I think my vote record would suggest otherwise, Sachetorte. My vote chart shows an awful lot of blue names I voted for. 
I wonder why town is so unconcerned with the fact that third parties could be close to their win condition per Storyteller’s explicit post on the subject near the start of the game.
I wonder if the fact that Storyteller said recruitment was optional in the game set up would explain the different numbers of recruitments, assuming the zombies are recruits for a 3rd party necromancer type dude. I think on one of the conspiracy games there were two vampires who would recruit, maybe two here, given that there is a option for recruits to refuse plus no doubt other methods for getting rid of the zombies.
Also seams a couple of people were in early with LF smudges “surprised she wasn’t dead”
Also I think LF needs to provide some claim so I would be voting that way but not because she wasnt dead.
I would put pressure on her for sure. As a outed power role, she really should have been a target. Scum playing dare with the doc will only explain so much survival.
I think with so many dead vanilla townies, a mass claim might not be a bad idea. There’s almost no point in “protecting” any more power roles, with their hiding place being so small. With the cop dead, the doc has nobody of much value to protect, at least according to the roles storyteller outlined. If we DO have more, it’s time town found out about them, and put together the pieces.
Also, why has nobody done a revised voting chart? Those are valuable… patterns really stand out when you can glance at all of a day at once.
Did anyone ever do a “balance” calculation, I seam to remember that was popular a while ago, in an attempt to figure out how many scum town might have to deal with. If town are even close to being out of redshirts that mass claim could be a good plan.
At the very least, a mass claim now will absolutely give town a good place to start looking. If we have a town-aligned second vigilante, he can take credit for his kills, which will also help town by examining who died. Scum and SK(s) must claim peasant or some weird power, and town can scrutinize more effectively
Right you were. It was indeed an honest mistake I made because I wasn’t at my computer. I could have flipped over, but I honestly had remember all the stuff about being an extra, not the Peasant Readshirt part.
Even knowing you’re town, I still think that was pretty scummy. You were right, this really wasn’t my best game. 
I think your death is the best evidence so far that town has a second vig. SK(s) and scum would leave you alone, as you’re an easy mislynch that isn’t one of them.
I agree given the number of deaths there could be another town vig, but a 3rd party killer would probably want to pare down scum to prevent them getting too big a lead.
I think they’d target someone unlikely to be lynched anyway. If you know someone is a target for lynching, you let that go ahead and happen. Now, today is up in the air. Town could lunch an SK or scummer pretty easily.
Astral, agreed.
I wonder if anyone is going to look at Reds posts to see if there are any nuggets. I did a quick skim and as far as I can see he mostly voted for town, so probably didn’t find any scum but he must have some hints on who is trustable or not. SubPlank just breezed through and said he had not noted Red saying anything, with no analysis, sort of a “nothing to see there, I already looked , move along”
Start lynching the experienced players!
Dizzy still looks crazy scumtastic to me. That probably means she’s town, though 
Yeah, I had ATPG pegged as scum as I thought he was trying hint stuff to fellow wolves on day one prior to wolves being allowed to talk, I guess I should not have purchased the budget Scumdar model ICTHRUU 101, damn thing is flaky as hell.
And on that note Cookies is giving LF an unusually generous pass on her inadvertent outing, Cookies knows something about LF.
Ahh the peanut gallery threads are so much less stressful, wild arse speculation without consequences.
I’m here, I don’t think I’m very good at this game.
Ortho , I think you are still in the game as a zombie and allowed to post in game. Not that we know anything in this thread but you may want to ping Storyteller and check where you should be posting.
No such thing as bad at mafia, so long as you are playing.
What precam said. I think if you’re “alive” back in the real thread, you shouldn’t post or read here.
I’m keeping this quote for next time you suspect me.
That is fair and a half. I guess in hindsight “movie extra” didnt make sense as a scum slip, since they’d presumably be pretty aware of what the vanilla PM was after the Stanislaus thing. I’d have copied and pasted it into the scum boards immediately to prevent further slips.
Still, it was a weird townie mistake.
Yes, yes, OK. Let’s move on, eh?
I laughed at that. If it was a game full of Astrals, you’d maybe still be alive, Stan!
Edit: of course, if it was LITERALLY full of Astrals, you’d have been investigated Day 1. So… maybe not so much.