Since the guy was hiding. The article doesn’t mention any threatening moves. Should the mom have held him at gunpoint and called 911?
I wish they’d give more details in these news reports.
Bone
June 27, 2016, 2:58pm
882
Not enough details, but under Oregon law she’s probably in the clear. § 161.219 says that a person is justified in using deadly force if the person reasonably believes that the other person is (2) committing or attempting to commit a burglary in a dwelling.
In other news, MAN SHOOTS, INJURES INTRUDER
The suspect is identified as 34-year-old Blake Elliot Herman. He was shot in the leg.
The resident told investigators he heard a noise coming from his sister’s bedroom. When he opened the door, he reported seeing a man standing in the doorway. The resident adds, he feared for his life thinking Herman had a gun.
Herman told deputies he had a key to the home. He also admitted that he used to date the woman who lives at the home and that he was there to get revenge.
DGU with no deaths. I would say changing the locks after you move into a new place is a good idea.
Bone
June 28, 2016, 3:14pm
883
In other news,Teen burglars greeted by gunfire in Jeannette
When four juveniles tried to enter a home through a window late Tuesday night, two of them were shot by a man who lives in the house, Jeannette police said.
The other boy who was shot, a 13-year old, was found on Chambers Avenue, police said.
DGU with no deaths. 4 vs 1 and the one prevailed. Reading the article it seems like both the homeowner and the burglars began posting to Facebook immediately about the incident which seems unwise.
Bone:
In other news,Teen burglars greeted by gunfire in Jeannette
DGU with no deaths. 4 vs 1 and the one prevailed. Reading the article it seems like both the homeowner and the burglars began posting to Facebook immediately about the incident which seems unwise.
Not sure why that’s “positive.” I know in this case nobody was killed but if I killed an unarmed 13-year-old even if he was trying to break into my house, it would haunt me for the rest of my life.
Dickerman:
Woman shoots former abusive boyfriend: http://www.kansascity.com/news/nation-world/national/article85770537.html
DGU with boyfriend shot and behind bars. Another good example of how a firearm empowers women in the face of real threats to their lives. The boyfriend had threatened to kill the woman, had violated a restraining order against him three times, and broke into her house while an alarm system was being installed. I’m glad we’re not hearing about the alternate ending.
He was not fatally shot, just in the foot. He landed in jail but I’m afraid that you won’t hear about *any *ending until one of them is dead. I hope it’s him.
Bone
June 28, 2016, 4:05pm
886
It would be unfortunate - but I regard being able to defend yourself from home invasion by 4 people as a positive thing.
I guess there is a debate over whether home invasion per se poses a threat requiring deadly force to defend. I guess it depends on the laws of whatever state, and of course the individual situation. (See also: not-so-positive story about the man who killed his own teenage son thinking it was a home invasion.)
Bone
June 29, 2016, 4:41pm
888
All states allow self defense including lethal self defense if necessary to defend your life or the life of another. The specific fact pattern matters, but generally when in your own home and someone has forcibly entered or attempts to enter, this satisfies the requirement that a person be in reasonable fear of great bodily injury.
In other news, Deputies: Neighbor catches burglar in the act, held him at gunpoint
Deputies said they were called to a home on Double Branch Road in Cowpens shortly after 5 p.m. Monday.
Deputies arrived to find Jimmy Rhodes on his knees on the back porch with the homeowner pointing a gun at him.
Rhodes was placed in handcuffs while deputies investigated.
The neighbor told deputies he investigated when he heard the dog next door barking excessively and found the moped and damaged door. The suspect came out of the house after the neighbor called the homeowner, and he ordered the man to get down while he then called deputies.
DGU with no injuries. If that’s my neighbor I’m buying him a 6 pack. Good job neighbor!
Bone
June 30, 2016, 2:38pm
891
In other news, Mother shoots attempted break-in suspect who entered through baby’s window
“She heard the window get busted and she called her husband and said I think somebody’s breaking in the house,” said Edsel Ballard, the woman’s father.
