My point was to show that I know who I targeted without forcing them to out themselves. (A Townie with 2 targets might be a juicy target for a Scum roleblocker). So I chose a way to identify the person as part of a not too small, but not too large subset.
Although I think sangaman is quite suspicious
(for the slip
for his style
for Meeko’s vote on Krayz)
could people please stop voting him for now. We have lots of time left to look at other people and still come back to him.
vote Astral Rejection
Voting for gnarly and Episkey because of the messages is poor logic, given how unreliable they have proven to be. Your case on Episkey was extremely thin, and really doesn’t justify your vote on him.
Ed got his role (and alignment, Ed?) and PCM got someone’s role and alignment, but with the wrong name.
Sorry for me being UTR. I keep forgetting to catch up with this game, and when i do remember I’m always distracted 
I got a message last night that dancecat was town, though that is now completely worthless given she’s dead, she must have targetted me with her night action, which would make sense given that we’ve played together a lot
Agreed
insane/paranoid cops will eventually find out what they are depending on their investigations dying, there is no need to investigate the same people over and over.
It would be wrong in my opinion for any wolf to target another wolf to find out their powers, as they will usually have a killing role and a wolf vigging themselves is just lol bad.
I have no idea why you’re voting pizzaguy, he’s probably my biggest town read, only because he seems to genuinely be trying to work this game out, even if I don’t agree with him. i don’t know him so he could be able to fake this, but since I don’t, he’s probably town.
And where is Pizza when you need him? Since he, allegedly, has received 2 investigative results, I really want to ask him if the wording was identical on the two.
I don’t get this post.
You think sanga is scummy, but then you urge people to not vote him?
Well, I got a complete role PM. Worded much like the ones showing up in the death reveals.
This is only our second game with him, but I totally think that he could fake it.
I disagree with Episkey’s implied conclusion. I think it makes more sense that Episkey’s action on **PizzaGuy **gave PizzaGuy the message about NAF.
I recall that, and I believe I suggested that could have been the Apothecary.
And I thought that made sense at the time, but I am sure now that the color of the protection roles is different for each role.
When people have a vote they think is on scum they often stop looking for the day. Sure, lynch sangaman, but we don’t need to do it yet.
His is basically the only case being made today. There is a lot of talk in the thread about roles and claims, but much less about who is scum. Town want to work out their roles as well, but these kind of conversations give scum a) a lot of info, and b) a way to be involved, and look active without having to make cases. Episkey has claimed cop now. Good that he knows, I guess, and hopefully the docs know their powers as well (seems like there’s good chance they do), but there’s only a couple of them, and they will need to coordinate to keep him alive, and then there are the masons to protect as well. I want people to talk about something else besides sangamaan is scum and who the cops might be.
NETA: I am not sure that the color has anything to do with the role. The apothecary role may give a warm glow or maybe makes you feel healthy. But I am sure that if you think you might be a doc because you made someone have a warm glow N1, and someone feel safe on N2, then you are not a doc. Your targets will all have the same feeling each night. Your targets (or the redirected results of your targets).
What’s possibly bothering NAF, and what should turn up is that I’m not really making any cases. I’m struggling to follow up. I missed out on most of the Cop ‘debacle’ yesterDay. ToDay, I’ve only really commented on things pertaining to myself.
That isn’t to say I’m not following along with everything else.
However, I’m not following as closely as I should be. I’m still forming a few opinions and thoughts. Maybe at some point ehy will solidify.
There are just so many people in this game.
Just occurred to me that Episkey could have constructed a fake cop claim here to deflect the message ATPG got. He can’t be counterclaimed when we don’t know the setup, and the last game had several cops.
hey guys, spent the day working and playing a POG Game, been skimming a few posts when I have the chance.
I have had two night actions, both with no result, however, my one last night was re-directed.
I suppose it’s plausible that thats the case, but it isn’t. As I said when I announced my opinion of what’s occurring, please look at my body of work this game rather than a message that - from your perspective - could just as easily be fake as real as evident by one role already revealed which provided false messages. I understand that nobody else has the information of my role that I do and so it’s up in the air to them, but this message is false. I believe it’ll become evident the longer this game goes on.
On another note: I’ve realized it might not even be someone that’s targeted exactly Gnarly -> Me the first two nights that is the one who chooses who my targets get an investigation from. There could have been a randomization occurring last night onto whoever it is.
Seriously? You think he’s the most pro-town? He’s been throwing out theories with little substantiation and demanding DEMANDING that people follow his theories.
How many times has he DEMANDED that people take his poll?
How many times has he DEMANDED that everyone vote for me? Especially based on his ill conceived reasoning.
Does he really think that his asinine habit of replying to a confrontational post line by line gives him more town cred? To me it looks overly defensive.
He is a prolific poster and takes up bandwidth. If that makes him a pro-town read, than you are easily manipulated. Was it the memes? Are you afraid he’ll “be disappoint” with you?
If I want lolcats, I’ll go to failblog.
But, lolcats aint gonna help the town win this game.
I am currently voting Astral Rejection for voting you, so it wasn’t an accusation. Just a possibility people should keep in mind.
I have looked over your posts. You were poking at people on Day 1, had a decent enough vote on Silver Jan, didn’t say anything on Day2, when you were moving, but were the 5th vote on Blam, commented on NKills, and have been figuring out your role today. Not rock solid but looks Townie.
poisoner was town 89% sure in that game
wolves probably can’t have vig + poisoner anyway
and it would be stupid for wolves to target themselves n1 if they did
also i agree with donk, pizza is basically lock villa
Brewha has definitely fooled me before. But voting him now seems silly when he is poisoned. The only possible reason for voting brewha would be a scum looking to get town cred when brewha flips scum.