Mornin folks! No votin’ here either.
As to poor FCD: Here are two stories to perhaps share with him.
If you were a caregiver, or even an interested bystander, there is always guilt after the infirm person dies. It doesn’t matter how much you did, including herculean efforts, you could have done more. And you know it. The trick is to persuade yourself that what you did was enough. And its the total over your/their life that matters, not the last 2 weeks or whatever. And don’t remember to allow the other person agency. e.g. if late BIL would have refused the kidney transplant anyhow, it’s not your fault you didn’t override his wishes and force it upon him. It’s his. We can all lament his stubbornness, but don’t blame yourself for his behavior.
My late first wife has been dead over 2 years now (Wow!). I still often regret the things I left undone for her in those last few days and hours. But I’m long past guilt over it, and never had debilitating guilt, just significant guilt. No one who was there believes I left a single stone unturned, a single thing undone. I know different. But I’ve managed to get to where I can live with that knowledge. Not because I’m cavalier, but because clairvoyant perfection in the heat of battle is an unachievable goal and I know that my emotions want to hold me to that unattainable standard.
Story 2:
A good friend of mine developed hepatitis. Probably from a needle stick as a first responder. A youth of drugs followed by a life of drinking didn’t help though, and eventually at age 60ish his liver was crapping out. And yet he still drank. Not alcoholically, just socially and heavily.
As he was getting acute there was quite a fight among the care team about whether he was a good enough candidate for a liver or whether his general decrepitude and unwillingness / inability to curb his drinking made his case hopeless and just a waste of a otherwise good transplant candidate. He turned over a new enough leaf, or persuaded them he had, and he did end up getting a replacement liver.
Which liver he killed by drinking over the next 5-7 utterly miserable years. Miserable both for him and his angelic spouse who cared for him at home night and day for the whole decade-long descent. His death was a tragedy, but it was also a relief for everyone who’d ever known or cared about him. People who refuse to help themselves eventually become a burden too great for anyone, including themselves, to carry.
IMO FCD’s BIL was cut from this same cloth and was following the same path. And would have with or without a new kidney. The details differ, the big picture does not.
As others have rightly said, Logic isn’t effective here; FCD will have to emote his way out of the spot he’s emoted his way into. At the same time, intellectual awareness that there are other ways, and other reactions possible, and that other people have gotten through it, gives the hope he doesn’t use his logical brain to reinforce being stuck, rather than using it to pull, however weakly at first, towards emotional recovery.
Switching targets … I hope the situation with truefish’s Dad becomes clear, and more calm soon. There is so much wrapped up in the infirmity and death of a parent. Most of us get to live through that, but none of do well with it, and especially at the time. Big {{{hugs}}}.