Except it doesn’t. If storyteller wanted to give Cookies knowledge that a player was town, he would have done so. “Total Lost is town-aligned.”
He didn’t do that. He left wiggle room. Why? Two choices:
- Story is an evil bastard mod who wants us to make the wrong decision.
- Story is a clever guy who want to make us put puzzle pieces together.
I think it’s the latter, and I think the latter implies that Total Lost is not town.