I wasn’t talking to you; if I were you would know it. I was referring to this post:
Here’s another one for you. Don’t assume every post has something to do with you. One of these days you aren’t going to be a pro-town power role and you’re going to be lynched early on for your consistently anti-town play.
Please quit telling me how to play. Posting a bunch of randomness isn’t fun for me and it’s confusing to the Town (no I’m not referring to you, Meeko, I’m speaking in general); when I have something to say I’ll say it.
That’s usually referred to as metagaming. And I don’t think that your inference follows: Even if we’re at LyLo (five Town to four Scum), we could still have three more full Nights, if we hit Scum every time.
I consider Meeko and Chronos confirmed. The block-protect of Chronos didn’t disrupt the night kill. Until I know how the block mechanics work – which will be after the game ends, I’m sure – I’ll have to assume blocking any Scum would / might disrupt the kill. And at this point, there’s no reason to doubt Meeko’s claim of only one bullet.
Meeko, I applaud you on your gambit. It was very well played.
I consider storyteller 90% confirmed Town. Assuming he’s been telling the truth, he’s effectively plain Town. There is the possibility that he’s been lying to us, but I strongly discount this based on my best WAG about the block mechanics: pedescribe block-protected storyteller on Night 1, and the Scum got their kill off all the same. So by the same logic as my considering Chronos confirmed, I updated my rating on story.
Everybody else – no clue.
I am willing to consider lynch-or-modkill the lurkers.
Schedule-wise, I don’t know how much I’ll be on this weekend, and not at all on Monday.
I can’t keep straight who subbed for BillMC. But, wow, that’s it, if that’s it Then again, both the Diver and the Scubaer (One that scubas, right?) are still in, right?
Meeko(5) : Pedescribe, BillMC, AllWalker, Tom Scud, Oredigger,
I have it down that USCDiver subbed for BillMC and, you’re right, he’s the only one left.
Yesterday Diver sniped with Meeko a bit about just how “confirmed” Meeko was but otherwise kept fairly quiet. Looking over his posts, I think the reason that I didn’t have much of a read on him is that he tended to keep his head down.
Story’s comment made a great deal of sense when it was made, but I’m not sure I’m willing to accept the first premise as being conclusively proven. 4 out of the 5 players who voted for you were town, thus voting for you was not a “real” scum tell in each of those cases. But you were a very tempting bandwagon and, at the time, I thought that story was right; at least one scum was probably on the wagon (this is part of why I was suspicious of pedescribe). **Diver’**s defense isn’t aided by his fairly low post count, he’s been a bit lurkerish at times when others were putting themselves out there.
My other living suspicion is Scuba. Shadow, however, made a fairly determined effort to get scuba killed. This could have been an effort to build town cred - others were after scuba and, if a mafia is going to die, other mafia would love to be seen as having helped town kill them - but I think it’s worth leaving that WIFOM until Tomorrow.
But yes, I really should put my vote where my mouth is, at least for now.
Story : What do you think of still voting for USCD? I mean, it is your theory after all, and I would assume, not having heard otherwise, that you are, at least in principal?
Telcontar: I’m not with you on Cardinal, but, I’m perhaps there With Zeriel. He’s called me a " spaz " more than once. I wonder if there isn’t some… attack here, that was conspired.