Mystery Mafia -- Game Thread

Also, the “mafia” cop said someone was innocent. Bad move.

We can guaranteed hit a scumbag now.

I think I just made up for being annoying. Hallefreakinglujah. :D:D:D

Drain, Don’t waste your breathe on this. Jan did not target Charlie. She is not confirmed as a cop of any variety.

**Everyone **please examine TexCat, DanceCat, Silver Jan, and Blaster.

One of these four is guilty. We can still save this round, help me figure out which one it is.

Let’s say the oracle thing is happening and that it IS with those five roles…that would mean that Weedy’s result is most likely from the sane oracle, whereas Silver Jan’s could be from the insane one or the paranoid one. I know I’m Town, so mine isn’t scummy, that divides up **Giraffe **and Scuba’s reads from the naive OR paranoid OR insane (depending on which one Jan’s got and which one mine isn’t) and my read between the naive OR paranoid OR insane one (depending on which one Jan got and which one the non-scummy Giraffe or Scuba got)
I sure hope that all made sense because it BARELY made sense to me and I’m the one who wrote it.

It could all be redundant, though, if it’s not the case.

you’re making the same mistake I did. SilverJan isn’t a cop, she’s one of the people who got a result from one of the cops

Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk

shoot on a shingle.

unvote all

vote giraffe.

Sorry, hit reply instead of quote. This was in reply to drainbead

Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk

unvote all
vote: texCat for now.

I don’t trust the mason claim, and lynching TexCat will yield useful information both on the other 3 (all likely innocent if she’s guilty) and her claimed mason partner (50% chance they’re guilty if she is)

All aboard the TexCat wagon! We gots to spare Scuba!

Idle, I didn’t think that you targeted Jan. Did you? If not, your result, regardless of your affiliation has nothing to do with your result and could be true or false? Just as I assume that Jan’s result does not have to do with her affiliation.

Ack! What happened to waiting for more info? There were definitely masons in earlier versions of this game.

This is a total reversal from Pizza, and looks scummy to me. Been talking to your scum partners, Pizza?

DanceCat’s posts
TexCat’s posts
Silver Jan’s posts
Blaster Master’s posts

I have no idea if the searches will work, they have search IDs, so maybe the links won’t be valid for anyone but me.

However, I can go over their votes really quickly. We have less than a day remaining but that’s plenty to solve this.

Well, I think we can cross Texcat off that list, as she’s claimed Mason and Weedy (if Weedy is to be believed) got the message he was a Mason last night. Since Texcat couldn’t have known Weedy got that (if Texcat is to be believed)…I’d say that pretty much shows that Texcat is a mason.

And (again, IF we’re going by the five oracle’s assumption), we can probably deduce that Jan is telling the truth. Jan’s read was either from the Insane or Paranoid cop, since a wolf cop would probably lie about their fellow scum’s results and say they were Town, not wolf. So the fact that she’s giving a result of wolf would mean she could be crossed off.

So what happened to the results from the Night actions of Jan, Weedy, et al? Or did all if you also get a PM with another result? (I’m not asking anyone to claim what they did or what result they got.)

[quote=TexCat;14170648This is a total reversal from Pizza, and looks scummy to me. Been talking to your scum partners, Pizza?[/quote]

BARK BARK BARK BARK BARK WOOF WOOF WOOF WOOF!!!

I found a scumbag master! May I kill it?
@Idle:

Oh fine. You want to believe the crazy mason claim? Okay I’ll look at the others. Recommendation?

Sorry for cutting that off. Posting from iPad, lost cursor, couldn’t get it back.

So.

Charlie is Scum:
–Jan and Scuba are Town. Tex is Scum.

Charlie is Town:
–Tex is Town. We don’t know, but suspect Jan and Scuba.

Again, I think we get more info from a Jan lynch, and it’s clear that we have either lying or untrustworthy info from her or Tex/Charlie. Killing her will tell us which that is, while killing Charlie won’t necessarily do so.

unvote gnarlycharlie
vote Silver Jan

I’m drunk and open to suggestion, though.

Sorry, I keep thinking Texcat is male and I’m mixing pronouns :smack:

The above SHOULD read:
Well, I think we can cross Texcat off that list, as she’s claimed Mason and Weedy (if Weedy is to be believed) got the message she was a Mason last night. Since Texcat couldn’t have known Weedy got that (if Texcat is to be believed)…I’d say that pretty much shows that Texcat is a mason.

Nah, I didn’t target anyone in this huge kerfuffle.

NETA @ pizza: Yes, lynching me would result in a lot of info. Waiting till tomorrow to lynch me would yield a lot more info. Why the reversal?

Buh?!

This is what I get for replying on a post by post basis.

That’s a complete, 100 percent, turn in what you were just talking about.

This makes me more suspicious of you.