For the record this is very much the Idle and ToeJam playstyle I remember. Never was able to get a good read on either of them. I’m going to ahead and
vote Idle
for a similar reason that I voted Colby. At worst he is an unhelpful vanilla townie. At best he is a scum. We can’t let scum hide behind over the top playstyles and I do find the fact Idle called for this game and disappeared at least a little odd.
As for Toejam, the doctor is one of the strongest roles remaining, and doesn’t require any knowledge gained to be provided, so I’d lean towards it being a lie. I’m willing to let it play out a bit though rather than risk I’m wrong.
I said I’d start looking at people, and I haven’t had time, but now I got a couple hours to kill. Will start with Mhaye as there was a request on him.