Love at first song...then not so much

It’s happened to you. You hear a song, and it’s great. You’re sure you’re going to love the band or artist. Then you hear other songs. You don’t love them, you don’t even really like their other songs much at all.

Which songs lead your heart astray…until you heard others by the same band/artist?

My most recent list (ie what’s still on my computer):

Blonde Redhead - Equus
Forgotten Cassettes - Like Tiny Swords
Depswa - This Time
Sufjan Stevens - The Dress Looks Nice on You
Kings of Leon - Molly’s Chambers
The Features - Me & The Skirts
GusGus - Starlovers
Gomez - Get Myself Arrested
Matt Pond PA - Lilly Two
Aerovox - Could’ve Been A Contender
The Stills - Still in Love Song
The Von Bondies - C’mon C’mon
The Killers - Somebody Told Me