Yup, that’s it. What did we prove with finding that? That Khameleon is still a viable candidate?
It was bugging me so found t. I want to take a closer look at both of them now.they currently are both suspect ( without researching)
Ah Paul you played the good game. I secretly thought you were scum because you were playing so hard. I am sooo sorry for doubting you.
Best vanilla town player ever
vote Texcat
For all the reasons I’ve given the past two Days, including in my WoW.
Sachertorte’s death shows that the cult does exist. Note that he was specifically identified as the first deacon, as per his claim. Since they have unique names, it means that no-one can masquerade as a fake LUTHA: any such attempt can be countered. Indeed, the uniqueness of names means that they don’t really need to confirm each other.
Vote Texcat
I like the cases that have been presented by Hoopy and nesta.
I know Khameleon isn’t one of the more vocal people, but has anyone done a WoW on a past day?
Sadly Meeko - vanilla town has not responded to any posts or prods. He’s been removed from the game and has lost no matter the outcome.
He does not count toward multi lynch because he was never really in the game. He has been erased from the record books.
I made my main case on Day 3. The relevant posts are:
Since then, there was the slip about not being worried about a night-kill (D4#272). There was also the odd comment that lurking is a valid town tactic (D5#201).
Khameleon’s main response to my case is here: D4#229. My response to that is here: D4#243
–
I make no apologies for inaccuracies with the numbering of things. I seem to get it wrong all the time, but I think the actual links are all correct.
That was me, yep. I’ve since given up on it since nobody agreed with me.
Sorry to see you go Paul. Bye Meeko, sad I didn’t get to know you.
Vote TexCat
Vote Johnny Bravo for advocating cultist lynchings instead of scum lynchings on Day 5.
The Day 5 lynch reminds me of a piece of advice that I picked up in some previous game. If one person has the majority of votes that they’ve picked up slowly over the course of the Day, scum approve of their lynch and therefore they are the wrong person to lynch. I regret I didn’t remember this in time for Prof. Pepperwinkle, but maybe it will be a useful reminder in the coming Days.
Before I forget, and I do see he hasn’t posted much.
EnderW - On day 3, you commented you KNEW crys was lying. In light of sach’s death reveal, can you explain how you know this?
**Day 6 Vote Count
Khameleon(2) - snfaulkner(6), johnnybravo(10)
Texcat(2) - Hoopy(24), CaptainKlutz(26), plumpudding(31)
Johnnybravo(1) - innerstickler(32)**
vote CaptK
Looks to me like he’s trying to slip onto a wagon without being noticed. No case, just an easy “me too” vote.
I noticed that the vote summaries do not have Brain Dead’s votes. I’ve added BD’s EOD votes to the summary below, but unvotes have not been included.
[spoiler]The Living
3. Biotop - D1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 Squid lynched scum – D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
bufftabby - D1 Lakai mislynch -D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Prof. P not lynched - D4 Diggit - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
Captain Klutz - E1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3Idle mis-lynch - D4 Squid lynch scum - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
ComeToTheDarkSideWeHaveCookies - D1 Lakai mislynch -D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Idle mis-lynch - Squid lynch scum - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
crys75 - D1 No vote - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Enderw24 not lynched - D3 Enderw24 not lynched- D5 no vote
-
[del]DaphneBlack[/del]Lakai 2 - D1 no vote (as Daphne) - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 - HockeyMonkey not lynched - D4 - Diggit mis-lynched -D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
EnderW24 - D1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 no vote - D3 Prof. P not lynched - D4 Squid lynch scum - D5 no vote
-
Guiri - D1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 ToeJam not lynched - Squid not lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch - D5 Total Lost not lynched
