So you don’t have any idea whose alignment you even whisper? i.e. you target Silver Jan but you have no idea who the whisper Silver Jan gets will be about?
That really seems unlikely to be a town role.
See, I agree with you. It’s why I’m in this situation I’m in: my role is NOT protown at all. It sucks. I hate it. But I can’t do anything about it. I do have two questions I think you should answer though:
1.) Let me preface this with stating I typically hate this argument. With that said, ask yourself why in my right mind would THIS be my masterful plan as a wolf? I’m sitting here jumping up and down screaming that I’m an anti-town role and THAT should save me? I’d like to think I could come up with a better argument than that if I were scum, but instead I’m just presenting what I know about my role. Does that seem like the optimal wolf play to you?
2.) Here’s the important one:
Let’s look at this as if I WERE a scum insane whisperer giving out a bunch of backwards peeks. So lets say as the game progresses, I send out Players A,B,D are wolves and Player C is a villager. Then lets say I die and my role is revealed as “Insane scum whisperer”. Well, now you can look at all the peeks I’ve given and realize players A,B, and D are actually villagers while player C is actually scum.
So in reality, I’d be a wolf role that GIVES THE VILLAGER PROPER INFORMATION ON ROLES EVERY NIGHT ONCE IM DEAD. That is like the most anti-wolf role every for a wolf to have, isn’t it?
My role just creates chaos and confusion to start, but it’s a town role. I hate it due to the pressure I get because of it, but when you break it down it makes more sense as a town role than a scum role does it not?
Yeah I have absolutely ZERO idea of how the target of the investigation itself is chosen. Initially I thought it was like a duo where i chose person to receive investigation and someone else chose who gets investigated, but since nobody has claimed to save me I doubt thats whats going on.
I have no clue. I’m in the dark just as much as everyone
Unless you’re paranoid instead. Although you’re making a good argument for why an insane whisperer could be pro town. Now I’m unsure again 
yeah, if im paranoid I just give up and give gad the evil eye. at least insane is useful lol
Either way - you aren’t currently the lynch leader if I’m counting right.
Crackedquads : Do you have a defense? Role claim? Anything? Since it seems likely you’re going to be lynched do you want to tell us who you targeted each night so we don’t lose information on your death?
Generating a lynch that will provide meaningful data. Same as usually.
See, however, your role is Pro-Scum if you don’t accurately reveal which peeks are yours and which aren’t. We won’t know which ones to trust and distrust.
Now, granted, I think we’ve been very fortunate in one regard, most of the whisperers have died.
I’m still unsure of Episkeys result on pwnsall. I’m not convinced that the whisper would have returned to him when gnarlycharlie died. Either he’s right, and he did get the result. Or he lied and got no result when gnarlycharlie died, or there’s another whisperer.
It makes zero sense for me to lie about something so out there in either role though.
I wouldn’t lie as a villa obviously
I wouldn’t lie as scum if I could just say “Meh targeted gnarly and he died”
I got it, and my guess was it was because my target died.
Well if you were scum you could be trying to protect a possible scumbuddy in pwnsall. Not saying it’s the most likely, just something to consider if you do flip scum.
Yeah, maybe you thought it through poorly.
Or maybe you wanted more evidence of your paranoia to try to clear yourself.
One of the prettiest non answers I’ve seen in a while
Thanks. I was originally going to go with something in the voice of Brain from the Animaniacs but thought this was more elegant. It was silly question, particularly coming from Ed.
This is the crux of my issue. First his targets got wrong messages about other people. Then one allegedly got a wrong message about him. And then when he targeted himself, he got a wrong message about himself. What are the odds?
and how does a lynch of crackedquads genrate more information than a lynch of Episkey?
Especially since we’ll find Episkey’s true role if he were to be lynched.
What data will be gained from a lynch of crackedquads?
Wait, did he target himself on the last night or pwnsall?
the days sort of just blend together at this point
lightfoot 2.0 are you a wolf?
At this point, I’m pondering a NAF and Episkey as Scumbuddies (odd isn’t it, with my vote on crackedquads. He may very well be Scum too.
I wonder if NAF stole PizzaGuy’s power and used it last Night on Drain Bead.
However, I haven’t gone back to check how that works with lilflower and Normal Phase claiming to have been doubled on the same Night I doubled Drain Bead.
I’m thinking it doesn’t work out.
NAF’s actions:
N0 steals peeker’s power (or anyone’s really)
N1 steals my power
N2 re-steals my power from himself?
N3 claims to have targeted Normal and lilflower (would have needed to target PizzaGuy. Normal, lilflower and Drain all claim having been doubled)
N4 (would have needed to target DrainBead)
If NAF is lying, the so are lilflower and Normal. It just seems highly unlikely. NAF and Normal would never go along with a plan that linked 3 Scum together.Good lord. I don’t even know how to begin to catch up. Ugh.
vote NAF
Because it seems to be between NAF and Episkey at this point, and NAF has made a scummier impression on me than Episkey.