I looked at the Brewha voters. It seems to me that it would easy for scum to hide behind the lynch all liars reason, without actually looking at Brewha’s lie or what the alleged scum motivation for it might be.
The problem for me was that there were so many of them and none of them stood out as scummier than most of the others.
What did stand out on re-read was Sachertorte’s vote. It certainly does not look like someone who wants to be identified as a fellow cultist. I agree with Ender that something looks off in the whole cult business.
Brewha votes:
373 Bufftabby thinks Brewha’s plan is a scum gambit
417 Bufftabby unvotes when Chronos explains that the plan was his and not Brewha’s
538 Chronos points out the lie and votes
543 Biotop hops on
556 BoozySquid votes with “It’s not the best case in the world, but it’s by far the best case I’ve seen in this game so far.”
575 Cookies. Willing to switch to Crys if needed.
576 Sachertorte. “I actually wasn’t all that upset about brewha’s lie, but the Crys thing makes me really want brewha dead. Mainly because Crys really doesn’t want brewha dead.”
621 Hooker votes because the switch PM does not match Crys or CaptK’s.
622 Bufftabby. Brewha fessed up to lie when called out on it.
638 Drain Bead. Clear liar who should have fessed up to the lie immediately.
646 RavenThief. Inconsistencies with when the switch PM arrived. Doesn’t match. Earlier lie.
699 Paul. liar who had a very scummy motivation to lie
716 Khameleon. PMs don’t match. Lie.
720 Lakai doesn’t like the explanation for the lie.
726 Meeko
730 ToeJam
743 Crys
767 JohnnyB lynch all liars
794 ProfP
909 Biotop unvotes. Votes ToeJam.
913 Sachertorte unvote. Votes ToeJam. “I have a terrible vote on brewha. I was trying to blend in…”
947 BillMc prefers Brewha over Crys
956 TotalLost
988 Hooker unvotes Brewha. Votes ToeJam.
1002 RavenThief unvotes. Votes ToeJam.
1033 InnerStickler