I’m against a mass claim.
I really don’t see an advantage to outing our power roles. We’ve got two confirmed Masons. If either of them get night killed, we still have one that can confirm the rest as needed. For that reason, I don’t think there’s much advantage for scum to target either of them.
Mhaye is most likely safe from night attack as well. Because either he has a shotgun to protect himself and the scum now know it, or because he is scum himself.
So, right now, I think we’re doing pretty well to keep scum in the dark. Outting power roles would help scum much more than hurt them, IMHO.
Also, if we have a vig, I think Mhaye would make a perfect target tonight. Unless I’m mistaken, his first shot is just a warning. So a vig attack on Mhaye would not put our vig in any danger (assuming Mhaye is telling the truth) and would end up more or less confirming Mhaye either by his death or his ability to scare off the vig.
He’d still retain a shot and the ability to protect if he’s alive in the morning.
On preview:
No, I saw that Total Lost. But that was posted more than a few days ago (4 iirc). I figured it was a good time for a reminder.