And to append my above post, that puts the scum total at five or six knives used – so there’s a chance they only have one more standard kill.
I have to say that while I couldn’t stop MHaye’s killing, I have mixed feelings about it. Scum was protected last night which means that one of two things would happen. 1) MHaye was town and he died, like he did. Or 2) MHaye was scum and absolutely nothing would happen. Probably not even a note from Storyteller that anything had been attempted. Then we’d have to trust Hal’s claim that he did something last night and figure out whether it failed because of scum’s protection or something else or if Hal was lying, which could have caused all sorts of trouble. But what’s done is done. MHaye’s dead. Visor’s dead. Bleh.
So there’s good news and bad news. The bad news is that two Townies have died. It puts us at a race now at 5-2 which means we MIGHT be down to one lynch if we’re not careful in toDay’s selection.
The good news? It only took two investigations, one Clerk, and a death. But congrats Stanislaus! I believe you’re confirmed town now! 
That puts us at one confirmed town. One neutral (and I’m strongly of the opinion that we’re too close to the end to lynch Hal (so congrats Hal. One way or another it looks like you’ll end up winning)).
That leaves 5 left, including me (though I know where I stand) and two scum.
(I like parentheses)
I’ll vote for someone tomorrow. Not much time today to really review anything.
Updated Player List w/claimed roles and actions (and I’ve simplified the layout a bit)
Alive
6. [del]Alka Seltzer[/del] RyJae - Physician - protected self & visor N1 - no kill?
11. Enderw24 - Nun’s Priest - watched Visor N2 - no activity
19. Hal Briston - Chaucer - gained Shipman power - attempted NK on SP N4 (SP lived) - killed Mahaloth N5
4. Babale - Monk - power unused
9. MentalGuy - Cook - attempted to block Snickers N2
12. [del]Tengu[/del] (now known as Kamino Neko), replaced by Astral Rejection - Merchant
3. Stanislaus - Prioress (investigated as non-scum by fubbleskag, while MHaye says the Cloak of Lies is not in play)
Dead
**7. Texcat - Miller - died with power unused
10. sinjin - Canon - used potion - presumed Restorative, presumed on visor
14. fubbleskag - Man of Law - investigated Stanislaus N1 - S reported non-scum
17. Snickers - Knight - used action - presumably drew attack
16. KellyCriterion - Shipman - power unused - apparently claimed by Hal
15. Mosier - Summoner/Seraph - watched SP N1 - no activity. Watched Babale N4
- Mahaloth - Squire - presumably killed Inner Stickler N5 - killed by Hal N5
- gnarlycharly - Friar - investigated Stanislaus N1 - result: S is non-scum
- Visorslash - Pardoner -Pardoned self D1 - Killed N6
- MHaye - Clerk - checked Cloak N1 - Cloak not in play - killed by Hal N6
- Suburban Plankton - Reeve (claimed Prioress) - didn’t die N4 (despite claimed but unverified attack)
- Inner Stickler - Parson
**
(Color corrected) Updated Player List w/claimed roles and actions (and I’ve simplified the layout a bit)
Alive
6. [del]Alka Seltzer[/del] RyJae - Physician - protected self & visor N1 - no kill?
11. Enderw24 - Nun’s Priest - watched Visor N2 - no activity
19. Hal Briston - Chaucer - gained Shipman power - attempted NK on SP N4 (SP lived) - killed Mahaloth N5
4. Babale - Monk - power unused
9. MentalGuy - Cook - attempted to block Snickers N2
12. [del]Tengu[/del] (now known as Kamino Neko), replaced by Astral Rejection - Merchant
3. Stanislaus - Prioress (investigated as non-scum by fubbleskag, while MHaye says the Cloak of Lies is not in play)
Dead
**7. Texcat - Miller - died with power unused
10. sinjin - Canon - used potion - presumed Restorative, presumed on visor
14. fubbleskag - Man of Law - investigated Stanislaus N1 - S reported non-scum
17. Snickers - Knight - used action - presumably drew attack
16. KellyCriterion - Shipman - power unused - apparently claimed by Hal
15. Mosier - Summoner/Seraph - watched SP N1 - no activity. Watched Babale N4
- Mahaloth - Squire - presumably killed Inner Stickler N5 - killed by Hal N5
- gnarlycharly - Friar - investigated Stanislaus N1 - result: S is non-scum
- Visorslash - Pardoner -Pardoned self D1 - Killed N6
- MHaye - Clerk - checked Cloak N1 - Cloak not in play - killed by Hal N6
- Suburban Plankton - Reeve (claimed Prioress) - didn’t die N4 (despite claimed but unverified attack)
- Inner Stickler - Parson
**
**At least my last sight was a good view. (I like waterfalls, although where you’re going to find one between London and Canterbury is beyond me.)
