, results weaker
Chronos prefers confirming Townies as-needed, not all at once
Zeriel votes Chronos for anti-town thinking
Telcontar votes storyteller as last vote in two lynches, sticking to topic of name claim
Meeko votes USCDiver for BillMC’s vote motives
Meeko unvotes USCDiver, votes Scuba_Ben, rejects question
Scuba_Ben walls ShadowFactsm, sees contradiction in behavior towards Meeko and Scuba_Ben
Scuba_Ben walls cardinal_fang
Chronos votes storyteller for voting pattern, sticking on name-claim
AllWalker votes Scuba_Ben for wishy-washy posts
cardinal_fang votes Chronos for previous reasons, Chronos’ case vs. storyteller
Scuba_Ben votes Chronos in self-defense
Scuba_Ben unvotes Chronos, votes storyteller for lack of vote
storyteller claims John Locke, detective, claims investigations of pede and Telcontar failed
Meeko claims to have known storyteller was detective
Scuba_Ben unvotes storyteller, votes Chronos, back to self-defense; claims Charlie Pace (vanilla)
storyteller votes Imaginary Fiend for inactivity and to test theory
Scuba_Ben unvotes Chronos, votes Imaginary Fiend, for information and people supporting Chronos
Telcontar unvotes storyteller for claim
storyteller posts role PM
Telcontar votes pede for previous arguments, lack of vote
Meeko fingers Scuba_Ben
Chronos unvotes storyteller, votes Imaginary Fiend after looking at vote count
Meeko unvotes Scuba_Ben, votes Imaginary Fiend, due to claim
Scuba_Ben votes to replace Imaginary Fiend if he survives
ShadowFacts unvotes Scuba_Ben, votes Imaginary Fiend, to break tie and to kill lurker
End of Day 3; Imaginary Fiend (Nikki Fernandez, vanilla) dead
Meeko fingers Scuba_Ben
Chronos updates program, output
Meeko suggests voting without discussion; voting for all-new people
Telcontar lists scenarios under which Meeko might conceivably be Scum
End of Night 3; AllWalker (Miles Straum, Lie-Detector) dead
[/spoiler]
Day/Night 4:
Meeko votes Scuba
Jimmy Chitwood thinks AllWalker might have breadcrumbed Chronos and storyteller as Town
storyteller claims no investigation result on ShadowFacts
Scuba_Ben claims Charlie Pace, vanilla; votes pede, not yet vote leader, disappeared yesterday; fingers cardinal_fang for lack of posts
storyteller continues recap of Day 1, suspects pede
Scuba is confident that Meeko is not a killer
Chronos scans AllWalker’s posts for breadcrumbs
Chronos fingers ShadowFacts for distrust of storyteller
Chronos contemplates game balance, number of Scum, suggests full claim of names and roles
Chronos modifies code again
Jimmy Chitwood supports claim
Chronos votes ShadowFacts for befuddling Town
Jimmy Chitwood finds statements by Chronos and storyteller that AllWalker might have investigated
Telcontar suspects pedescribe
Meeko claims Vig
Meeko unvotes Scuba, votes pede
Chronos asks Meeko about how many he can kill per Night
Meeko unvotes pede, votes Chronos for anti-Town question
USCDiver votes pede, most suspicious of him, not confirmed
Meeko unvotes Chronos, votes pede, misunderstood question
Telcontar votes pede, see previous posts
Telcontar votes for mod kill of pede
Chronos votes for mod kill of pede
Jimmy Chitwood votes for mod kill of pede
pedescribe shows up
pedescribe claims Jack (roleblocker), claims to have hit storyteller Night 1, Shadow Night 2, nobody Night 3
Chronos votes pede for inconsistency with storyteller
pede edits
Scuba_Ben unvotes pede, tentatively trusts claim, votes Jimmy
storyteller votes ShadowFacts on possibility that pede’s block stopped Night-kill
Scuba_Ben unvotes Jimmy, votes ShadowFacts based on storyteller’s case
ShadowFacts claims to have been protected, not blocked, Night 2, votes pedescribe
Scuba_Ben unvotes ShadowFacts, on possibility that there’s a doctor after all
Scuba_Ben suggests that maybe pede combines protection with blocking
storyteller considers pede might be paranoid Doc, claims that he got protection message Night 1 (but not 2 or 3)
Chronos unvotes pede, (re)-votes Shadow, hadn’t considered possibility of Town and Scum blockers
Chronos suggests that Night 2 no-kill might be from paranoid doc protecting Shadow
ShadowFacts votes storyteller, on improbability of having two Detectives
Zeriel votes ShadowFacts, can’t be proven Town, only proven Scum
storyteller re-suggests mass-claim
Jimmy Chitwood says a mass-claim might put him in jeopardy, but still supports idea
Telcontar claims Ana Lucia Cortez
Meeko unvotes pede
Jimmy claims Rose Nadler
Zeriel claims Mr. Eko, vanilla
USCDiver unvotes pede, votes ShadowFacts for ignoring AllWalker’s breadcrumb
Meeko votes Shadow
Jimmy claims vanilla
ShadowFacts claims Boone, vanilla
USCDiver claims Daniel Faraday, vanilla, posts later-season role PM
cardinal_fang claims Claire Littleton, vanilla
Jimmy Chitwood votes ShadowFacts
Scuba_Ben votes ShadowFacts
cardinal_fang votes ShadowFacts based on questioning breadcrumbs, presumed role-block, weak defense
pedescribe votes ShadowFacts based on lack of death when blocked
