People, people, people. What’s the deal? I KNOW there’s more pornophiles on this board than that.
Never EVER EVER let a first-timer pick the movie. Why? They usually end up getting a lame-o one that’s a play on some famous movie title. Real life example: SO decides to pick up PULP FRICTION, a wretched excuse for porn.
Never ever make a first-timer watch that amateur stuff. Try showing her a Max Hardcore piece of misogyny and she’ll never speak to you again, let alone watch another porno. The Ed Powers “Dirty Debutante” series is equally creepy, in that all it is is a middle-aged putz with a pony tail inviting teenagers with a “when do I get my money?” look over to his house for pervy sex. Remember, you want the lady to ENJOY the movie. That said, most of the male performers in the amateur movies are pot-bellied, balding, and usually creepy. Amateur movies in general also have NO plot whatsoever. Your woman will be shocked that that’s all there is to pornography.
Steer clear of the “classics.” These things were made mostly in the 70s, so it looks like a grainy, grungy piece of color-faded filth. All the men are as hairy as bigfoots, and at least half of them aren’t circumcised. Not to mention that everyone in 70s porno is as pale as a ghost. DEEP THROAT, DEBBIE DOES DALLAS, and GREEN DOOR are wildly overrated to begin with. For the most part, the ensemble players in porn flicks didn’t get attractive until the 80s.
Don’t even THINK about getting a movie that seems like it’s all girl lezzie fest. Recipe for disaster, I think you know why. Same thing with movies that play up the anal sex aspect.
Your best bet is to find something relatively new. If there’s a hot chick on the box, go for it. But be sure there’s at least one piece of male eyecandy in there for the ladies. My girlfriends in the past have generally liked movies with Peter “The Decorator” North or Randy Spears. The aggressive “styles” of a TT Boy or a Tony Montana might be a turn-off for her.
It also might be wise to rent two movies, just in case one turns out to be a lame piece of crap, you can always pop in the other one. And believe me, there’s a lot of tepid crap out there.