I don’t question that you have an easily verifiable claim. I expect that before Dusk Tomorrow you’ll reveal the side of ToDay’s lynchee, and before Dawn of Day3, the sides of ToNight’s nightkill(s). Before Dusk of Day 3, providing you’ve correct so far, I’d expect you to reveal the role of ToDay’s lynchee. Get one wrong, of course, and you’ll be next on the gallows.
I don’t trust you. I think you’ll be swinging on Day 3 at the latest. You’ve not yet commented on the other people with high vote counts. Your reaction to having a whopping 4/31 votes was to claim. You could’ve responded to the people who voted for you, or built a case against someone else, but you just claimed.
I find the risk more unplatable though. So: unvote brewha
This, to my count, puts Darth Sensitive in the lead, with brewha, Nanook, pedescribe, Oredigger77, Pollux Oil, Santo Rugger, and NaturalBlondChap tied for second.
Crap. I’m not happy with lynch the lurker, and less happy with no lynch (in the chance of a tie). Quickly rereading.
Shit, Redwing, he’s claimed arguably one of the most easily verifiable roles, and if he’s wrong, he’ll swing, just like you say. Why the continued smudges?
Yeah, a whopping 4 votes which put me in the lead on the last day of the Day. Let’s keep things in perspective here, alright? Claiming when I did, I still was tied for the lead with less than an hour to go. And you think I should have waited to claim?
Truth of the matter is, the coroner is only really useful after he’s claimed. I had planned on claiming sooner than later - but just not this soon. Because of this - like I’ve already said - claiming early was not a big deal.
Hmmm…gonna have to call bullshit on this, and I’m wondering if I should just put my vote back on you.
There is no ‘admission’ in my reasoning for voting for you, and the decidedly negative spin you try to put on my reasoning with that word bothers me greatly. You on the other hand, have admitted to trying to avoid scrutiny.
You seem to be trying to wave away the scummy motivations for avoiding scrutiny. You also took issue with me calling you out for participation level, after compiling a similar report card on my posts. I’m willing to let bygones by bygones in that area, and leave that up to the court of public opinion.
I just wanted to point out that I’m not defending players in particular, I’m pointing out flaws in arguments against them that I see.
And thanks for the second part, I think.
I’m not sure who I’d pick out of those two. I’m trying to read Oredigger’s posts; he raised my hackles at least once (his reaction to Pollux Oil’s anti-mass-claim stance).
I thought I saw something else, but was unable to trace it this afternoon.
[QUOTE=brewha]
Yeah, a whopping 4 votes which put me in the lead on the last day of the Day. Let’s keep things in perspective here, alright? Claiming when I did, I still was tied for the lead with less than an hour to go. And you think I should have waited to claim?
[QUOTE]
No, I think you should have sought out a better place to put your vote. Self-preservation is a null-tell, but you certainly could’ve moved your vote, or built a case against Zsofia beyond the omgus that you started with. I have removed my vote from you due to your claim. Don’t ask that I be happy about it as well.
I don’t like how close we are to a tie currently. I don’t have a solid case against either of the high vote holders, but the self-vote thing bugs me. I don’t like voting purely on being bugged, but: vote Darth Sensitive
ComeToTheDarkSideWeHaveCookies, Yes, I_have_admitted to trying to avoid scrutiny. Because that is exactly what I was trying to do. I was trying to go unnoticed until just before Pleonast revealed the role of the first killed. Then I was going to chime in and say, “Pleo is about to reveal that so-and-so is a so-and-so”. Then when he did, I would gain the trust of the town and be able to reveal the rest of the knowledge I had obtained without the skeptiscm.
OK, I may have paraphrased. But I was in no way trying to put a negative spin on your vote. I’ve said it - probably three times - that I understood why you voted the way you did. It was the people that were trying to get a bandwagon going on me with your reasoning that raised suspicions with me.
This is the part I remember:
And that is what I was agreeing with. I’m really not seeing what it was about my posts that have pissed you off so much.
brewha: I’m not pissed, I just took issue with your choice of words. It is not really a big deal in light of the current firedrill.
Neither Darth nor Oredigger have been in my awareness much at all, aside from noting Darth’s vote for himself. I don’t have enough data to make anything like an informed decision, so I hope the rest of you choose well.