Story, can I have spoilers please?
Go Town and down the Brotherhood!**
Yeah it actually took Jaelyn until today to be back to normal. Bad runny nose, still walking like she was woozy. I was concerned enough I called the doctor. Her nose is bleeding even as I type this :smack:
It took a lot longer under than they thought but considering they had to do everything from xrays to cleaning to repairing I guess it was to be expected. Autism sucks.
As for the game, I did bad, I am so sorry gnarly. That was, unexpected. You where the one person I was sure was scum, so sure in fact I would have bet my in game life on it.
Stanislaus feel free to :smack: me. What is the course of action you think we should take? Since Day 1 while not always correct you laid out many paths to follow, with insight. I thought you where guiding town for nefarious purposes tbh.
I was shocked reading and being so so so very wrong. Makes me feel rather stupid :mad:
I seriously expected Babale to protect Visorslash last night. It was the safe play, and as a new player, I expected him to make the safe play.
So I protected Stanislaus instead. :smack:
I guessed wrong. I should have protected Visorslash instead of convincing myself that Babale would do it.
Babale, did you use your power last night? If so, on who? If so, why them?
Also, it looks like I should have trusted my gut and pushed harder to get Hal lynched. He’s been terrible for town.
…because lynching me rather than any other mislynch would mean a whopping one more townie alive. A townie who would count against the scum wincon in the same way I do, except scum would be able to do something about them.
Yeah, I’m horrible.
Updated Player List w/claimed roles and actions
Alive
6. [del]Alka Seltzer[/del] RyJae - Physician - protected self & visor N1 - no kill?
11. Enderw24 - Nun’s Priest - watched Visor N2 - no activity
19. Hal Briston - Chaucer - gained Shipman power - attempted NK on SP N4 (SP lived) - killed Mahaloth N5
4. Babale - Monk - power unused
9. MentalGuy - Cook - attempted to block Snickers N2
12. [del]Tengu[/del] (now known as Kamino Neko), replaced by Astral Rejection - Merchant - protected Stanislaus N6.
3. Stanislaus - Prioress (investigated as non-scum by fubbleskag, while MHaye says the Cloak of Lies is not in play)
Dead
**7. Texcat - Miller - died with power unused
10. sinjin - Canon - used potion - presumed Restorative, presumed on visor
14. fubbleskag - Man of Law - investigated Stanislaus N1 - S reported non-scum
17. Snickers - Knight - used action - presumably drew attack
16. KellyCriterion - Shipman - power unused - apparently claimed by Hal
15. Mosier - Summoner/Seraph - watched SP N1 - no activity. Watched Babale N4
- Mahaloth - Squire - presumably killed Inner Stickler N5 - killed by Hal N5
- gnarlycharly - Friar - investigated Stanislaus N1 - result: S is non-scum
- Visorslash - Pardoner -Pardoned self D1 - Killed N6
- MHaye - Clerk - checked Cloak N1 - Cloak not in play - killed by Hal N6
- Suburban Plankton - Reeve (claimed Prioress) - didn’t die N4 (despite claimed but unverified attack)
- Inner Stickler - Parson
**
Assuming no scum tricks, we have two mislynchs left, correct?
Seven left – 4 town, 2 scum, and me. So from either side’s perspespective, it’s 5-2. Barring any surprises, the end of the Day will put us at 4-2 (mislynch) or 5-1 (scum lynch). Morning will then be 3-2 or 4-1.
So toMorrow will end with either 2-2 and game-over-scum-win from a mislynch or 4-0 and game-over-town-wins from a scum lynch. Am I missing anything here?
Assuming that? Maybe we have two mislynches. Maybe not. It’s most probable we have two Days left. But between the bloody spear, the memento, the Seraph dying and scum picking up a new tool, & a hidden element to the game we can’t even begin to guess at, there’s possible path to victory for scum by Night’s end if we’re not careful.
So I’d prefer to play this game under the assumption that we need to guess right toDay, or else.
