Anyway, I’m still happy with my vote.
I’m not entirely happy with my vote, but I’m glad I’ve put one out there. For those playing along at home, we’ve got THREE VOTES in! I’m almost positive than not all three of Zoggie, fluidruid and Idle are scum, but if this stands, any scum could swoop in in the next 48 hours, place a single vote down on any one of the three, and decide the lynch. Find a reason, some sort of reason, any reason, and just toss a vote somwhere. Poorly guided votes are a hell of a lot better than scum-guided ones, and those are the votes we’ll have if the town won’t vote.
This game, in case no one saw ShadowFact’s chart, is a bloodbath. We don’t have that many more days left . Put a vote in before you’re dead.
Where’s Puff Daddy when you need him? Vote or Die, bitches! 
Right,
Having looked through most of the players I can come to the conclusion that there are really not much in the way of any tells on anybody at the moment. This Day alone only has a couple of pages. it feels like there are 6 instead of 16 players.
The biggest problem I think is the ongoing situation between sachertorte and Idle Thoughts. As I cannot see either of these two being lynched in the short term, I’m ignoring it for the moment.
Other players. Only three others have struck me as being scummy.
DiggitCamara: Still on the list from his slip concerning half the town roles. Yes, its a slip but how serious and of what it means, Im not sure.
Fluidduid: I can see the argument placed before us by Blaster Master. Your votes do seem to follow other people’s reasoning with a little extra added on by yourself
But also this post as well for consideration #617
This comes under the slips marked “you townies” / “our wolf”
Explainable both ways I guess.
MHaye. I would hazard a guess that at least one of the No Lynch party would be a Cabalist trying to get OAOW off. The vote carries plausible deniability in the case he was/was not the Vigilante.
Now: If **Rysto ** was Cabal, I would say **MHaye ** is less likely to be a Cabal as well.
If Rysto was town, I would expect at least one Cabal to have been on the bandwagon and Mhaye had a fair amount of interaction with OAOW earlier that day, so MHaye would be a good bet for a Cabal member.
So, a question for sachertorte, given these arguments, would you be willing to reveal if Rysto was a Cabal member or not?
In order of scumminess I would put it currently as
fluiddruid
Mhaye,
DiggitCamara,
but that may change dependent on any answer I get from sachertorte.
What’s really depressing is that this is Day 3 of the game with 16 people in it and we only have 2 1/2 pages of posts to digest. Only 5 people have over 5 posts and half the players have 3 posts or less.
Please get in here and give your opinions and vote.
One last thing: Idle Thoughts, sachertorte, you have reached an impasse. Instead of going after each other, is there anyone else who you consider scum in the remainder of the players.
Well, that was productive.
Luckily today is my get-off-at-10am day, so I’ll post a vote by early afternoon at the latest. God only knows who I’ll be voting for, though. Things seem to have come to a stalemate.
Me too 
fluiddruid did this in M5 as well. I know because I called her out on it. We lynched her for it. And… she was Town. I don’t say this to necessarily defend fluiddruid (I still don’t like that style) and she could very well be scum in this game, but it is her style.
Rysto is not a member of the Cabal.
This has to be quick, as I’m leaving for home within the next 30 minutes. I’ll be back home around 9:30pm or so but doubt whether I’ll have fully registered Today until late on.
Sachertorte parcelling out his information works to get him confirmed, providing he does (as I understand he will), before Nightfall on any given day, post Roles and Sides that Pleonast will reveal in the following Dusk and Dawn.
Idle presents a whole different kettle of fish. Basically to confirm himself he needs to talk to a Witch, or get verifiable information from an investigator. Freemasons may or may not have any information that can get Idle verified. All he gets from a Mason is a list of other people the dead Mason knows are Masons. In order to use this, he has to out a Mason (that is, state that a living Player is a Mason). I think we’re getting to the point where that is acceptable.
I’ve already made my reservations about Idle speaking to amr known. There’s a very real risk that he’ll get no information that can help him.
Thanks for the information.
Given this piece of information and my previous arguments
vote MHaye
Hehehehe.
What?
Ok, ok, I’ll get some real thoughts in by lunchtime…
I can’t think of any reason why the dead Mason wouldn’t be able to teach him the secret handshake, or whatever, making him, in essence, a Mason as well.
Assuming he’s telling the truth, of course.
:smack:
You know, in Korea, to call someone a wolf means they are constantly thinking dirty thoughts. Just sayin’. 
What’s the other way? I’m inclined to think that, although this has been shown to not necessarily be a scum tell, it seems to be how scum have been caught in the past.
Probably the same reason a dead witch couldn’t tell him how to mix eye of newt and blood of bat, to make him an extra witch. Or a dead Vig couldn’t tell him where he kept his hidden stash of guns. The power gives him information, not abilities.
That’s completely different, IMHO. It’s a hand sign, which can’t be that hard to learn. Heck, Kramer on Seinfeld even identifies himself as member of the “Monroe” gang on accident in one episode. Teaching somebody to be a Witch or teaching them how to be a sniper (or whatever) seems like it’d be pretty hard without some hands-on-training, no pun intended. I can describe any configuration I can put my hands in with words alone, which is, again, IMHO, all you’d have to work with if you were talking to a dead guy.
Did you change your name, from Pygmy Rugger?
Yes, I did. I was just coming in here to give you guys the heads up.
My college club was called the Pygmies, but now I play for Santa Fe’s men’s club, the Santos. The surname is still the same, so hopefully it won’t cause too much confusion.
While what you’re saying may be true, it’s still an in-game power, which I feel seperates itself from mere information. Would you think it’s fair if one of the Masons got converted, and taught the sign to the Omega Wolf? Or all the wolves? But this is entirely besides the point. I’d really like to move on from the whole Idle/sache deal and focus on which person we’re going to string up in the next 27 hours.
And all this time I was wondering what rugging was, and why you did it to those poor pygmies.
It just feels like we’re making stabs in the dark. I’m leaning towards changing my vote to No Lynch.
Dagnabbit, we have so little to go on. Nevertheless, we must soldier on…
When Diggit first made that slip, I had a couple of thoughts about it. First, it seemed certain he was not one of the roles he was confused about about. But second, that didn’t mean he wasn’t another Town role. There was some back and forth from others on these very points. It garnered him some quick votes at the time (which to my mind seemed a little hasty).
What I now find a tiny bit suspicious is that, despite several people mentioning The Slip Up as the reason he is on their suspicion lists (such as CIAS above), he’s never come in and defended himself about it (as far as I can recall). I would think a townie would be in here trying to convince us it was all an innocent mistake and to stop suspecting him. At least, that’s what I would be doing.
So, how 'bout it, Diggit? Care to explain the circumstances of your gaffe a bit more? To give you some added incentive…
Vote DiggitCamara
Regarding the freemason handshake. Given that several people have differing ideas about whether or not it can be passed across, it should be left as an assumption whether or not it could occur.
The simple answer is we don’t know. So unless Pleonast comes forward and tells us, we are stuck with maybe’s. It’s not going to be answered until Idle Thoughts tries it, if he ever does try it.
Now can we leave this and find some scum please.
Zoggie: Please don’t no-lynch, try and find something in the previous few days that sets your scumdar off and bring it up for discussion.