-
Hal Briston - D1 no vote - D2 no vote - D3 Prof. P not lynched - D4 no vote - D5 no vote
-
hawkeyeop - D1 Colby not lynched - D2 Crys not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 Squid lynch scum -D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
HookerChemical - D1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3 Pleonast not lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch – D5 Nanook not lynched
-
Hoopy Frood - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 HockeyMonkey - D3 Prof. P not lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch – D5 TexCat not lynched
-
Inner Stickler - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Prof. P not lynched - Squid lynch scum – D5 Johnny Bravo not lynched
-
Johnny Bravo D1 Normal Phase not lynched - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 Squid lynch scum - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
Khameleon - D1 no vote - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 no vote - D5 - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
Koldanar- D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 SNFaulkner not lynched - D3 no vote - D4 Diggit mis-lynch - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
LightFoot - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 Pleonast not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 Prof. P not lynched - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
Mhaye - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3 Prof. P not lynched - D4 Prof. P not lynched - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
Nanook of the North Shore - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 Chronos not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 Prof. P not lynched - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
Nesta - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - no vote - D5 Texcat not lynched
-
Plumpudding - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 Texcat not lyched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 Squid lynch scum - D5 Texcat not lynched
-
[del]Precambrian mollusk[/del]Cygnus 42 - D1 no vote - D2 no vote - D3 Prof. P not lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
Raventhief - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 Diggit mis-lynch – Khameleon not lynched
-
Scathach - TexCat not lynched - Crys75 not lynched - D3 no vote - D4 no vote - D5 no vote
-
sinjin - D1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - D4 Prof. P not lynched - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
-
snfaulkner - D1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 Crys75 not lynched - D3 Squid not lynched - D4 Squid lynch scum – Khameleon not lynched
-
Texcat - D1 Colby not lynched - D2 Crys75 not lynched - D3 Prof. P not lynched - D4 Squid lynch scum - Paulwhoisnotlynched
-
Total Lost - D1 Angel not lynched - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Prof. P not lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch - D5 no vote
-
Zeriel - D1 Angel not lynched - Crys75 not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch - Prof. P not lynched - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
The Deceased(19):
12. Dante G – ModKilled D1 –Vanilla Town
29. Lakai 1 – Lynched D1 - Vanilla Town - D1 Toejam not lynched
35. Normal Phase – Daykilled D1 - Investigative Journalist - D1 Toejam not lynched
45. septimus – Daykilled D1 - EMT - D1 Toejam not lynched
48. Suburban Plankton – Nightkiled N1 (1) Homicide Detective - D1 Colby not lynched
9. Colby11 – Nightkilled N1 – Vanilla Town - D1 brewha not lynched
5. brewha – Lynched D2 – Vanilla Town - D1 Colby not lynched - D2 Toejam not lynched
8. Chronos – Daykilled D2 - Mason - D1 Toejam not lynched - D2 brewha mis-lynched
15. Drain Bead - Nightkilled N2 - Leprechaun - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 brewha mis-lynched
41. Red Skeezix - Modkilled D3 - Vanilla Town - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 no vote
43. Sario – poofed D3 - Wizard - D1 no vote - D2 no vote
23. Idle Thoughts - Lynched D3 - Vanilla Town - D1 no vote - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3 Toejam not lynched