Damn, I hate losing long posts. Summed-up version:
Yes, sorry, I was unclear there – my post was about a best-case scenario, but there’s no reason to suspect a best case and a lot of reason to suspect scum still have tricks up their sleeve.
I had the Bloody Spear and Memento in mind, but completely forgot that killed the Seraph gives them the ability to swap out a tool.
Day 1 (post 1)
Visorslash vf Suburban Plankton, 10
[del]Visorslash unvote Suburban Plankton,[/del] vf TexCat, 20
vf Visorslash, 98
Alka Seltzer/RyJae vf Mahaloth, 118
TexCat vf no lynch, 122
MentalGuy vf Mahaloth, 124
fubbleskag vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, vf Enderw24, vf Mahaloth, vf KellyCriterion, 128
[del]Alka Seltzer/RyJae unvote Mahaloth,[/del] vf Enderw24, 131
Mahaloth vf Visorslash, 136
Tengu/Astral Rejection vf no lynch, vf Visorslash, 138
Enderw24 vf Snickers, 140
[del]fubbleskag unvote Mahaloth, unvote Alka Seltzer/RyJae,[/del] 141
Stanislaus vf Hal Briston, 144
Hal Briston vf no lynch, 155
fubbleskag vf TexCat, vf Tengu/Astral Rejection, vf Hal Briston, 187
Mosier vf TexCat, 192
Sinjin vf MHaye, 197
Babale vf Visorslash, 200
Snickers vf Hal Briston, 207
[del]fubbleskag unvote Enderw24[/del], 216
[del]MentalGuy unvote Mahaloth,[/del] vf Visorslash, 222
[del]Visorslash unvote TexCat,[/del] vf Visorslash, 224
KellyCriterion vf Tengu/Astral Rejection, 225
[del]Stanislaus unvote Visorslash,[/del] vf Snickers, 226
Suburban Plankton vf Visorslash, 228
[del]Enderw24 unvote Snickers,[/del] vf Visorslash, 230
[del]fubbleskag unvote KellyCriterion,[/del] 235
TexCat vf Visorslash, 238
[del]MentalGuy unvote Visorslash,[/del] vf Snickers, 239
Inner Stickler vf Mosier, 240
[del]fubbleskag unvote Hal Briston, unvote TexCat,[/del] 243
[del]Stanislaus unvote Hal Briston,[/del] 245
MHaye vf Visorslash, 250
gnarlycharlie vf Snickers, 254
Lynch: Visorslash, town Pardoner
Night Kill: none
Day 2 (post 303)
TexCat vf gnarlycharlie, 309
Stanislaus vf Suburban Plankton, 313
gnarlycharlie vf Snickers, 324
sinjin vf MHaye, 326
Enderw24 vf Snickers, 330
[del]Alka Seltzer/RyJae unvote Enderw24,[/del] vf MHaye, 333
Visorslash vf TexCat, 337
MentalGuy vf Snickers, 340
Mahaloth vf TexCat, 349
Snickers vf Mahaloth, 360
[del]Stanislaus unvote Suburban Plankton,[/del] 362
Mosier vf TexCat, 371
Stanislaus vf Inner Stickler, 375
fubbleskag vf Inner Stickler, 378
Babale vf Mosier, 379
MHaye vf Mosier, 381
Hal Briston vf Inner Stickler, 399
TexCat vf Inner Stickler, 402
Inner Stickler vf TexCat, 406
Suburban Plankton vf TexCat, 417
[del]Enderw24 unvote Snickers,[/del] vf TexCat, 422
[del]Babale unvote Mosier,[/del] 425 (not sure this unvote counts)
[del]Alka Seltzer/RyJae unvote MHaye,[/del] vf TexCat, 428
[del]Hal Briston unvote Inner Stickler,[/del] vf gnarlycharlie, 429
Babale vf TexCat, 437
[del]TexCat unvote gnarlycharlie,[/del] 444
TexCat vf gnarlycharlie, vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, vf MHaye, 445
Tengu/Astral Rejection vf MHaye, 448
Lynch: TexCat, town Miller
Night Kill: sinjin, town Canon
Day 3 (post 474)
Stanislaus vf Inner Stickler, vf Enderw24, vf Babale, vf gnarlycharlie, 483
Alka Seltzer/RyJae vf fubbleskag, 489
Visorslash vf fubbleskag, vf Babale, 490
fubbleskag vf Inner Stickler, vf KellyCriterion, 491
Enderw24 vf Mahaloth, vf KellyCriterion, 493
gnarlycharlie vf Snickers, 499
MentalGuy vf Snickers, 507
[del]Stanislaus unvote Enderw24, unvote Inner Stickler,[/del] vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, 510