“He broke in through the baby’s window, ok, and when he was coming out the door, my sister was coming out her bedroom door, he aimed and shot at her first and then she shot him,” said Eddie Ballard, the woman’s brother.
The woman exchanged gunfire with the burglar, family members said, and the intruder was hit multiple times. He was taken to an Indianapolis hospital, police said. Dispatchers said the intruder was also carrying zip ties and a walkie-talkie.
DGU with no deaths. Given the walkie talkie and zip ties I’m thinking this could have gone very badly if the intruder got their way.
Man charged after opening fire, wounding several people at nightclub
Deputies said 32-year-old Jody Ray Thompson pulled out a gun after getting into an argument with another man and fired several rounds toward a crowd that had gathered out in front of the club.
“His rounds struck 3 victims, and almost struck a fourth victim, who in self-defense, pulled his own weapon and fired, striking Thompson in the leg,” Lt. Kevin Bobo said.
Man opens fire on crowd of bystanders and one of them is able to return fire, ending the shooting spree. Eventually there will be a mass shooting ending this way that the national media won’t be able to ignore.
Orwell
June 30, 2016, 4:01pm
893
I don’t think so. The media has done a good job ignoring this story, given that it happened several days ago, even while sit-ins and other protests are being held by gun control advocates in the wake of the similar FL event. The mainstream media doesn’t want to report events like this, so they don’t. I read about this event on an alternative media outlet, but haven’t heard a peep from mainstream sources.
You would surely hear about it if the second guy had hit a bystander.
Bone
July 1, 2016, 2:47pm
895
In other news, HPD: Store clerk fatally shoots suspected robber
A 25-year-old store clerk fatally shot a suspected robber inside his store, Houston police confirmed.
It happened around 9:30 a.m. Friday at 8624 W. Montgomery Road.
Police said it wasn’t immediately clear if the masked suspect was armed.
The other workers ran to the back of the store when he came in.
“I left the back room to see if he was OK, see where he was at,” Ivan Sanchez said. “And when I left the back room, and when I go out there, I see him with the robber and the robber was already lying on the floor.”
“This place has been robbed several times,” the clerk’s uncle said. “Right before Thanksgiving, they robbed him and even after he gave them everything, they still hit with him the gun.”
DGU with one death. I can’t imagine the dollar store is a high value target.
Bone
July 2, 2016, 6:32pm
896
In other news, TACO STAND EMPLOYEE FATALLY SHOOTS SUSPECT IN SOUTH LA BOTCHED ROBBERY
Three suspects tried to rob the taco stand, authorities said, and an employee ended up shooting one of the men who was 19-years-old.
The suspect was transported to Harbor-UCLA Medical Center where he later died. His name was withheld pending notification of next of kin.
The other two suspects fled on foot and remain at large, police said.
DGU with one death. 3 vs 1 and the one prevailed. They picked the wrong taco stand.
Unfortunately the article does not say whether the suspect was armed, appeared to be armed, or what threat he otherwise posed.
Other than attempting robbery. His actions were clearly unlawful. Do you wait until the suspect injures or kills someone before deciding to stop him?
You wait until the suspect poses a threat to life or limb.
A more informative article from the L.A. Daily News . FTA:
The shooting took place at San Pedro Street and West Century Boulevard about 11:30 p.m. Friday, LAPD Lt. Clint Dohmen said.
“Three men walked up to the taco stand with the intention of robbing it,” Dohmen said. “One of the men pulled out a handgun and one of the employees at the taco stand pulled out his gun and fired at the robbers.”
The would-be robber with a gun was shot and later died at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center, Dohmen said.
The clerk shot the guy with the gun, stopped shooting him when he wasn’t a threat anymore, and didn’t shoot anyone else. Better than the cops do, frankly.
Really, the fact the criminals were robbing —taking money or goods in the possession of another, from his or her person or immediate presence, by force or intimidation —should be sufficient. OTOH, the media is frequently imprecise with their descriptive language, and it wouldn’t be surprising for them to call a mere theft a robbery.