- AngeloftheNorth - Nightkilled N3 - Vanilla Town - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 Crys not lynched - D3 Idle mis-lynch
- Toejam - Nightkilled N3 - Doctor Seward - D1 Colby not lynched - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Prof. P not lynched
- jsgoddess - Daykilled D3 - Beta Wolf - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 Toejam not lynched - D3 Prof. P not lynched
- Thing Fish - Daykilled D3 - Omega Wolf - D1 Pleonast not lynched - D2 ToeJam not lynched - D3 Khameleon not lynched
- DiggitCamara - Lynched D4 - Vanilla Town - D1 SNFaulkner not lynched - D2 Crys not lynched - D3 Thing Fish not lynched - D4 Boozahol Squid, P.I. lynched
- Boozahol Squid, P.I. - Lynched D4 - Outrider - D1 AngeloftheNorth not lynched - D2 brewha mis-lynched - D3 Thing Fish not lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch
- Pleonast - Daykilled D4 - Seer - D1 Colby not lynched - D2 Thing Fish not lynched - D3 Prof. Pepperwinkle not lynched - D4 Prof. Pepperwinkle not lynched
- BillMc - Night Killed N4 - Whelp - D1 Toejam not lynched - D2 brewha mis-lynch - D3 Idle Thoughts mis-lynched - D4 Prof. Pepperwinkle not lynched
- Sunny Daze - Night Killed N4 - Informant - D1 Toejam not lynched - D2 Toejam not lynched - D3 Idle Thoughts mis-lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch
- Hockey Monkey - Night Killed N4 - Consigliere - D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 Crys not lynched - D3 Idle Thoughts mis-lynched - D4 Squid lynch scum
- Prof. Pepperwinkle - Lynched D5 - D1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 sachertorte not lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch - D5 Sachertorte not lynched
- Sachertorte - D1 ToeJam not lynched - D2 ToeJam not lynched - Prof P not lynched - D4 Squid lynch scum - D5 Nanook not lynched
- [del]Winston Smith[/del]Paulwhoisvanillatown - Vanilla town Night killed N5 - D1 no vote - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Diggit not lynched - D4 Diggit mis-lynch - D5 Prof. P mis-lynched
- Meeko - Vanilla town Mod killed D6- D1 Lakai mislynch - D2 brewha mislynch - D3 Khameleon not lynched - D4 Squid lynch scum - D5 no vote
[/spoiler]
sure, but do you have anything else to add?
Are Scathach and Hal even playing beyond their one post a day? Gah!
Too quiet in here. I’d like to contribute a WOW I did, hoping to find something, but what I hoped would be obvious isn’t there. I may have to re-read this and see. Please note I skipped repeats / fluff.
SNFaulkner
Day 1 -
Post 37 – Fast vote for Angel
Post 157 – Unvotes Angel, votes Boozy (known scum). Defends Colby (town)
Post 286 – Defends not voting Colby
Posts 287 – 288 – Game info.
Post 295 – Unvotes boozy(scum), votes Lakai(town) for his vote.
Post 312 – Again defends his no vote on Colby, and his vote on Lakai.
Post 431 – Stiunk eye on prof p.
Post 751 – FOS on Total Lost. Defends prof p.
Post 935 – Congradulates Sunny Daze (mafia) on play. Some claim analysis.
Post 952 – Still didn’t like the Colby vote for his ‘slip’
Post 962 – Gentle suspicion on Prof p?
Post 969 – same
Post 1118 – Meta stuff on Colby
Post 1205 – Switch from Lakai to Toe Jam (Town)
Post 1244 – Says he might vote for prof p.
Post 1352 – vote count.
Day 2:
Post 12 – Vote Count #2
Post 17 – FOS on everyone that voted on a townie on day 1
Post 19 – post count
Post 171 – Tells a wolf (jsgodess) to use meta.
pOST 330 – Batman strategy talk
Post 332 – doesn’t like pleo AND digit, both town.
Post 351 : Switch commentary
Post 410- throws a little shade on a switch claim
Post 585 – Comments on brewha lying. Believes Crys
Post 592 – Comments on diggit’s vote of crys.
Post 631 : Comments on crys and brewhad in bufftaby’s post.
Post 641 – Votes on Crys despite belief in her
Post 682 – Comments on wanting to lynch scum, but wonders about cult.
Post 837 : justifies vote on crys because of no confirmed scum.
Post 840 – believes brewha
Post 925 – thinks a cult death would give info
Post 934 – wants to lynch toe jam and crys.
Post 1084 – After day vote count
Post 1206 – may agree with LTL
Day 3:
Post 17 – Crazy reasoning to voe Toe Jam (town)
Post 18 – Vote counts from night 1
Post 29 – Plum asks SNF for leans, etc. He replies with a read list. Marks Sunny and Bill as town enough.