Hal Briston vf Snickers, 513
Tengu/Astral Rejection vf Alka Seltzer, 515
Mahaloth vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, 517
Mosier vf Babale, 522
Babale vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, 526
Suburban Plankton vf Hal Briston, 536
Babale vf Hal Briston, 539
Snickers vf gnarlycharlie, 541
KellyCriterion vf Tengu/Astral Rejection, vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, 561
[del]Mahaloth unvote Alka Seltzer/RyJae,[/del] vf KellyCriterion, vf Enderw24, 565
[del]Babale unvote Alka Seltzer/RyJae, unvote Hal Briston,[/del] vf KellyCriterion, 566
[del]Hal Briston unvote Snickers,[/del] vf KellyCriterion, 571
[del]Stanislaus unvote Alka Seltzer/RyJae, unvote Babale, unvote gnarlycharlie,[/del] vf fubbleskag, 576
[del]MentalGuy unvote Snickers,[/del] vf Hal Briston, 584
KellyCriterion vf fubbleskag, 590
Inner Stickler vf fubbleskag, 592
[del]Mosier unvote Babale,[/del] vf fubbleskag, 593
MHaye vf Hal Briston, 596
[del]Enderw24 unvote Mahaloth,[/del] 602
Lynch: fubbleskag, town Man of Law
Night Kill: Snickers, town Knight
Substitutions: RyJae for Alka Seltzer, Astral Rejection for Tengu
Day 4 (post 634)
RyJae vf gnarlycharlie, 639
Mosier vf RyJae, 652
Stanislaus vf Mahaloth, vf Hal Briston, 667
Stanislaus vf Enderw24, 668
Suburban Plankton vf Hal Briston, 671
Mahaloth vf KellyCriterion, 681
MentalGuy vf KellyCriterion, 683
Hal Briston vf KellyCriterion, 688
[del]Stanislaus unvote Mahaloth, unvote Enderw24,[/del] 689
MHaye vf Hal Briston, 690
Astral Rejection vf Hal Briston, 692
[del]Enderw24 vf KellyCriterion,[/del] 701
Inner Stickler vf KellyCriterion, 709
gnarlycharlie vf KellyCriterion, 726
Lynch: KellyCriterion
Night Kill: none
Day 5 (738)
Mosier vf Suburban Plankton, 755
Hal Briston vf Suburban Plankton, 756
gnarlycharlie vf Suburban Plankton, 761
Astral Rejection vf Suburban Plankton, 762
Inner Stickler vf Suburban Plankton, 776
[del]gnarlycharlie unvote Suburban Plankton,[/del] 783
Mahaloth vf Suburban Plankton, 812
Visorslash vf Suburban Plankton, 817
Stanislaus vf Suburban Plankton, 818
Suburban Plankton vf Stanislaus , 824
Suburban Plankton vf Mahaloth , 825
Enderw24 vf gnarlycharlie , 827
gnarlycharlie vf Enderw24, 837
MentalGuy vf Suburban Plankton, 838
MHaye vf Suburban Plankton, 839
RyJae vf Stanislaus , 840
Day 6 (900)
Astral Rejection vf Hal Briston 908
Visorslash vf Enderw24 920
Visorslash [del]vf Enderw24[/del] vf Babale 939
Astral Rejection vf Enderw24 953
Babale vf Enderw24 957
MentalGuy vf Enderw24 959
[del] Babale vf Enderw24[/del] 962
Visorslash [del]vf Babale [/del] vf MHaye 967
Hal Briston vf MHaye 968
Astral Rejection [del]vf Enderw24[/del] 969
Enderw24 vf MHaye vf Stanislaus 971
Astral Rejection [del]vf Hal Briston[/del] 982
Stanislaus vf Enderw24 989
Visorslash [del]vf MHaye [/del] vf Enderw24 990
Visorslash vf RyJae 992
Astral Rejection vf Enderw24 998
Visorslash [del]vf Enderw24 vf RyJae[/del] vf gnarlycharlie 1007
gnarlycharlie vf Enderw24 vf Astral Rejection 1010
Astral Rejection [del]vf Enderw24[/del] vf gnarlycharlie 1014
MHaye vf RyJae 1020
Stanislaus[del] vf Enderw24[/del] vf gnarlycharlie 1029
gnarlycharlie [del]vf [/del][del]Enderw24 vf Astral Rejection 1010[/del] vf [COLOR=#0000ff]gnarlycharlie 1030
[/COLOR]Enderw24 [del]vf MHaye vf Stanislaus[/del] vf [COLOR=#0000ff]gnarlycharlie 1031[/COLOR]
gnarlycharlie Lynched 1045
Visorslash knifed 1057
MHaye Lynched(?) Treed to death? 1057
Looks like story took me up on the Chaucer’s “Evil Dead” thing. 
