Why bother numbering them if there were only 2? Ask Opal or Meeko.
I like this theory. It might be worthwhile to take another look at Hooker’s post history to see what scum was trying to stop him from doing. Otherwise why not go after Mhaye? There would be no reason not to unless there was someone more important to kill.
Since the claim, we had scum kill Ender, Cyrs, and then Hooker. The Ender kill is understandable, but it’s odd that Mafia thought Cyrs was a better target and that the Wolves thought Hooker was more important.
And why am I the only one who is asking this question - who did Mhaye watch yesterDay?
Prior to Koldanar’s claim, the cult was regarded as comprising 5 deacons, numbered 1 to 5. For someone to false claim to be a different type of cultist is a rather high risk gamble. If there were indeed 5 deacons, then number 5 would surely have spoken up by now. For these reasons I think that Koldanar is indeed a cultist.
If there are any other deacons left, I suggest investigating Koldanar toNight and coming forward toMorrow. (Come forward toMorrow rather than toDay, as Mafia have shown they want to interfere with any confirmation attempt)
Good question. I was somehow under the impression I had already answered this, but a quick check of my D08 posts shows I haven’t addressed it.
I Watched LightFoot.
Nobody bothered LightFoot during either Day or Night.
Apologies for the delay. I was unsure whether it was due to the headaches my role gives the Mods, or alternatively whether I had been roleblocked or my off switch had been thrown. (If there is such a thing as an Off switch for my role; with reports from all seven Days making me doubt its existence).
In general I give the Mods 24 hours to let me know what I did before checking (because of the aforementioned headaches) so there is likely to be some delay before the results are published.
Thanks, I was about to ask this, too!
Question 1 was if I would know if my powers were successful - I got two different answers from two different mods.
There was no question 3!
Sorry, the cult part there was underlined by me to highlight it - I felt it added extra confirmation to my claim.
Guiri - Yes, at that point, I felt that without pressure, it was better for me to claim at that point, and be 100% honest. I would have claimed sooner, had I not been worried about GladOS. And to be honest still, I’m ok not having the others claim at the moment, since I can see they would still be worried about some aggression, as you can see I’ve been getting some thrown my way, but only by one or two people so far.
I gave some reasons why scum would choose Hooker over MHaye.
There are few roles with active powers remaining.
This is just bad form. I mean editing a quote is frowned upon in general, but in game of mafia, even worse.
It’s really, really, really weird that it kind of feels like end game, things are slowing down, but there are still 21 of us - many games begin with fewer players!
I’ll reinstate my Vote TexCat
I’d also be perfectly happy lynching Nesta - for barely avoiding the modkill, Plumpudding - has anyone done a WoW on him?, sinjin - seems to have given up hunting, and Zeriel - for the post-hoc vote reasoning.
Have I not voted yet? crap!
Vote Khameleon
You seem like a nice person IRL, but i still think you are scum-scuminy scum-scuminy scum scum-miny.
NAF said he’s never played Portal so didn’t get that it was a Potal reference. What does all this mean? That the mods don’t care about the color as much as we do, it seems.
vote khameleon
I’ve made my case across multiple days. I still think, in my heart of hearts, that Koldanar edited his role PM but that’s not provable.
Sure. Whether my hypothesis is correct is another thing worth looking at. Thanks for putting the list together.
I don’t like who you are choosing to watch, but I can’t tell you who I think you should watch because then no one will visit that person.
Why did you pick LightFoot. Why did you think LightFoot would have a visitor?
Is this because Hooker was suspicious of him and then died? Other people voted for TexCat at other times and they seem to still be alive. Why weren’t other TexCat voters killed?
Looked into this some more, and apparently Hooker voted for Nanook on Day five. Who else voted for Nanook? Sachertorte. And what happened to Sachertorte? He was killed on Day five.
Two people voted for Nanook. Two people are mysteriously murdered by the Mafia.
Vote Nanook
Hmmmm…maybe, maybe…
Consider this in future ( 'specially If I end up dead) The players you have watched are unlikely for you to watch again soon. This gives our killers a free shot the next cycle or two.
Maybe save your reveals ( or at least the no data ones ) an extra cycle or so? and… I don’t remember if you have done this- but hold your results until the cycle is finished.
- to not project your current target *
Now I need to research who has pushed you for results - you see how it could be used?
It is a sin* to edit a quote with out posting in the same post that the edits were yours and why.
- not really a sin but * damn * bad form.
I’ll save you the research. I pushed him both times. This request, however, to save reveals, sounds like you want him to withhold information until scum have a chance to kill him. I think Mhaye should reveal his targets as soon as possible since he is on borrowed time here.
I mentioned before that I don’t think it’s a good idea to help Mhaye make a choice because it might alert scum to potential targets. But then I decided a little guidance might be more helpful. Here is a list of scum and their roles courtesy of Captain Klutz:
Mafia (4):
The Godfather - First kill of them will fail
The Bodyguard - Night protect, but dies instead
The Mook - One time use power of dead teammate
The Enforcer - Roleblocker for following Day and Night
Wolves (3):
The Alpha Wolf - First kill of them will fail
The Bloodhound - Day tracker
The Trickster - Roleblicker for current Day and following Night
Who could potentially use a power that Mhaye can catch? Not the Godfather or Alpha Wolf. They don’t visit anybody and let their pawns do all the work. Next we have The Bodyguard, who will only use his power to protect Mafia. Hard to predict who he or she will protect without knowing who is in the Mob. Next up is The Mook, who can use a dead teammate power, which means he can use The Hitman’s power or the Informant’s power. The Hitman is out since the town doesn’t have any more protectors, so The Mook will probably use The Informant’s power, if any.
Finally, we have The Bloodhound (day tracker) and two role blockers. If you add The Mook with the Informants power, what do all these people have in common? Who are they going to target?
Lightfoot, I have to say I’m on Lakai’s side on this. I don’t think Mhaye should wait to reveal his info, now that he is out.
Nope nope and nope, and an extra nope! I know this is meaningless, but trust me, you do not want to do this.
I also don’t know if I will even be around to defend myself as I am going away from tomorrow to Monday so will most likely miss EoD. I will try to check in but I don’t know if I will have access.
I trust Lakai’s instincts here so I will place a vote now in case I can’t get back before EoD.
Vote Nanook