MAFIA: The Game - Ideal for Beginners [Game in Progress]

[Plumpudding]

@Jimmy_Chitwood

This is persuasive, and I think there’s strength in coming closer to a consensus as compared to yet another near-tie. Based on this reasoning, Plum would tell us more and sooner about whether we’re fucking up. Turns out this is the answer to your question about what it would take to get me to vote him.

Vote Plumpudding

Jimmy, I’ve told you for two days that lynching me would be fucking up. I see I’m the favourite, and as it’s closing in on the EOD I guess I’ll go down. I think you guys will get some info out of this, but it will bring town down two players. Lets hope it’s worth it.

[Thing_Fish]

@Plumpudding

This is wrong.

So the opposite of what you are saying here. After Chronos posted the logical conclusion to the tie-breaker plan, I felt pretty sure he was town.

You are right, my mistake.

[Thing_Fish]

@Precambrianmollusc

Bayard – no idea
Biotop - leaning town re the whole tie break analysis
Chronos – leaning town for the tie break analysis, then again he has been on it from day one, for him to be scum we would have to assume he saw from the outset the tie break mechanism was beneficial to scum hence pushed it. Obviously he is an experienced and smart player, my feeling would be if he were a wolf he would not have pushed so hard early without knowing or thorough all the permutations .
Cygnus42
Dante G - the whole tipping hand thing, seams scummy.
DiggitCamara
Jimmy Chitwood
Johnny Bravo
Jsexton think their objection to the coordinated lynch comes more form a ‘play the game; perspective rather than a would trying to stop the coordination
Mahaloth– not sure
Nonsuch
Plumpudding -Seams to be a bit all over the place , throwing a lot of accusations out there, their reasoning may be bad, but I think it’s a genuine attempt to hunt for scum
Precambrianmollusc 13 the towniest town person you could ever hope to meet.
Prof. Pepperwinkle maintaining low profile
sangfroid kind of smudging those ( I think he was aiming at Chronos and Texcat) by calling the disagreements a wolf fight
Sario
septimus I agree with post 360 – scum can screw with us and get mis lynch and things rapidly go sideways, sure we get a would, but we lose the masons pretty quickly, then again like texcat, I can see it as a scum move , depends on motivation, which we cant know
Texcat had I have pretty much agreed from night zero that the coordinated lync is problematic to town. I could see a wolf not liking the scheme, I know I don’t but then , I know I am town, I don’t know what tex cat is. Slight scum lean for now
Thing - lots of discussion

Not sure what sangfroid is getting at (as per usual) but what I notice about this post is that he isn’t saying anything at all about four of my other five possible wolves, is calling the other one (Plumpudding) town, and seems to be leaning town on **JSexton **while saying nothing about Sario. Certainly easy to interpret as scummy.

[Thing_Fish]

Well, looks like I’m going to get what I asked for. Hope to hell I’m right.

[Biotop]

Still 30 minutes to change our minds.

Ayone else really troubled by the theory that Plumpudding posted a fake PM. Because that just doesn’t seem his style at all.

[Plumpudding]

@Biotop

[Snip] I cannot figure out why more wolves did not jump on the easy case against Plum if he is town.

This has been my question as well. I cannot for the life of me see why I wasn’t jumped on yesterDay, as I was clearly the best target.

@Biotop

I think we learn more from finding out about Plum then Diggit.[Snip]

Maybe, maybe not. I would be careful about who to assign blame for my lynch. To me, some are a better bet of being town than others. I think both Jimmy Chitwood and Thing Fish are town, or amazing scum. I think you are town, Biotop, toghether with **Cygnus42 **and Prof. Pepperwinkle. I think I’m less sure about the Prof. than the others in this group. I have gotten a general town read from Nonsuch, but he hasn’t posted enough for me to be sure.

Right now, I believe **DiggitCamara **is a wolf. The rest I’m unsure about, and could go either way for all I know.

[Jimmy_Chitwood]

@Biotop

Still 30 minutes to change our minds.

Ayone else really troubled by the theory that Plumpudding posted a fake PM. Because that just doesn’t seem his style at all.

Of the many thousands of things I am troubled by, this is not one… so there’s that, I guess. If he’s a wolf, of course he’s lying.

[Plumpudding]

@Thing_Fish

Well, looks like I’m going to get what I asked for. Hope to hell I’m right.

You’re not right.

[Precambrianmollusc]

@Thing_Fish

Not sure what sangfroid is getting at (as per usual) but what I notice about this post is that he isn’t saying anything at all about four of my other five possible wolves, is calling the other one (Plumpudding) town, and seems to be leaning town on **JSexton **while saying nothing about Sario. Certainly easy to interpret as scummy.

Of course it should be noted that post was made way back, there wasn’t much to go on for the others or I didn’t have a strong read either way.

[Thing_Fish]

Now begins the compulsive refreshing.

[Prof.Pepperwinkle]

Anyone want to bet Storyteller’s been just called away into a meeting?

[Jimmy_Chitwood]

His light’s green.

[Biotop]

I don’t know if I can ever play this game again. It is just too exhausting.

[Prof.Pepperwinkle]

Yeah, but you’re good at it. I’m tired and I suck at it.

[sangfroid]

Just checking in…

…and waiting with bated? baited? breath.
Must be a thread about that here on the SD *“Proud Home of the Grammer Pedants”*® somewhere…

[Biotop]

I sure hope I am excited and exhilerated. Come on** Plum,** please be scum.

[Jimmy_Chitwood]

His light ain’t green.

[Prof.Pepperwinkle]

It’s “bated breath”.

[Biotop]

Well at least I learned something today.

[storyteller0910]

Day is over; Dusk is forthcoming.