Ender, thanks for tackling that. If you have a reason to redo it, I’ve found actually putting “unvote” on unvotes helps visualize the data. I use “vf” because it’s short for “voted for,” and it’s messing with my brain to see “vf” used for unvotes, too! 
Sure thing. I copied and pasted from the previous version so it should be the same from Day 5 and before (except that I added blue to names as needed).
And yeah, good lord that can be a project. Thankfully I discovered the “switch editor mode” which helped a bit.
Day 1 (post 1)
Visorslash vf Suburban Plankton, 10
[del]Visorslash unvote Suburban Plankton,[/del] vf TexCat, 20
vf Visorslash, 98
Alka Seltzer/RyJae vf Mahaloth, 118
TexCat vf no lynch, 122
MentalGuy vf Mahaloth, 124
fubbleskag vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, vf Enderw24, vf Mahaloth, vf KellyCriterion, 128
[del]Alka Seltzer/RyJae unvote Mahaloth,[/del] vf Enderw24, 131
Mahaloth vf Visorslash, 136
Tengu/Astral Rejection vf no lynch, vf Visorslash, 138
Enderw24 vf Snickers, 140
[del]fubbleskag unvote Mahaloth, unvote Alka Seltzer/RyJae,[/del] 141
Stanislaus vf Hal Briston, 144
Hal Briston vf no lynch, 155
fubbleskag vf TexCat, vf Tengu/Astral Rejection, vf Hal Briston, 187
Mosier vf TexCat, 192
Sinjin vf MHaye, 197
Babale vf Visorslash, 200
Snickers vf Hal Briston, 207
[del]fubbleskag unvote Enderw24[/del], 216
[del]MentalGuy unvote Mahaloth,[/del] vf Visorslash, 222
[del]Visorslash unvote TexCat,[/del] vf Visorslash, 224
KellyCriterion vf Tengu/Astral Rejection, 225
[del]Stanislaus unvote Visorslash,[/del] vf Snickers, 226
Suburban Plankton vf Visorslash, 228
[del]Enderw24 unvote Snickers,[/del] vf Visorslash, 230
[del]fubbleskag unvote KellyCriterion,[/del] 235
TexCat vf Visorslash, 238
[del]MentalGuy unvote Visorslash,[/del] vf Snickers, 239
Inner Stickler vf Mosier, 240
[del]fubbleskag unvote Hal Briston, unvote TexCat,[/del] 243
[del]Stanislaus unvote Hal Briston,[/del] 245
MHaye vf Visorslash, 250
gnarlycharlie vf Snickers, 254
Lynch: Visorslash, town Pardoner
Night Kill: none
Day 2 (post 303)
TexCat vf gnarlycharlie, 309
Stanislaus vf Suburban Plankton, 313
gnarlycharlie vf Snickers, 324
sinjin vf MHaye, 326
Enderw24 vf Snickers, 330
[del]Alka Seltzer/RyJae unvote Enderw24,[/del] vf MHaye, 333
Visorslash vf TexCat, 337
MentalGuy vf Snickers, 340
Mahaloth vf TexCat, 349
Snickers vf Mahaloth, 360
[del]Stanislaus unvote Suburban Plankton,[/del] 362
Mosier vf TexCat, 371
Stanislaus vf Inner Stickler, 375
fubbleskag vf Inner Stickler, 378
Babale vf Mosier, 379
MHaye vf Mosier, 381
Hal Briston vf Inner Stickler, 399
TexCat vf Inner Stickler, 402
Inner Stickler vf TexCat, 406
Suburban Plankton vf TexCat, 417
[del]Enderw24 unvote Snickers,[/del] vf TexCat, 422
[del]Babale unvote Mosier,[/del] 425 (not sure this unvote counts)
[del]Alka Seltzer/RyJae unvote MHaye,[/del] vf TexCat, 428
[del]Hal Briston unvote Inner Stickler,[/del] vf gnarlycharlie, 429
Babale vf TexCat, 437
[del]TexCat unvote gnarlycharlie,[/del] 444
TexCat vf gnarlycharlie, vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, vf MHaye, 445
Tengu/Astral Rejection vf MHaye, 448
Lynch: TexCat, town Miller
Night Kill: sinjin, town Canon
Day 3 (post 474)
Stanislaus vf Inner Stickler, vf Enderw24, vf Babale, vf gnarlycharlie, 483
Alka Seltzer/RyJae vf fubbleskag, 489
Visorslash vf fubbleskag, vf Babale, 490
fubbleskag vf Inner Stickler, vf KellyCriterion, 491
Enderw24 vf Mahaloth, vf KellyCriterion, 493
