I’ve been rereading and searching the thread, but have come to few conclusions. I have a few strong Town leans but have no strong Scum suspects. A weak suspect is
Vote: Pleonast
I have a hunch that among the recent front-runners other than TexCat (Pizza, Astral, Darth) there is at least one Scum. There was some Scum-scum bussing going on. However I can’t figure out which of the three is Scum. If Pleo is Scum then, on Day 1 when Pleo jumped into the lead (perhaps as a result of Scum votes), Scum had a sudden need to join a bandwagon on Dizzy. However all three of these suspects joined that bandwagon.
Of the three, one seems slightly more suspicious to me.
ROLE TYPE: Vanilla
ALIGNMENT: Yours (Town)
WIN CONDITION: You win when all of Mine (Scum) have been eliminated.
*Mr. Donner –
This is to invite you to attend an informal gathering at my home this Tuesday evening. I know what you’re thinking: why would he invite an ordinary carpenter to such a prestigious event?
Sincerely,
M*
POWERS:Regrettably, none. But maybe someone will need a shelf.----
CLUE: A man named Langdale Pike is in possession of false information that should be ignored.
Your reveal of your clue after all your pussy-footing around is
Question 1: Why did you think your clue would not be bad to post? You supposedly have a list of 5 people who could be scum. You do not know how many if any are actually scum but thought it might be a good idea to post your clue and wanted everyone else to post their clues because what’s the harm? Are you really that “clueless”?
Question 2: Were either of the scum who have been lynched on your list?
Question 3: Were any of the folks on your list among the town who have died?
vote Mahaloth for the same reasons I voted you before, all the clue bs, and for more of the same.
vote Inner Stickler because you questioned Daphne after she outed the GF. This is a slightly shakier vote due to the back-up GF, but I still don’t like your play and I don’t like Mahaloth’s clue. Feels like a scum busing to me.
I am pretty stumped at this point, beyond my already stated but unsubstantiated suspicions. If the silent ones would contribute I would feel better about where we are.
I have no objections to voting for any person who hasn’t posted in the last (random time increment, feel free to extend if you think this is inadequate) 3 real-life days on principle of being unhelpful.
i’m thinking it’s either she went after one of them but didn’t receive any support, they killed her because she likely wasn’t watched or scum just wants to screw with us.
yes, i’ve basically dealt with the situation or perhaps it’s more accurate to say that the situation resolved itself albeit not in the way i had hoped.
some interesting posts in light of Texcat’s flipping scum:
i’m reconsidering Astral’s scumminess. both he and **Texcat **had similar reasons for voting me but i don’t think two scum would do that.
was **Rysto **the difference in the voting? it just struck me as odd. i can’t say why. just a gut feel.
i’m not sure name claiming is okay. there seem to be clues that include names. they can lead to lynches of townies if the clues are false.
Sorry about my absence for a few days (I haven’t been on the internets that much during that time).
But still, this post pings me big time as an attempt to get on the good side of a lot of posters for not very good reasons. So:
Vote AskThePizzaGuy
and for good measure, Mahaloth’s supposed clue strikes me as extremely in-plausible. A list of 5 possible scum players would be game-breaking if true, and therefore far too obviously a false clue. I don’t think storyteller goes around handing townie badges. Lynch all liars!