Post 65 – Batman comments
Post 78 – Comments on paul, calls out a slight ping.
Post 87 – Justification of his calling a night kill a vig killing.
Post 101 – More vig comments.
Post 106 – Comment on Sario.
Comment from Thing fish (Post 196) – he finds Sunny Daze, Biotop, Hooker Chem, sinjin, Capt. Klutz, Guiri. Townie. Says town and null on SNF.
Post 202 – Comments on Pleo’s votes. Doesn’t agree with most.
Post 215 – Casts suspicion on paul for defending idle.
Post 231 – Asking about modkill peoples
Pist 250ish? – posts his whole players list with small notes.
Post 396 – Talks about why he voted Crys – sounds okish.
Post 402 – Actively looking for meta info about toe jam. Will vote idle if he comes to avoid mod kill.
Post 464 – Disparaging Prof P again.
Posts 479 and 480 – discussing Prof P with Paul.
Post 489 – wants a claimed cultist to die at some point.
Post 705 – Idle stuff.
Post 777 – Would vote squid (scum) or Diggit (town).
Post 813 – Asks Khameleon about one of his (her?)_ odd posts.
Post 822 – Ok with Boozy, digit, or pleo going down. Not ok with prof p. Didn’t he disparage him before? Oh post 464?
Post 836 – votes for Boozy.
Day 4:
Post 17 – Happy to either get two scum or one scum / one 3p
Post 18 – Post count post.
Post 27 – Comment on Prof’s strategy of looking for famed scum hunters that are alive.
Post 44 – Comments on a doc / protector switch
Post 51 – Comments on Boozy’s weird vote for Prof P.
Post 69 _ Mentions Crys might have edited her pm.
Post 183 – Comments on Angel’s trust of prof p, likes the case on boozy and digit.
Post 192- Votes Boozy, doesn’t like Ender.
Post 195 – Comments on his vote for boozy.
Post 323 – Comments on Boozy’s scum comment.
Post 392 – Comments on paul’s note that wolves might push for a lynch if possible.
Post 400- Another comment on wolf strategies re : mafia.
Post 404 – Comments on lutha having more to it than we’ve seen so far, but doesn’t sound worried.
Day 5:
Post 28 – Says he claimed Sach’s post on bio was BS.
Post 34 – vote Count
Post 36 – Can’t see any vote Bussing
Post 43 – Who posted post.
Post 45 – Calls out to Prof to vote for mid to low mid posters.
Post 68 – Votes Prof, thanks to Pleo. Still interestd in khameleon.
Some argument on when he got his role pm.
Post 112 – Corrects Lightfoot on Paul’s attitude.
Post 122 – Wants to know why lightfoot feels that cultists will be resolved with more scum deaths
Post 135 – Assumes 3p are real
Post 172 – Calls out Sinjin’s smudge
I was hoping for some link here - I thought if the Prof turned up scum, this would be an easy vote, as SNF kept half defending / half going after the prof. Since he’s town, I see this as a null right now.
There was a little early chumminess with SunnyD, but nothing that really pinged me.
After doing this, if he’s scum, he’s staying under my radar for sure. His content is a little lighter than his post count would indicate, though. I’m hoping someone else might see something in this.
@NAF Town
Farewell Paul! Bye Meeko, tough luck. We went from 3 deaths to 1 - switches, blocks, or protections?
I’ll repeat my Vote Total from yesterDay
Hope you’re feeling better.
I’m fine with Texcat too for her interactions with jsgoddess and her vote on Colby despite knowing his style, or Khameleon for the weirdness about being found by Thing Fish and not being afraid of a night kill.
Agression or confusion?
Unless there aren’t 5!
This. Scathach is posting, but seems to be stuck in D2 mode and worrying about cult rather than scum.
@Koldanar, this is classic “Post 837 : justifies vote on crys because of no confirmed scum.” Did you miss the rest of D5, his 231 is the post that most caught my attention yesterDay