gnarlycharlie vf Snickers, 499
MentalGuy vf Snickers, 507
[del]Stanislaus unvote Enderw24, unvote Inner Stickler,[/del] vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, 510
Hal Briston vf Snickers, 513
Tengu/Astral Rejection vf Alka Seltzer, 515
Mahaloth vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, 517
Mosier vf Babale, 522
Babale vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, 526
Suburban Plankton vf Hal Briston, 536
Babale vf Hal Briston, 539
Snickers vf gnarlycharlie, 541
KellyCriterion vf Tengu/Astral Rejection, vf Alka Seltzer/RyJae, 561
[del]Mahaloth unvote Alka Seltzer/RyJae,[/del] vf KellyCriterion, vf Enderw24, 565
[del]Babale unvote Alka Seltzer/RyJae, unvote Hal Briston,[/del] vf KellyCriterion, 566
[del]Hal Briston unvote Snickers,[/del] vf KellyCriterion, 571
[del]Stanislaus unvote Alka Seltzer/RyJae, unvote Babale, unvote gnarlycharlie,[/del] vf fubbleskag, 576
[del]MentalGuy unvote Snickers,[/del] vf Hal Briston, 584
KellyCriterion vf fubbleskag, 590
Inner Stickler vf fubbleskag, 592
[del]Mosier unvote Babale,[/del] vf fubbleskag, 593
MHaye vf Hal Briston, 596
[del]Enderw24 unvote Mahaloth,[/del] 602
Lynch: fubbleskag, town Man of Law
Night Kill: Snickers, town Knight
Substitutions: RyJae for Alka Seltzer, Astral Rejection for Tengu
Day 4 (post 634)
RyJae vf gnarlycharlie, 639
Mosier vf RyJae, 652
Stanislaus vf Mahaloth, vf Hal Briston, 667
Stanislaus vf Enderw24, 668
Suburban Plankton vf Hal Briston, 671
Mahaloth vf KellyCriterion, 681
MentalGuy vf KellyCriterion, 683
Hal Briston vf KellyCriterion, 688
[del]Stanislaus unvote Mahaloth, unvote Enderw24,[/del] 689
MHaye vf Hal Briston, 690
Astral Rejection vf Hal Briston, 692
[del]Enderw24 vf KellyCriterion,[/del] 701
Inner Stickler vf KellyCriterion, 709
gnarlycharlie vf KellyCriterion, 726
Lynch: KellyCriterion
Night Kill: none
Day 5 (738)
Mosier vf Suburban Plankton, 755
Hal Briston vf Suburban Plankton, 756
gnarlycharlie vf Suburban Plankton, 761
Astral Rejection vf Suburban Plankton, 762
Inner Stickler vf Suburban Plankton, 776
[del]gnarlycharlie unvote Suburban Plankton,[/del] 783
Mahaloth vf Suburban Plankton, 812
Visorslash vf Suburban Plankton, 817
Stanislaus vf Suburban Plankton, 818
Suburban Plankton vf Stanislaus , 824
Suburban Plankton vf Mahaloth , 825
Enderw24 vf gnarlycharlie , 827
gnarlycharlie vf Enderw24, 837
MentalGuy vf Suburban Plankton, 838
MHaye vf Suburban Plankton, 839
RyJae vf Stanislaus , 840
Day 6 (900)
Astral Rejection vf Hal Briston 908
Visorslash vf Enderw24 920
Visorslash [del]unvote Enderw24[/del] vf Babale 939
Astral Rejection vf Enderw24 953
Babale vf Enderw24 957
MentalGuy vf Enderw24 959
[del] Babale unvote Enderw24[/del] 962
Visorslash [del]unvote Babale [/del] vf MHaye 967
Hal Briston vf MHaye 968
Astral Rejection [del]unvote Enderw24[/del] 969
Enderw24 vf MHaye vf Stanislaus 971
Astral Rejection [del]unvote Hal Briston[/del] 982
Stanislaus vf Enderw24 989
Visorslash [del]unvote MHaye [/del] vf Enderw24 990
Visorslash vf RyJae 992
Astral Rejection vf Enderw24 998
Visorslash [del]unvote Enderw24 vf RyJae[/del] vf gnarlycharlie 1007
gnarlycharlie vf Enderw24 vf Astral Rejection 1010
Astral Rejection [del]unvote Enderw24[/del] vf gnarlycharlie 1014
MHaye vf RyJae 1020
Stanislaus[del] unvote Enderw24[/del] vf gnarlycharlie 1029
gnarlycharlie [del][COLOR=#000000]unvote [/del][/COLOR][del]Enderw24 vf Astral Rejection[/del] vf [COLOR=#0000ff]gnarlycharlie 1030