pedescribe unvotes ShadowFacts based on claim to have been protected, posts full role PM
Telcontar unvotes pede based on role PM
Jimmy Chitwood finds pede, Shadow, storyteller, and Telcontar all suspicious
Telcontar votes ShadowFacts based on response to story/pede and arguments against Chronos
Jimmy unvotes ShadowFacts based on protection message
storyteller starts summary of Day 2
storyteller finishes Day 2 summary
Jimmy Chitwood votes pedescribe
Jimmy Chitwood unvotes pede, votes ShadowFacts, based on Chronos’ defense of pede
ShadowFacts makes farewell post, confession
End of Day 4; ShadowFacts (Ethan Rom, Other) dead
Scuba_Ben edits
Telcontar clarifies to vanilla
Chronos posts notes of what happened previous Day
Meeko suspects Telcontar, Jimmy, Scuba
End of Night 4; pedescribe (Jack Shephard, paranoid doctor) dead
Day/Night 5:
storyteller claims to have been blocked
Chronos claims to have been protected
Chronos speculates that Meeko was one-shot
Meeko votes Chronos
Meeko verifies one-shot
Meeko unvotes Chronos
storyteller re-examines game balance
Meeko concludes USCDiver is Scum for voting Meeko Day 1
Meeko votes USCDiver
Telcontar votes USCDiver for voting Meeko Day 1; having low post count
Jimmy Chitwood posts role PM
Chronos votes Jimmy Chitwood for his suspicion of pede and storyteller, not having posted alignment matched name
Zeriel posts role PM; same as everyone else’s
Telcontar posts role PM
cardinal_fang posts role PM
Chronos slightly suspects USCDiver for having different PM
USCDiver suspects Zeriel, Telcontar, cardinal_fang for quick succession of PMs
storyteller notes lack of character pairs, other than AllWalker and USCDiver
Jimmy Chitwood votes Zeriel for fishy interaction with ShadowFacts, posture towards AllWalker’s role, lack of hand-dirtying
Zeriel votes Jimmy Chitwood, OMGUS
cardinal_fang votes USCDiver for grasping at straws, and smudging based on PMs
storyteller points out Chronos might be Godfather-like role
Possible PIS by Zeriel (saying USCDiver is Town)
Chronos unvotes Jimmy, votes Zeriel for apparent PIS and voting OMGUS
Meeko unvotes USCDiver, votes Zeriel
USCDiver votes Zeriel for PIS
Zeriel votes USCDiver in self-defense
Scuba_Ben abstains from voting
Telcontar votes Scuba for abstaining
Telcontar unvotes USCDiver (NETA)
Scuba_Ben votes USCDiver
Telcontar unvotes Scuba, votes Zeriel so Scum can’t save him
storyteller would vote for USCDiver, but doesn’t want to make a tie
storyteller votes USCDiver
End of Day 5; Zeriel (Benjamin Linus, Other Roleblocker) dead
Chronos posts vote analysis results
Meeko fingers Jimmy
USCDiver suspects Telcontar for casting deciding vote on Zeriel, Scuba_Ben for vote-abstaining, Telcontar and cardinal_fang for identical PMs
storyteller posts parting thoughts
storyteller continues thoughts, most suspects USCDiver and Chronos, least suspects Scuba and Meeko
End of Night 5; storyteller (John Locke, detective) dead
Day/Night Six:
Meeko votes Jimmy Chitwood per Chronos’ plan, scum pairs
Chronos votes Jimmy Chitwood, from vote analysis, not claiming alignment match, associated with USCDiver
Telcontar votes USCDiver for yesterday’s case, frantic desire to cast suspicion on Telcontar and cardinal
Meeko unvotes Jimmy, votes Diver, “magic bag claim”
Meeko fingers Chronos
Meeko unvotes Diver, votes Chronos, “don’t think town can win anyway”
Scuba is inclined to trust USCDiver, no reason given
USCDiver votes Telcontar
Chronos walls cardinal, concludes he’s definitely not lurking
cardinal_fang votes USCDiver for previous suspicions, reinforced by storyteller’s opinion
Scuba suspects that Jimmy and Telcontar are not both Town based on smudge by Jimmy
Scuba votes Jimmy as per previous
Jimmy suspects a Scuba/Diver team, votes USCDiver
USCDiver clarifies case against Telcontar as same as one yesterDay
USCDiver unvotes Telcontar, votes Jimmy in self-defense
Meeko declines to break tie
Meeko asserts Telcontar is Scum
Meeko thinks or thought both Chronos and Telcontar are Scum
Scuba declines to move vote
End(ish) of Day Six, Jimmy and Diver abducted by smoke
Complete end of Day Six, USCDiver missing, unknown alignment
Jimmy claims knowledge that Diver was Town and is dead
Meeko fingers Telcontar
Jimmy points out that Zeriel’s PIS should have cleared Diver
cardinal speculates that Jimmy and Diver were different alignments
Scuba_Ben speculates that Scum Jimmy would report USCDiver as Scum regardless
Meeko fingers cardinal
Chronos makes potentially last post; recommends lynching cardinal_fang
End of Night Six; Meeko (James “Sawyer” Ford, Survivor Gunman) dead, storyteller substitute-modding
Day/Night Seven
Scuba analyzes possible pairs, votes cardinal, fingers Telcontar
Telcontar analyzes possible pairs
Chronos votes cardinal for previously-outlined reasons
Chronos points out that the Jimmy/Diver scenario is a sure win for Town
Jimmy trusts cardinal; distrusts Telcontar and Scuba
Telcontar votes cardinal
Jimmy votes cardinal, doesn’t have much else to work with