[/COLOR]Enderw24 [del]unvote MHaye vf Stanislaus[/del] vf [COLOR=#0000ff]gnarlycharlie 1031[/COLOR]
gnarlycharlie Lynched 1045
Visorslash knifed 1057
MHaye fatal case of [COLOR=blue]Dendrophobia 1057[/COLOR]
It’s an adventure every time I make one!
(actual scum hunting will come after work)
vote Babale pending explanation of what his unused protection was doing last Night.
vote Ender for all the reasons laid out yesterDay.
So from my perspective, there are four players left and two are scum.
I’m looking at Astral Rejection’s voting record and I’m not seeing scum. First, yesterday, he was all over the map. Six separate votes (voting for me twice!), looks legitimately like indecision. But also on Day 5, when the bandwagon started for Suburban, Astral was 4th on the voting list. 5th came Inner, but I think there’s a big difference between 4th and 5th here. If Astral was scum, I think there would have been plenty of time start a new bandwagon with a different player (which could have then been backed by Inner). But #4 practically seals Suburban’s fate and I think it was too soon for scum to need to resort to that. I’m open to hearing others opinions, but I’m looking elsewhere.
I also think I lean town on MentalGuy. I took a look at some of the things I had accussed him of in the past and, with the benefit of hindsight, can see now that I was calling him out along with another Townie and a Third Party dude (post 534). Sure he voted against me yesterday, but I’ve looked back on what, specifically, he was accusing me of and it’s asking questions that, frankly, I don’t think scum would be too concerned about knowing. Like why I never followed up on my Snickers line of thought. So I like how he’s been thinking. He’s wrong about me, but still…
I know it seems weird to go scum hunting by finding town, but, as I said above, from my perspective we’re down to 2 scum and 2 town to vote for. So if you eliminate one side of the equation…
VOTE RYJAE
VOTE BABALE
Okay, I am finally checking in toDay. We took a family trip yesterday, and I started back to work today, so this is the first chance I have had to sit down and play. Fortunately, there wasn’t a whole lot to catch up on. Unfortunately, that means there wasn’t much new information.
If Ender flips scum, then that would make me suspect Astral somewhat since she (he? I forget) was fairly instrumental in saving Ender. Unfortunately, we don’t really have the luxury of lynching Ender just to get that information.
So of the players left, I consider Stanislaus confirmed Town. I don’t know if Hal is being completely honest, but I do think he is a third party player of some type and the rules prevent him from being a PFK. And I know that I am not scum. So that leaves Astral, Ender, Ryjae, and Babale. There has to be two scum in that group (I realize any Town players in that group will just replace their own name with mine). I have generally had a Town lean on Astral, but if Ender is scum, then I could buy that Astral might also be scum. Mosier thought Ryjae was scum and gave a way that it could be true, but I did not really see any reason to suspect Ryjae over some of the other players. That leaves Ender and Babale. For me, it is almost a coin flip. I have leaned slightly more toward Ender being scum, primarily because of the PM Visorslash revealed, but I think I do need to try to go back and look at these two again. I will try to do that tomorrow.